Valentine Clearance 50% Off >   Holiday Clearance 75% Off >

Personalized Shop · Weddings · New Arrivals

Win a Party at Paper Source! enter on Instagram with #myPSparty · details >

Gifts for Animal Lovers

Flying Magic Butterfly

Flying Magic Butterfly
next
Place this magic butterfly in a greeting card or book. The unsuspecting recipient will open ... Read More
10000573
$6.95

Swell Khaki Cheetah Water Bottle

Swell Khaki Cheetah Water Bottle
previous / next
The perfect water bottle for a fashionista! Tan water bottle with cheetah print detail. Keeps ... Read More
10000468
$35.95

Cat Lady Adhesive Patch

Cat Lady Adhesive Patch
previous / next
Take pride in your cat lady tendencies. Embrace your inner cat lady, and add some ... Read More
10000532
$5.95

Black Bee Coated Canvas Pouch

Black Bee Coated Canvas Pouch
previous / next
Throw this pouch in your backpack or purse to keep pencils, cash, or makeup contained! ... Read More
10000569
$14.95

Cat Head Adhesive Patch

Cat Head Adhesive Patch
previous / next
Here kitty kitty! Bring a little feline friend with you wherever you go with this ... Read More
10000531
$4.95

Doggone Fun Valentine Cards

Set of 28
Doggone Fun Valentine Cards
previous / next
Valentines for the dog-lover to send love to their friends! This set of Valentines includes ... Read More
10000102
$16.50 $8.25

Swan Journals

Set of 3
Swan Journals
previous / next
This set of swan journals features Paper Source designed artwork, 72 blank interior pages and ... Read More
523006
$14.95

Dog Lover Mug

Dog Lover Mug
previous / next
The perfect mug for the dog lover! Bold bright colors and an oversized shape make ... Read More
848404057158
$12.95

Elegant Swan Cards

Set of 12
Elegant Swan Cards
previous / next
These beautiful cards feature Paper Source exclusive swan artwork with gold foil accents. The set ... Read More
10000107
$21.95

Swan Notepad

Swan Notepad
previous / next
An elegant notepad featuring Paper Source original swan artwork. The tear away sheets allow you ... Read More
523012
$9.95

Cat Pinball Game

Cat Pinball Game
previous / next
It's a CAT-tastropy! This classic pin ball game is re-imagined as a cosmic cat galaxy. ... Read More
5055923704912
$12.95

Swan Rubber Stamp

Swan Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Bring extra elegance to your crafting projects with this classic Swan! Pair with our vibrant ... Read More
10000116
$8.95

Caturday Cat Bowl

Caturday Cat Bowl
previous / next
"Everyday is Caturday" with this cute cat bowl. The perfect size for your feline friend ... Read More
848404057424
$12.95

kate spade new york Leopard Spiral Notebook

kate spade new york Leopard Spiral Notebook
previous / next
Put a little roar in your work day, study session or laundry list of to-dos ... Read More
10000046
$14.95

Best Dog Bowl

Best Dog Bowl
previous / next
Celebrate your favorite pup with this adorable dog bowl. Bright, bold colors and an interior ... Read More
848404045254
$17.95

Crazy Cat Lady Mug

Crazy Cat Lady Mug
previous / next
The perfect mug for cat lovers! Bold bright colors and an oversized shape make this ... Read More
848404057202
$12.95

Cat Shape Trinket Dish

Cat Shape Trinket Dish
previous / next
The perfect gift for any pet lover! This cat shaped trinket dish is great for ... Read More
848404060097
$12.95

Devil Pet Tag

Devil Pet Tag
previous / next
The perfect tag for your handsome devil four legged friend! Every pet deserves a sparkly ... Read More
530583
$9.95

IQ Pet Tag

IQ Pet Tag
previous / next
This pet tag is perfect for that pet who might actually be smarter than you ... Read More
530586
$9.95

Party Pet Tag

Party Pet Tag
previous / next
The perfect pet tag for your party animal! Every pet deserves a sparkly tag to ... Read More
530585
$9.95

Queen Pet Tag

Queen Pet Tag
previous / next
Every pet deserves a sparkly tag to make them stand out from the crowd and ... Read More
530584
$9.95

Festive Furry Friends Holiday Cards

Set of 24
Festive Furry Friends Holiday Cards
previous / next
Four unique photographs, featuring two unique "Furry Friends", these cards are the perfect way to ... Read More
10000010
$18.95 $4.74

Cat Emoticons Stickers

Pack of 45
Cat Emoticons Stickers
previous / next
Get the best of two worlds with these emoticons featuring your favorite cats. Express yourself ... Read More
10000220
$2.95

Gold Foil Cats Cards

Set of 10
Gold Foil Cats Cards
previous / next
These cards featuring gold foil cats in all sorts of poses, are 100% handmade made ... Read More
807760
$14.95

Dog Emoticons Stickers

Dog Emoticons Stickers
previous / next
Get the best of two worlds with these emoticons featuring your favorite dogs. Express yourself ... Read More
10000219
$2.95

Unicorn Puffy Stickers

Unicorn Puffy Stickers
previous / next
If you believe in unicorns and all things magical then these stickers will make perfect ... Read More
10000217
$6.95

Narwhal Plush

Narwhal Plush
previous / next
Bright & magical, this narwhal plush is the perfect gift or stocking stuffer.Size - 12" ... Read More
512156
$22.95

Mini Splash Cat Plush

Mini Splash Cat Plush
previous / next
Handmade in Peru, this plush pal is made of 100% cotton and is extra soft ... Read More
530580
$44.95

Mini Toutou Dog Plush

Mini Toutou Dog Plush
previous / next
Handmade in Peru, this plush pal is made of 100% cotton and is extra soft ... Read More
530581
$44.95

Monkey Plush

Monkey Plush
previous / next
This cuddly monkey is the most fun pal in the jungle! In soft and snuggly ... Read More
670983045598
$26.95

Cats of Instagram

Cats of Instagram
previous / next
Cat lovers, rejoice! This irresistible book compiles over 400 photos from the hugely popular Instagram ... Read More
9781452151960
$16.95

Puppy Makes Mischief

Puppy Makes Mischief
previous / next
Just the present for cheeky babies, Puppy Makes Mischief is so much fun. Slide down ... Read More
670983093988
$12.50

The Dogist

The Dogist
previous / next
The Dogist is a beautiful, funny, and inspiring tribute to the beloved dogs in our ... Read More
9781579656713
$24.95

Party Animal Virtual Reality Glasses

Party Animal Virtual Reality Glasses
previous / next
Bring out your inner party animal with glasses that turn you into a cool cat, ... Read More
5037200043938
$9.95

Cat With A Red Bow Card

Cat With A Red Bow Card
previous / next
Not everyone can wake up to an adorable kitten under their tree on Christmas morning. ... Read More
012615734065
$4.49 $1.12

Bird Wine Charms

Bird Wine Charms
previous / next
Never lose your drink with these little multicolored bird wine glass markers. To use as ... Read More
440456
$8.95

Cavallini Vintage Dogs Gift Bag Set

Cavallini Vintage Dogs Gift Bag Set
previous / next
This wonderful gift wrap set lets you quickly package a gift in the most charming ... Read More
9781619921788
$13.95

Cavallini Animals Rubber Stamp Set

Cavallini Animals Rubber Stamp Set
previous / next
A set of 14 animal rubber stamps from Cavallini & Co. The adorable images will ... Read More
481231
$27.95

Cavallini Dogs Rubber Stamp Set

Set of 3
Cavallini Dogs Rubber Stamp Set
previous / next
Celebrate man's best friend with this set of dog rubber stamps featuring images from the ... Read More
462099
$14.95

Elephant Rubber Stamp

Elephant Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Bring extra cuteness to your crafting projects with this adorable Elephant! Pair with our vibrant ... Read More
871827
$8.95

Cheetah Print Rubber Stamp

Cheetah Print Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Cheetah print is the perfect way to dress up any card, place card or invitation. ... Read More
871826
$11.95

Rifle Paper Co. Birds of a Feather Journals

Set of 2
Rifle Paper Co. Birds of a Feather Journals
previous / next
These pretty notebooks have unlined pages for creative use inside. Covers feature wonderful bird artwork ... Read More
530066
$14.95

Troubles Fly Away Bird Necklace

Troubles Fly Away Bird Necklace
previous / next
Let your troubles fly away with this 14k gold plate necklace. A stylish 16 inch ... Read More
417990
$12.95

Copper Safari Animal Magnets

Set of 4
Copper Safari Animal Magnets
previous / next
Go Wild with these copper safari animal magnets! Pack of 4 magnets features a lion, ... Read More
521029
$8.95

Spoil Me Pet Tag

Spoil Me Pet Tag
previous / next
This pet tag is perfect for that pet you just can’t say no to. Every ... Read More
530587
$9.95

Unicorn Tape Dispenser

Unicorn Tape Dispenser
previous / next
Make your desk magical with this Unicorn Tape Dispenser and rainbow tape! Includes two rolls ... Read More
5037200025118
$14.95

Cavallini Insects Journals

Set of 3
Cavallini Insects Journals
previous / next
Bug out with these insect mini journals! Three mini journals packaged in one set. Features ... Read More
9781619928220
$11.95

Unicorn Hang Tags

Set of 10
Unicorn Hang Tags
previous
Make their day even more magical by embellishing their gift with a to/from unicorn gift ... Read More
4661008227
$8.95

Gifts for Animal Lovers

Adorable icons of our furry friends make the perfect gifts for dog lovers and cat lovers. These gifts for animal lovers include animal icons & other unique gift ideas. Whether you need a gift for a dog lover or a gift for a cat lover, our assortment of gift ideas will make it easy to buy for any animal lover.

Arrow pointing to top