Valentine Clearance 50% Off >   Holiday Clearance 75% Off >

Personalized Shop · Weddings · New Arrivals

Win a Party at Paper Source! enter on Instagram with #myPSparty · details >

Gifts For Sweet Tooth

Bunny Tail Gummies

Bunny Tail Gummies
next
Sugarfina Bunny Tail Gummies in sweet Easter packaging perfect for springtime baskets. Sweet and sour ... Read More
10000870
$9.95

Batman Chocolate Set

Set of 8
Batman Chocolate Set
previous / next
What happens in the Bat Cave stays in the Bat Cave. If your Valentine loves ... Read More
10000144
$9.95 $4.98

Fluffy Bunny Gummies

Fluffy Bunny Gummies
previous / next
Sugarfina Fluffy Bunny Gummies in special Easter packaging. Multi-colored fluffy bunny candies are sweet with ... Read More
10000871
$9.95

Lolli And Pops Aphrodisiac Truffles

Set of 12
Lolli And Pops Aphrodisiac Truffles
previous / next
Lolli & Pops delicious set of truffles (2 of each). Cinnamon Pine Nut, Ginger Lemon, ... Read More
10000510
$25.00 $12.50

Easter Gummy Kebab

Easter Gummy Kebab
previous / next
A stack of springtime gummy snacks pairs perfectly with all the goodies in your Easter ... Read More
521581
$4.95

Chocolate Perfect Man

Chocolate Perfect Man
previous / next
Finally, the Perfect Man. Made of solid milk chocolate, he's a sturdy hunk of man ... Read More
520127
$6.95 $3.48

Bunny Pooper

Bunny Pooper
previous / next
Looks like the Easter Bunny left a couple extra treats. This wind up bunny poops ... Read More
10000413
$6.95

Easter Junior Mints

Easter Junior Mints
previous / next
Delicious Junior Mints in pastel shades just in time for Easter! These limited edition sweet ... Read More
071720530764
$2.95

Compartes Pink Elephants Chocolate Bar

Compartes Pink Elephants Chocolate Bar
previous / next
The perfect unique gift for the chocolate lover. This dark chocolate and animal cookie chocolate ... Read More
034017442348
$10.00

Compartes Let Them Eat Cake Chocolate Bar

Compartes Let Them Eat Cake Chocolate Bar
previous / next
Let them eat cake--and chocolate! This Compartes gourmet bar is made with vanilla, fluffy delicious ... Read More
034017442249
$10.00

Compartes Cereal Bowl Chocolate Bar

Compartes Cereal Bowl Chocolate Bar
previous / next
Compartes Cereal Bowl chocolate bar is a white chocolate cereal marshmallow dream. Creamy Compartes white ... Read More
034017442096
$10.00

Sugarfina Sparkle Pops

Sugarfina Sparkle Pops
previous / next
Sugarfina's delicious Sparkle Pop Chocolates wrapped in Paper Source exclusive packaging - a match made ... Read More
10000482
$9.95

Compartes Salty Malty Chocolate

Compartes Salty Malty Chocolate
previous / next
This Compartes bar features malted milk chocolate filled with crunchy malt balls and a touch ... Read More
034017442300
$10.00

Sugarfina Peach Bellini

Sugarfina Peach Bellini
previous / next
Paper Source exclusive packaging wraps Sugarfina's all natural Peach Bellini Gummies. These gummies are filled ... Read More
10000483
$9.95

Bee-Cause Honey

12 oz.
Bee-Cause Honey
previous / next
Honey from Savannah Bee Company is perfect for you. For every Bee-Cause honey jar purchased ... Read More
10000448
$19.95

Sugarfina Large Martini Almonds

Sugarfina Large Martini Almonds
previous / next
Don't worry, there aren't any actual olives in this candy... just smartly-dressed, chocolate-covered almonds masquerading ... Read More
10000000
$19.95

Sugarfina Rosé Gummies

4 oz.
Sugarfina Rosé Gummies
previous / next
Can't get enough Rosé? This gummy is for you! Sugarfina's Rosé Gummies feature exclusive packaging ... Read More
521703
$9.95

Sugarfina Champagne Bears

3.3 oz.
Sugarfina Champagne Bears
previous / next
Infused with bubbly champagne, these sophisticated bears from Sugarfina sparkle in flavors of Brut and ... Read More
521424
$9.95

Junior Mints Peppermint Crunch

Junior Mints Peppermint Crunch
previous / next
Junior Mints with a delicious candy cane crunch addition to each chocolately bite. A festive ... Read More
071720530610
$2.95 $0.74

Merry Christmas 3 Piece Bento Box

Merry Christmas 3 Piece Bento Box
previous / next
Say happy holidays to all the wonderful people in your life with this shimmery gift ... Read More
10000032
$26.95 $6.74

Honey Spoons

Set of 6
Honey Spoons
previous / next
Perfect for flavoring any hot beverage, simply place a honey spoon in your drink, wait ... Read More
521420
$9.95

Unicorn Gum

Unicorn Gum
previous / next
Every time you chew a piece of gum, a unicorn gets its horn. Chomp on ... Read More
092657025925
$1.95

Edible Eyes

Edible Eyes
previous / next
Getting your kids to eat their veggies will be a breeze with these stick on ... Read More
520621
$9.95

Chocolate Magic Milk Straws

Set of 6
Chocolate Magic Milk Straws
previous / next
Magic Milk Straws are yummy straws filled with flavor beads that transform white milk into ... Read More
497154
$3.95

Ginger Chews

Ginger Chews
previous / next
Unlock the amazing powers of ginger in a little chew! Individually wrapped.Size - 1.5 oz. ... Read More
521418
$3.95

Bean Boozled

Bean Boozled
previous / next
Is the black jelly bean Licorice, or is it Skunk Spray? Perhaps the blue bean ... Read More
071567988612
$3.95

Star Wars Rogue One Pez Gift Tin

Star Wars Rogue One Pez Gift Tin
previous / next
The perfect gift for the Star Wars fan, the Rogue One Pez Gift Tin is ... Read More
073621906921
$19.95

Star Wars Jelly Beans

Star Wars Jelly Beans
previous / next
The Force is strong with this sparkling Galaxy Mix of jelly beans. Each bag features ... Read More
071567997768
$1.95

Heart Junior Mints

Heart Junior Mints
previous / next
Melt someone's heart with deliciously sweet heart-shaped Junior Mints. ... Read More
071720539620
$2.95 $1.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Strawberry Champagne Lollipops

Set of 4
Strawberry Champagne Lollipops
previous / next
Gourmet lollipops? Sign me up! These gourmet lollipops are flavored with champagne and are embedded ... Read More
521702
$9.95 $4.98

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Compartes California Love Chocolate Bar

Compartes California Love Chocolate Bar
previous / next
California Love by Compartes Chocolates Los Angeles. Gourmet handmade dark chocolate bar made with gourmet ... Read More
034017442065
$10.00

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Compartes Coney Island Chocolate Bar

Compartes Coney Island Chocolate Bar
previous / next
Milk chocolate filled with crispy caramelized waffle cone pieces. This Coney Island chocolate bar is ... Read More
034017442034
$10.00

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Pooping Reindeer

Pooping Reindeer
previous / next
This super dooper reindeer pooper dispenses cola-flavored jelly beans when you push down his tail. ... Read More
439378
$6.95 $1.74

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Happy Hanukkah 3 Piece Bento Box

Happy Hanukkah 3 Piece Bento Box
previous
Say Happy Hanukkah to all the wonderful people in your life with this shimmery gift ... Read More
840278123519
$26.95 $6.74

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.
Arrow pointing to top