Get it by Dec. 24th!  Order by 1pm CST Dec. 18 with Ground Shipping · See More >

$5 Ground Shipping All Orders

Excludes International

Do Something Creative Every Day

Get it by Dec. 24th! Shipping Details >

Gifts: Gifts Under $50

Gifts Under $50
Sort By:

Mrs. Claus Apron

Mrs. Claus Apron
next
Get into the Christmas spirit with this festive Mrs. Claus apron! Fun to wear all ... Read More
481241
$34.95
add to bag checkout

The Elf on the Shelf

The Elf on the Shelf
previous / next
Ever wonder how Santa really knows who is naughty or nice? Now, the biggest North ... Read More
434147
$29.95
add to bag checkout

Mason Jar Cocktail Shaker

Mason Jar Cocktail Shaker
previous / next
Make cocktails in style with this nifty Mason Jar Cocktail Shaker. Inspired by vintage Americana, ... Read More
520036
$29.95
add to bag checkout

Buff & Shine Shoe Polish Kit Navy

Buff & Shine Shoe Polish Kit Navy
previous / next
This handy dandy shoe kit comes with 2 brushes (one hard, one soft), black and ... Read More
5060121274822
$25.95
add to bag checkout

Gentleman's Wash Bag

Gentleman's Wash Bag
previous / next
The perfect gift for your man on-the-go. Faux leather detailing creates a handsome look for ... Read More
520622
$39.95
add to bag checkout

Gentleman's Wash Bag Navy

Gentleman's Wash Bag Navy
previous / next
The perfect gift for your man on-the-go. Faux leather detailing creates a handsome look for ... Read More
5060121274761
$39.95
add to bag checkout

Authentic Record Coasters

Set of 6
Authentic Record Coasters
previous / next
These vintage LP coasters will be a hit with any music lover and record collector! ... Read More
520635
$24.95
add to bag checkout

Money Clip

Money Clip
previous / next
This brass-plated money clip keeps your dough in order. Perfect for the person that wants ... Read More
520625
$22.95
add to bag checkout

Dashing Reindeer Holiday Doormat

Dashing Reindeer Holiday Doormat
previous / next
Place this dashing doormat at your door to great your holiday guests! Our exclusive dashing ... Read More
520592
$24.95
add to bag checkout

Large Roland Pine Candle

Large Roland Pine Candle
previous / next
One of the best pine candle you will ever smell, this scent is uplifting, clean ... Read More
520041
$32.95
add to bag checkout
QUICKVIEW
Custom Stamp Gift Box $39.95
Buy 1, Get 1 50% Off

Custom Stamp Gift Box

Custom Stamp Gift Box
previous / next
OUR BEST SELLING GIFT IS ON SALE!Buy one Custom Stamp Gift Box, get a second ... Read More
814753012612
$39.95
add to bag checkout
QUICKVIEW
Custom Embosser Gift Set $60.00
Paper Source Exclusive

Custom Embosser Gift Set

Custom Embosser Gift Set
previous / next
Give the gift of a custom embosser with our Embosser Gift Set. The lovely package ... Read More
40050050
$60.00
add to bag checkout

Backgammon

Backgammon
previous / next
Enjoy the classic game of Backgammon with this retro-inspired version with sophisticated style. A great ... Read More
5060121271333
$29.95 $20.97
add to bag checkout

Kate Spade Gold Dot Pencil Pouch

Kate Spade Gold Dot Pencil Pouch
previous / next
Keep your pens and pencils tucked neatly inside this charming patent leatherette pouch for easy ... Read More
825466929562
$29.95
add to bag checkout

Kate Spade Office Kit

Kate Spade Office Kit
previous / next
This chic office set is the perfect gift for a recent graduate or to congratulate ... Read More
825466929630
$39.95
add to bag checkout

Rewined Pinot Noir Candle

Rewined Pinot Noir Candle
previous / next
This earthy, complex wine scent mimics the ground that produces it. Fresh fig and cranberry, ... Read More
520623
$29.95
add to bag checkout

Rewined Cider Candle

Rewined Cider Candle
previous / next
Fill your space with the warm and cozy scent of this fall favorite that offers ... Read More
520624
$29.95
add to bag checkout

Large Pomegranate Spruce Candle

Large Pomegranate Spruce Candle
previous / next
This Paddywax signature soy wax candle is scented with a festive winter pomegranate spruce fragrance. ... Read More
647658111575
$21.95
add to bag checkout

Corkcicle Wine Chiller

Corkcicle Wine Chiller
previous / next
Corkcicle keeps your wines at just the right drinking temperatures. Place inside a bottle, and ... Read More
440349
$17.95
add to bag checkout

Chillsner Beer Chiller

Chillsner Beer Chiller
previous / next
Keep your beer cool with this awesome beer bottle chiller. The frozen wand slides into ... Read More
519519
$29.95
add to bag checkout

Love You More Picture Frame

Love You More Picture Frame
previous / next
This striking picture frame looks like a distressed wooden box painted with the message, Love ... Read More
519156
$24.95
add to bag checkout

Happy Place Decorative Box Sign

Happy Place Decorative Box Sign
previous / next
Take in the sea breeze with this white-wash decorative sign. Features painted wood and bold ... Read More
519356
$26.95
add to bag checkout

Paper Source Color Pop Plates

Set of 4
Paper Source Color Pop Plates
previous / next
Our exclusive color pop plates feature colorful artwork that will brighten your summer! Made of ... Read More
520346
$24.95 $12.48
add to bag checkout
QUICKVIEW
Paper Source Color Pop Glasses Set of 4 $22.95 $11.48
As seen in HGTV Magazine

Paper Source Color Pop Glasses

Set of 4
Paper Source Color Pop Glasses
previous / next
New! Juice glasses so fab and colorful they'll be the only ones you ever use. ... Read More
520347
$22.95 $11.48
add to bag checkout

Pink Tool Set

Pink Tool Set
previous / next
Functional and chic, this tool set is the perfect gift for the recent grad or ... Read More
817341012582
$29.95
add to bag checkout

Garden Tool Kit

Garden Tool Kit
previous / next
These garden tools are just as pretty as your flowers. Includes a hand trowel and ... Read More
520352
$39.95 $19.98
add to bag checkout

Rifle Recipe Box

Rifle Recipe Box
previous / next
A vintage-inspired tin recipe box that is as delightful as your culinary creations. Comes with ... Read More
519515
$34.95
add to bag checkout

Chevron Burlap Tote

Chevron Burlap Tote
previous / next
This jute/cotton blend carry-all features a stylish chevron print. Inside zipper pouch and magnetic closure.Size ... Read More
520222
$26.95
add to bag checkout
QUICKVIEW
New! Rifle Clear Floral Lace iPhone Case $36.95
iPhone 5/5s $36.95
iPhone 6 $36.95
add to bag checkout

Rifle Clear Floral Lace iPhone Case

Rifle Clear Floral Lace iPhone Case
previous / next
This beautiful iPhone case will instantly dress up your phone! The clear hard case is ... Read More
520675
$36.95
iPhone 5/5s $36.95
iPhone 6 $36.95
add to bag checkout

Mint Confetti iPhone 5 Cover

Mint Confetti iPhone 5 Cover
previous / next
Carry your phone in style with this Paper Source exclusive iPhone 5 case in festive ... Read More
520381
$29.95
add to bag checkout

Pink Triangles iPhone 5 Cover

Pink Triangles iPhone 5 Cover
previous / next
Carry your phone in style with this Paper Source exclusive iPhone case in fuchsia with ... Read More
520382
$29.95
add to bag checkout

Cats iPhone 5 Case

Cats iPhone 5 Case
previous / next
Your phone will be the cat's meow with our adorable iPhone cover. This hard case ... Read More
520672
$29.95
add to bag checkout

Paper Source Donuts iPhone Cover

iPhone 5
Paper Source Donuts iPhone Cover
previous / next
Add unique style to your smartphone with our wonderfully festive donuts iPhone case. Slim hard ... Read More
520086
$29.95
add to bag checkout

Obsessive Chef Cutting Board

Obsessive Chef Cutting Board
previous / next
Become a gourmet cook with the Obsessive Chef beech wood cutting board. Serve up impressive, ... Read More
416686
$26.95
add to bag checkout

Woodland Cheese Board

Woodland Cheese Board
previous / next
A sweet wooden cheese board with etched branches, flowers and woodland animals. Fun for entertaining, ... Read More
519777
$22.95
add to bag checkout

Paper Source Moss Perpetual Calendar

Paper Source Moss Perpetual Calendar
previous / next
This spiral calendar will keep your weekly tasks well organized. The perpetual calendar format lets ... Read More
479223
$29.95
add to bag checkout

Vintage Marquis Custom Stamp - PS design

Vintage Marquis Custom Stamp - PS design
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
479006
$29.95 - $39.95
get more info

Ampersand Custom Stamp - PS design

Ampersand Custom Stamp - PS design
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
479007
$29.95 - $39.95
get more info

Circle Monogram Custom Stamp

Circle Monogram Custom Stamp
previous / next
Our self-inking stamps are an easy way to add your return address to envelopes. Just ... Read More
478124
$29.95 - $39.95
get more info

Initial Script Over Banner Custom Stamp - PS design

Initial Script Over Banner Custom Stamp - PS design
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
479065
$29.95 - $39.95
get more info

Wonder Woman Apron

Wonder Woman Apron
previous / next
This apron is perfect for the wonderful woman in your life! Features adjustable ties in ... Read More
511184
$24.95
add to bag checkout

Superman Apron

Superman Apron
previous / next
Your man of steel may not don a cape, but he'll sure look buff wearing ... Read More
511185
$24.95
add to bag checkout

Ogo Sport Beach Game

Ogo Sport Beach Game
previous / next
Beach time gets even better with the Ogo Sport FORA game. Each disk has a ... Read More
519525
$29.95
add to bag checkout

Cubebot Wooden Robot

Cubebot Wooden Robot
previous / next
The hardwood frame of this Cubebot Robot strikes many poses. Features elastic band muscles and ... Read More
511264
$24.95
add to bag checkout

Lucia Votive Candle Set

Set of 4
Lucia Votive Candle Set
previous / next
These beautifully packaged scented organic soy candles burn cleanly for over 15 hours. Features lindseed ... Read More
519271
$26.95
add to bag checkout

True Friends Tray

True Friends Tray
previous / next
This colorful ceramic tray features the wonderful message: True friends are hard to find and ... Read More
520106
$24.95
add to bag checkout

Kelvin Multi-Purpose Tool

Kelvin Multi-Purpose Tool
previous / next
The Kelvin Multi-Purpose Tool is a unique, super functional hand tool designed for everyday jobs. ... Read More
519604
$36.95
add to bag checkout

Wallies Chalkborder Peel & Stick Border

Wallies Chalkborder Peel & Stick Border
previous
With over 6 feet of removable, repositionable peel and stick chalkboard, kids can finally write ... Read More
519081
$21.95
add to bag checkout