Valentine Clearance 50% Off >   Holiday Clearance 75% Off >

Personalized Shop · Weddings · New Arrivals

Win a Party at Paper Source! enter on Instagram with #myPSparty · details >

Valentine's Day Crafts

White Chalk Ink Marker

White Chalk Ink Marker
next
For a school-inspired look without the mess, write on chalkboards, plastic, glass and metal with ... Read More
890085001869
$5.95

Erasable Chalk Markers

Set of 3
Erasable Chalk Markers
previous / next
This set of bright, erasable chalk markers are a must-have for anyone with a craft ... Read More
718813699068
$10.95

Be Mine Decorative Paper Pad

6" x 6"
Be Mine Decorative Paper Pad
previous / next
This lovable pack includes 24 sheets of decorative paper for your card making and DIY ... Read More
699464193573
$4.48

Heart 1" Punch

Heart 1
previous / next
Punch out heart shapes to your heart's content! This easy punch creates 1" heart shapes ... Read More
475894
$14.95
Red & White Baker's Twine

Red & White Baker's Twine

500 yards

$7.95

As seen in Family Circle Magazine

Red & White Baker's Twine

500 yards
Red & White Baker's Twine
previous / next
This generous half pound roll of baker's twine offers plenty of material for your crafts, ... Read More
442655
$7.95

Cavallini Love Rubber Stamp Set

Set of 15
Cavallini Love Rubber Stamp Set
previous / next
These assorted wooden rubber stamps feature charming hearts, love birds and sweet words of love. ... Read More
876442
$14.95

Love Script Rubber Stamp

Love Script Rubber Stamp
previous / next
The sweeping script on this stamp will add charm to all your Valentine's Day projects. ... Read More
871812
$7.95

Love You More Rubber Stamp

Love You More Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Show some love with this simple message that means so much. Use bright, bold inkpad ... Read More
871727
$7.95

Glasses Rubber Stamp

Glasses Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Quirky and fun, these eyeglasses are great to stamp onto invitations, cards, gift tags and ... Read More
871695
$5.95

Flourish Heart Rubber Stamp

Flourish Heart Rubber Stamp
previous / next
This whimsical heart stamp will add style to Valentine's, stationery, even wedding place cards and ... Read More
439278
$12.50

Hearts Pattern Rubber Stamp

Hearts Pattern Rubber Stamp
previous / next
This clever rubber stamp allows you to stamp borders and repeated patterns with ease. Stamp ... Read More
871425
$11.95

Medium Solid Heart Rubber Stamp

Medium Solid Heart Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Nothing says love better than a heart and we're sure this regular heart will look ... Read More
871582
$6.95

Small Solid Heart Rubber Stamp

Small Solid Heart Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Nothing says love better than a heart and we're sure this tiny heart will look ... Read More
871583
$5.95

Heart Mini Rubber Stamp

Heart Mini Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Express your love with our heart rubber stamps. Our Mini Heart Rubber Stamp is oh ... Read More
800188
$4.75

You're My Cup of Coffee Rubber Stamp

You're My Cup of Coffee Rubber Stamp
previous / next
This great handcrafted coffee cup stamp lets you tell someone just how special you think ... Read More
085700901871
$8.95

Large Rose Outline Rubber Stamp

Large Rose Outline Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Our large rose outline rubber stamp will bring the most recognizable perennial to your paper ... Read More
871540
$6.95

Hedgehog Rubber Stamp

Hedgehog Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Our happy hedgehog rubber stamp is sure to play nice on all your paper projects.Impression ... Read More
871618
$5.95

Paper Bag 4 Bar Heart Card

Paper Bag 4 Bar Heart Card
previous / next
Our little heart shaped cards are perfectly sized to fit into 4 Bar envelopes. Turn ... Read More
3434402301
$6.95 - $7.50

Red Sealing Wax

3 pack
Red Sealing Wax
previous / next
The old world's first security system - if the seal on your letter was broken ... Read More
411684
$7.50

Peacock 4 Bar Heart Card

20 pack
Peacock 4 Bar Heart Card
previous / next
Our little heart shaped cards are perfectly sized to fit into 4 Bar envelopes. Turn ... Read More
3434452301
$6.25 $3.13

Luxe Blush 4 Bar Heart Card

Luxe Blush 4 Bar Heart Card
previous / next
Our little heart shaped cards are perfectly sized to fit into 4 Bar envelopes. Turn ... Read More
3505442301
$6.95 - $7.50

Black and White Washi Tapes

Set of 3
Black and White Washi Tapes
previous / next
Add an adorable touch to your cards and projects with the black and white washi ... Read More
900021
$9.95

Incredibly Awesome Cellophane Bags

Set of 20
Incredibly Awesome Cellophane Bags
previous / next
Fill these festive food-safe cellophane bags with fun goodies and treats for family and friends. ... Read More
48668574
$6.95

Heart Tissue Garland

Set of 2
Heart Tissue Garland
previous / next
This heart tissue garland is great way to add easy Valentine's Day flair to your ... Read More
521434
$4.95 $2.48

Bear with Heart Rubber Stamp

Bear with Heart Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Some things are even cuter when they're miniature. This bear is irresistible - send a ... Read More
871304
$5.50

Unicorn Rubber Stamp

Unicorn Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Dare to dream about unicorns, because now you have proof they're real! This magical stamp ... Read More
871794
$8.95

Hashtag Rubber Stamp

Hashtag Rubber Stamp
previous / next
This rubber stamp is #TheGreatest! Include a touch of pop culture in any of your ... Read More
871806
$4.95

Valentine Mailing Craft Kit

Set of 24
Valentine Mailing Craft Kit
previous / next
Add some DIY to your Valentines this year! This charming Valentine's Day mailing set has ... Read More
10000381
$24.95 $12.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Puppies & Kittens Valentine Craft Kit

Puppies & Kittens Valentine Craft Kit
previous / next
Send sweet greetings with these furry friends! Our puppy and kitten cards are irresistible and ... Read More
4071295711
$19.95 $9.98

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Lip Rubber Stamp

Lip Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Add a kiss to your Valentines without messing up your lipstick. This stamp is great ... Read More
10000115
$6.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Heart Shapes Pack

Pack of 10
Heart Shapes Pack
previous / next
Show someone you care with a large, homemade heart valentine! This pack includes assorted colors ... Read More
10000402
$7.95 $3.98

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Solid Washi Tape Set

Set of 5
Solid Washi Tape Set
previous / next
Adorn your planners, calendars, cards, and envelopes with this elegant Paper Source custom washi set. ... Read More
10000205
$19.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Gold Craft Knife

Gold Craft Knife
previous / next
This gold craft knife is a great for precise cutting and curvy designs, and has ... Read More
10000247
$6.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Love You to the Moon and Back Rubber Stamp

Love You to the Moon and Back Rubber Stamp
previous / next
A tiny reminder of your boundless love and affection. Use this stamp to create homemade ... Read More
10000112
$8.95 $4.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

XOXO Gold Foil Hang Tags

Set of 10
XOXO Gold Foil Hang Tags
previous / next
Use this set of 10 gift tags, with gold foil lettering on blush background to ... Read More
10000151
$9.95 $4.98

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Heart Day Stickers

Pack of 94
Heart Day Stickers
previous / next
This pack of stickers makes it easy to personalize hand made Valentine's, embellish scrapbook pages, ... Read More
10000422
$5.95 $2.98

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Spectacular Glasses Valentine Craft Kit

Spectacular Glasses Valentine Craft Kit
previous / next
Show friends you only have eyes for them by sending these sweet specs for Valentine's ... Read More
4071295709
$19.95 $9.98

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Puffy Character Heart Stickers

Set of 50
Puffy Character Heart Stickers
previous / next
These cute little heart stickers come with a variety of faces and expressions! Use to ... Read More
10000421
$4.95 $2.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

A7 Heart Cards

Pack of 21
A7 Heart Cards
previous / next
Make someone's day with a homemade, brightly colored heart valentine! A great canvas for you ... Read More
10000401
$10.50 $5.25

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Black Glitter Script Large Alphabet Stickers

Black Glitter Script Large Alphabet Stickers
previous / next
These large alphabet stickers really know how to make a statement! Perfect for school projects, ... Read More
10000215
$8.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Happy Valentine's Day with Hearts Rubber Stamp

Happy Valentine's Day with Hearts Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Perfect for making homemade Valentines cards, decorating envelopes, tags, treat bags and more! Designed right ... Read More
10000110
$6.95 $3.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Saturday Notepad

Saturday Notepad
previous / next
In a perfect world, everyday would be Saturday. Use this pad to write down your ... Read More
10000191
$6.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Rose Gold Metallic Marker

Rose Gold Metallic Marker
previous / next
Medium Tip Galaxy Markers are renowned for their smooth rich colors and top quality archival ... Read More
10000228
$2.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Heart Paper Garland

Heart Paper Garland
previous / next
This garland has die-cut heart shapes in magenta and red printed papers. The Lokta paper ... Read More
10000599
$9.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Love Heart Garland

Love Heart Garland
previous / next
Get the conversation going! Decorate for Valentine's Day with our Conversation Heart Garland featuring mini ... Read More
10000476
$10.95 $5.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Plantable Hearts

Plantable Hearts
previous / next
These adorable handmade paper hearts are embedded with the seeds of wildflower annuals and perennials. ... Read More
491665
$8.95 $4.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Raffia Pink Ribbon

Raffia Pink Ribbon
previous / next
Recipients will ooh and ahh upon seeing their gifts wrapped in Synthetic Raffia Ribbon. This ... Read More
713058276258
$9.95 $4.98

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

XOXO Paper Pad

XOXO Paper Pad
previous
A Paper Source exclusive from My Mind's Eye, this awesome 6" x 6" decorative paper ... Read More
699464206486
$7.95 $3.98

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.
Arrow pointing to top