Valentine Clearance 50% Off >   Holiday Clearance 75% Off >

Personalized Shop · Weddings · New Arrivals

Flash Sale! 50% Off Select Gifts  · while supplies last ·

Holiday Gifts

Melting Snowman Putty

Melting Snowman Putty
next
Mold this white putty into a tiny snowman with hat, eyes, scarf and arms. Then ... Read More
526805
$14.95 $3.74
Magnetic Display System

Magnetic Display System

$14.95

Perfect Way To Display Holiday Cards

Magnetic Display System

Magnetic Display System
previous / next
Display your photos, prints, posters and more up to 24" x 36" with the GoodHangups ... Read More
030915328883
$14.95

LED Twinkle Lights

LED Twinkle Lights
previous / next
These twinkly LED bulbs are attached to a bendable wire that easily takes shape and ... Read More
520557
$12.95

Junior Mints Peppermint Crunch

Junior Mints Peppermint Crunch
previous / next
Junior Mints with a delicious candy cane crunch addition to each chocolately bite. A festive ... Read More
071720530610
$2.95 $0.74

Sugarfina Champagne Bears

3.3 oz.
Sugarfina Champagne Bears
previous / next
Infused with bubbly champagne, these sophisticated bears from Sugarfina sparkle in flavors of Brut and ... Read More
521424
$9.95

Red & White Paper Straws

Set of 144
Red & White Paper Straws
previous / next
These retro red and white paper straws made from bio-degradable paper add stylish detail to ... Read More
479554
$6.95

Fake Snowballs

Set of 6
Fake Snowballs
previous / next
Winter play is easy with these faux snowballs that won't ever melt. Specially designed to ... Read More
520568
$10.95 $2.74

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Pooping Reindeer

Pooping Reindeer
previous / next
This super dooper reindeer pooper dispenses cola-flavored jelly beans when you push down his tail. ... Read More
439378
$6.95 $1.74

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Fancy Fold Napkins

Set of 12
Fancy Fold Napkins
previous
No one will want to get their fingers dirty when you set the table with ... Read More
877933006672
$12.95 $6.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Holiday Gifts Galore

The Paper Source collection of holiday gifts has been specially curated to help you find all of the presents you need. Start a holiday tradition with an elf on a shelf or bring in the new year with champaign flavored bears. We have gifts for every holiday this season including Christmas gifts, Hanukkah gifts, New Year's gifts, and more.

Arrow pointing to top