Valentine Clearance 50% Off >   Holiday Clearance 75% Off >

Fine Paper Sale · Weddings · New Arrivals

Win a Party at Paper Source! enter on Instagram with #myPSparty · details >

Stocking Stuffers

Chocolate Magic Milk Straws

Set of 6
Chocolate Magic Milk Straws
next
Magic Milk Straws are yummy straws filled with flavor beads that transform white milk into ... Read More
497154
$3.95

Ginger Chews

Ginger Chews
previous / next
Unlock the amazing powers of ginger in a little chew! Individually wrapped.Size - 1.5 oz. ... Read More
521418
$3.95

What I Love About You Journal

What I Love About You Journal
previous / next
The perfect gift for your sweetheart, fill in the blanks and this journal becomes something ... Read More
519279
$10.00

What I Love About Mom Journal

What I Love About Mom Journal
previous / next
We love this creative way to tell your mom why you love her. This fill-in-the-blank ... Read More
825703500653
$10.00

What I Love About Dad

What I Love About Dad
previous / next
We love this creative way to tell Dad why you love him. This fill-in-the-blank book ... Read More
825703500714
$10.00

Fifty Farts Cards

Fifty Farts Cards
previous / next
A fabulously funny deck of cards about flatuosity. From the snart to the rump roast, ... Read More
519021
$9.95

Gold Technology Decals

Pack of 100
Gold Technology Decals
previous / next
Bling out your phone with these glam decals. With over 100 geometric decals to choose ... Read More
9781452138114
$9.95 $4.98

Star Wars Jelly Beans

Star Wars Jelly Beans
previous / next
The Force is strong with this sparkling Galaxy Mix of jelly beans. Each bag features ... Read More
071567997768
$1.95

Emoji Stickers

Pack of 288
Emoji Stickers
previous / next
Add emoji-tion to your crafts with an assortment of your favorite emoji stickers that look ... Read More
616913652160
$6.95

Dammit Doll

Dammit Doll
previous / next
For those days when nothing goes right and you just want to hit the wall, ... Read More
455263
$14.95

Fruit Erasers

Set of 8
Fruit Erasers
previous / next
Kids and adults love these fruit erasers! Comes with 8 fruit puzzle erasers (cherries, bananas, ... Read More
4991685201249
$7.95

Rifle Paper Co. Clear Floral Lace iPhone Case

Rifle Paper Co. Clear Floral Lace iPhone Case
previous / next
This beautiful iPhone case will instantly dress up your phone! The clear hard case is ... Read More
520675
$36.95
iPhone 6 $36.95

Car Vent Phone Mount

Car Vent Phone Mount
previous / next
Go hands-free with a portable air vent phone holder with no slip grip. Expands to ... Read More
612615075740
$5.95

Color Cable Ties

Set of 8
Color Cable Ties
previous / next
Organize your computer and game console cables with our set of 8 color-coded ties.Size - ... Read More
612615071254
$5.95

On The Go Game Pad

On The Go Game Pad
previous / next
This paper pad will keep you occupied until the bus arrives or the movie starts…a ... Read More
520033
$11.95

Edible Eyes

Edible Eyes
previous / next
Getting your kids to eat their veggies will be a breeze with these stick on ... Read More
520621
$9.95

Tutti Frutti Scented Gel Pens

Set 6
Tutti Frutti Scented Gel Pens
previous / next
A fruit bowl of yummy scents, these glitter gel pens make doodling delicious! Enjoy sweet ... Read More
511087
$8.95

Sweet Talk Pens

Set of 3
Sweet Talk Pens
previous / next
Have fun jotting notes with these bright pens. Colors include: Blush, Perfect Pink and Mermaid. ... Read More
825466928282
$14.95

Flying Wish Paper

Flying Wish Paper
previous / next
Write it and light it! Send your wish off into the world with this whimsical ... Read More
520462
$11.95

Food Fun Chip Clips

Set of 6
Food Fun Chip Clips
previous / next
Set of six bright and colorful painted wooden chip clips with tiny flowers and funny, ... Read More
614390340235
$19.95

Cube Mighty Magnets - Set of 12

Set of 12
Cube Mighty Magnets - Set of 12
previous / next
These tiny, 3/16" cube chromed mighties are amazingly powerful magnets, perfect for holding photos and ... Read More
409152
$15.95

Mini Neon Cubebot

Mini Neon Cubebot
previous / next
The hardwood frame of the Cubebot Robot now comes in a miniature size and fantastic ... Read More
520458
$11.95

Cavallini San Francisco Eraser

Cavallini San Francisco Eraser
previous / next
Keep San Francisco close at hand with this wonderful eraser. The high quality soft rubber ... Read More
511282
$4.00

Cavallini New York Eraser

Cavallini New York Eraser
previous / next
Keep NYC close at hand with this fabulous eraser. The high quality soft rubber eraser ... Read More
511281
$4.00

Cavallini Vintage Paris Pencil Tin

Set of 10
Cavallini Vintage Paris Pencil Tin
previous / next
... Read More
9781619921900
$12.95

Wine Glass Writers

Set of 3
Wine Glass Writers
previous / next
A fun way to keep track of your wine glass. Simply write your name on ... Read More
0609722450386
$9.95

Bean Boozled

Bean Boozled
previous / next
Is the black jelly bean Licorice, or is it Skunk Spray? Perhaps the blue bean ... Read More
071567988612
$3.95

Unicorn Gum

Unicorn Gum
previous / next
Every time you chew a piece of gum, a unicorn gets its horn. Chomp on ... Read More
092657025925
$1.95

Prismacolor Colored Pencils

Set of 12
Prismacolor Colored Pencils
previous / next
From simple sketches to complex creations, these premium colored pencils and leads have you covered ... Read More
00070735035967
$22.95

Melting Birthday Cake

Melting Birthday Cake
previous / next
Celebrate your birthday over and over again! Make a birthday cake without all the mess! ... Read More
019218204681
$14.95

Pinch Photo Memo Holder

Set of 9
Pinch Photo Memo Holder
previous / next
These cute clothespins are attached to mixed length rods with adhesive ends. Add depth to ... Read More
028295408776
$15.95

Penguin Popper

Penguin Popper
previous / next
Most penguins waddle, but this one POPS! Simply load the soft foam balls into the ... Read More
605168543705
$12.95 $3.24

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Fake Snowballs

Set of 6
Fake Snowballs
previous / next
Winter play is easy with these faux snowballs that won't ever melt. Specially designed to ... Read More
520568
$10.95 $2.74

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Deer Bust Head Plush

Deer Bust Head Plush
previous / next
This quirky reindeer plush is a fun way to spruce up any room! This adorable ... Read More
636997225265
$26.95 $6.74

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Pocket Multi-Tool Pliers

Pocket Multi-Tool Pliers
previous / next
This multi-tool is everything you need all in one! Includes pliers, a knife, file and ... Read More
5060121272460
$17.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Hands Free Walkie Talkies

Hands Free Walkie Talkies
previous / next
Be super sneaky with this great hands-free walkie talkie. Push to talk antennas allow you ... Read More
035594039891
$19.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Pocket Manicure Tool

Pocket Manicure Tool
previous / next
Every gadget you could ask for is part of the Pocket Manicure Tool! Packaged in ... Read More
5060121269125
$21.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Cactus Tube Puzzle

Cactus Tube Puzzle
previous / next
Paper Source designed miniature puzzle in a giftable tube perfect as a stocking stuffer! 150 ... Read More
530558
$7.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Swell Pink Water Bottle

Swell Pink Water Bottle
previous / next
There's no better way to keep your drink cold or hot than this Pink Swell ... Read More
639725841010
$25.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Pooping Reindeer

Pooping Reindeer
previous / next
This super dooper reindeer pooper dispenses cola-flavored jelly beans when you push down his tail. ... Read More
439378
$6.95 $1.74

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

XL Braided iPhone Cord

XL Braided iPhone Cord
previous / next
This sturdy extra long phone charger is cute and practical with a black and white ... Read More
612615080331
$19.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Compartes Coney Island Chocolate Bar

Compartes Coney Island Chocolate Bar
previous / next
Milk chocolate filled with crispy caramelized waffle cone pieces. This Coney Island chocolate bar is ... Read More
034017442034
$10.00

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Plot Twist Bookmark

Plot Twist Bookmark
previous / next
Beautiful blush vegan leather bookmark features this fun saying "When something goes wrong in your ... Read More
636225776613
$8.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Fur Pom Keychain - Wine

Fur Pom Keychain - Wine
previous / next
Never lose your keys with these fun and furry pom keychains! This wine colored pom ... Read More
636225755656
$6.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Fur Pom Keychain - Tan

Fur Pom Keychain - Tan
previous / next
Never lose your keys with these fun and furry pom keychains! This lightly colored pom ... Read More
636225755601
$6.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Emoji Pencil Case

Emoji Pencil Case
previous / next
This bright pencil case features a quirky emoji print and is perfect for all your ... Read More
815498021846
$14.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

The Take-A-Part Plane by Toysmith

The Take-A-Part Plane by Toysmith
previous / next
Put it together or take it apart! The Take-A-Part Plane is a breakable toy that ... Read More
85761219922
$4.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Canvas Christmas Stocking

Canvas Christmas Stocking
previous
A great way to personalize your home for the holidays! This canvas stocking can be ... Read More
900475
$12.95 $3.24

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.
Arrow pointing to top