$5 Ground Shipping Sitewide!

excludes international/ends July 28

Do Something Creative Every Day

New & Seasonal: Valentine Crafts

Valentine Crafts
Sort By:

Peony Wreath Kit

Peony Wreath Kit
next
These pretty peonies are the pick of the season! Adorn your door or decorate your ... Read More
4071295648
$21.95
add to bag checkout

Nautical Sailboat Kit

Nautical Sailboat Kit
previous / next
Ships Ahoy! Sail into your next summer gathering with these colorful boats in tow. Whether ... Read More
4071295652
$12.50
add to bag checkout

Nautical Garland Kit

Nautical Garland Kit
previous / next
Ahoy Mates! Let this nautical garland be the anchor of your next party. Perfect for ... Read More
4071295651
$12.50
add to bag checkout

Valentine Heart Garland

Valentine Heart Garland
previous / next
Hearts will go aflutter with this easy to make Valentine’s Day garland. Hang in your ... Read More
4071295642
$10.95
add to bag checkout

Donuts Garland Kit

Donuts Garland Kit
previous / next
Playful donuts look so sweet strung together as a garland! A fun party decoration your ... Read More
4071295686
$12.50
add to bag checkout
QUICKVIEW
Hedgehogs Valentine Card Kit $19.95
As seen in Better Homes and Gardens
add to bag checkout

Hedgehogs Valentine Card Kit

Hedgehogs Valentine Card Kit
previous / next
Give special hedge-hugs this Valentine’s Day with cute and easy to make hedgehogs! Kit makes ... Read More
4071295644
$19.95
add to bag checkout

Valentine Cupcakes Kit

Valentine Cupcakes Kit
previous / next
Make Valentine's Day sweeter with these special cupcake treats that are fun to decorate and ... Read More
4071295677
$14.95
add to bag checkout

Owls Valentine Card Kit

Owls Valentine Card Kit
previous / next
Our delightful owls are back for Valentines Day - ready for you to share with ... Read More
4071295643
$18.95
add to bag checkout

Ombré Valentine Hearts Kit

Ombré Valentine Hearts Kit
previous / next
Make beautiful ombré style pink and red valentine cards with our festive kit. Kit makes ... Read More
4071295680
$19.95
add to bag checkout
QUICKVIEW
Valentine Pinwheels Kit $21.95 $10.98
add to bag checkout

Valentine Pinwheels Kit

Valentine Pinwheels Kit
previous / next
These cute paper pinwheel Valentines are easy to make, fun to twirl, and sweet to ... Read More
4071295645
$21.95 $10.98
add to bag checkout
QUICKVIEW
A7 Heart Shapes Pack Set of 20 $9.95
add to bag checkout

A7 Heart Shapes Pack

Set of 20
A7 Heart Shapes Pack
previous / next
Use these adorable A7 heart cards to make homemade Valentines cards, decorations and crafts. Fits ... Read More
3905129905
$9.95
add to bag checkout
QUICKVIEW
Chalkboard 4 Bar Heart Cards Set of 10 $9.95 $4.98
add to bag checkout

Chalkboard 4 Bar Heart Cards

Set of 10
Chalkboard 4 Bar Heart Cards
previous / next
These heart shaped cards have a unique chalkboard finish so you can write love notes ... Read More
3813752301
$9.95 $4.98
add to bag checkout
QUICKVIEW
Mini Clothespins - Red 25 Pack $2.50
add to bag checkout

Mini Clothespins - Red

25 Pack
Mini Clothespins - Red
previous / next
The same mini clothespins you know and love but this time in red...great for holiday! ... Read More
440041
$2.50
add to bag checkout
QUICKVIEW
White Mini Clothespins Pack of 25 $2.50
add to bag checkout

White Mini Clothespins

Pack of 25
White Mini Clothespins
previous / next
Tiny clothespins that do big work! Such a fun way to display anything around your ... Read More
843094021434
$2.50
add to bag checkout

Heart 1" Punch

Heart 1
previous / next
Punch out heart shapes to your heart's content! This easy punch creates 1" heart shapes ... Read More
475894
$14.95
add to bag checkout
QUICKVIEW
Red & White Paper Straws Set of 144 $6.95
add to bag checkout

Red & White Paper Straws

Set of 144
Red & White Paper Straws
previous / next
These retro red and white paper straws made from bio-degradable paper add stylish detail to ... Read More
479554
$6.95
add to bag checkout
QUICKVIEW
Red & White Baker's Twine 500 yards $7.95
add to bag checkout

Red & White Baker's Twine

500 yards
Red & White Baker's Twine
previous / next
This generous half pound roll of baker's twine offers plenty of material for your crafts, ... Read More
442655
$7.95
add to bag checkout

Red and White Twill Ribbon

10 yards
Red and White Twill Ribbon
previous / next
A wonderful cotton twill ribbon for gift wrapping or embellishing cards and invitations. A modern ... Read More
46522401
$7.50
add to bag checkout

Red & Ivory Stripe Cotton Ribbon

5 yards
Red & Ivory Stripe Cotton Ribbon
previous / next
A wonderful cotton ribbon for gift wrapping or embellishing cards and invitations. Classic red stripes ... Read More
497622
$6.50
add to bag checkout

Fuchsia Ric Rac Grosgrain Ribbon

10 yards
Fuchsia Ric Rac Grosgrain Ribbon
previous / next
Embellish wrapped packages, cards and crafts with extra wide grosgrain ric rac ribbon. In bright ... Read More
432402
$12.95
add to bag checkout
QUICKVIEW
Red Ric Rac Ribbon 10 yards $5.95
add to bag checkout

Red Ric Rac Ribbon

10 yards
Red Ric Rac Ribbon
previous / next
A spool of adorable red ric rac that is fun for gift wrapping, card making ... Read More
481900
$5.95
add to bag checkout
QUICKVIEW
Red Adhesive Crystals 68 pack $2.95
add to bag checkout

Red Adhesive Crystals

68 pack
Red Adhesive Crystals
previous / next
Bright, brilliant red adhesive crystals are the fastest, easiest way to add dimension, sparkle and ... Read More
457298
$2.95
add to bag checkout

Love & Hugs Rubber Stamp

Love & Hugs Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Create magical Valentine's Day crafts and cards or spread love and hugs throughout the year ... Read More
871584
$7.95
add to bag checkout

Hearts Pattern Rubber Stamp

Hearts Pattern Rubber Stamp
previous / next
This clever rubber stamp allows you to stamp borders and repeated patterns with ease. Stamp ... Read More
871425
$11.95
add to bag checkout

Medium Solid Heart Rubber Stamp

Medium Solid Heart Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Nothing says love better than a heart and we're sure this regular heart will look ... Read More
871582
$6.95
add to bag checkout

Small Solid Heart Rubber Stamp

Small Solid Heart Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Nothing says love better than a heart and we're sure this tiny heart will look ... Read More
871583
$5.95
add to bag checkout

Heart Mini Rubber Stamp

Heart Mini Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Express your love with our heart rubber stamps. Our Mini Heart Rubber Stamp is oh ... Read More
800188
$4.75
add to bag checkout

Bear with Heart Rubber Stamp

Bear with Heart Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Some things are even cuter when they're miniature. This bear is irresistible - send a ... Read More
871304
$5.50
add to bag checkout

Macaron Stack Rubber Stamp

Macaron Stack Rubber Stamp
previous / next
This stack of three French macarons will add a sweet finishing touch to any craft ... Read More
871651
$7.95
add to bag checkout

Macaron Rubber Stamp

Macaron Rubber Stamp
previous / next
A delightful French macaron rubber stamp for the most delicious handmade crafts.Size - 1 3/4" ... Read More
871650
$4.95
add to bag checkout

Lips Large Rubber Stamp

Lips Large Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Seal it with a kiss. Use our large Lips Rubber Stamps to decorate envelopes, note ... Read More
804570
$6.95
add to bag checkout

Love Postage Rubber Stamp

Love Postage Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Love will keep us together! Stamp your cards, stationery, gifts and scrapbook pages with this ... Read More
871526
$7.95
add to bag checkout

Neon Pink Stamp Pad

Neon Pink Stamp Pad
previous / next
Your crafts will pop with this season's trend - neon! Use neon pink ink for ... Read More
029477608014
$7.95
add to bag checkout

Cargo A-Z Stencil Set

Cargo A-Z Stencil Set
previous / next
Created exclusively for Paper Source by Ed Roth of Stencil 1 in Brooklyn, these alphabet ... Read More
447790
$39.95
add to bag checkout

4 Bar Heart Cards

4 Bar Heart Cards
previous / next
Our little heart shaped cards are perfectly sized to fit into 4 Bar envelopes. Turn ... Read More
3432042301
$6.25 - $7.00
get more info

Persimmon 4 Bar Heart Card

Persimmon 4 Bar Heart Card
previous / next
Our little heart shaped cards are perfectly sized to fit into 4 Bar envelopes. Turn ... Read More
3434472301
$6.25 - $7.00
get more info

Fuchsia 4 Bar Heart Card

Fuchsia 4 Bar Heart Card
previous / next
Our little heart shaped cards are perfectly sized to fit into 4 Bar envelopes. Turn ... Read More
3434353201
$6.25 - $7.00
get more info

Blossom 4 Bar Heart Card

Blossom 4 Bar Heart Card
previous / next
Our little heart shaped cards are perfectly sized to fit into 4bar envelopes. Turn them ... Read More
3432622301
$6.25 - $7.00
get more info

Beet 4 Bar Heart Card

Beet 4 Bar Heart Card
previous / next
Our little heart shaped cards are perfectly sized to fit into 4 Bar envelopes. Turn ... Read More
3432792301
$6.25 - $7.00
get more info

Pool 4 Bar Heart Card

Pool 4 Bar Heart Card
previous / next
Our little heart shaped cards are perfectly sized to fit into 4 Bar envelopes. Turn ... Read More
3432662301
$6.25 - $7.00
get more info

Paper Bag 4 Bar Heart Card

Paper Bag 4 Bar Heart Card
previous / next
Our little heart shaped cards are perfectly sized to fit into 4 Bar envelopes. Turn ... Read More
3434402301
$6.25 - $7.00
get more info

Kraft Hang Tags with Eyelets

20 pack
Kraft Hang Tags with Eyelets
previous / next
These small Kraft Hang Tags are adorned with silver eyelets and superfine soft white circles. ... Read More
34302202596501
$9.95
add to bag checkout

Superfine Soft White Hang Tags with Eyelets

20 pack
Superfine Soft White Hang Tags with Eyelets
previous / next
These small Superfine Soft White Hang Tags are adorned with silver eyelets and kraft circles. ... Read More
343054596501
$9.95
add to bag checkout
QUICKVIEW
Small Chalkboard Hang Tags Pack of 10 $9.95
add to bag checkout

Small Chalkboard Hang Tags

Pack of 10
Small Chalkboard Hang Tags
previous / next
Embellish these charming chalkboard hang tags with your penmanship or original artwork. A personalized way ... Read More
381375596501
$9.95
add to bag checkout
QUICKVIEW
Chalkboard Bracket Cards Pack of 10 $9.95
add to bag checkout

Chalkboard Bracket Cards

Pack of 10
Chalkboard Bracket Cards
previous / next
These wonderful die-cut bracket cards feature a chalkboard finish offering a unique way to decorate. ... Read More
497219
$9.95
add to bag checkout
QUICKVIEW
Cranberry Sealing Wax 3 pack $7.50
add to bag checkout

Cranberry Sealing Wax

3 pack
Cranberry Sealing Wax
previous / next
The old world's first security system - if the seal on your letter was broken ... Read More
406930
$7.50
add to bag checkout
QUICKVIEW
Red Sealing Wax 3 pack $7.50
add to bag checkout

Red Sealing Wax

3 pack
Red Sealing Wax
previous / next
The old world's first security system - if the seal on your letter was broken ... Read More
411684
$7.50
add to bag checkout

Two Miniature Birds Rubber Stamp

Two Miniature Birds Rubber Stamp
previous
This tiny rubber stamp features an image that will make a big impact on your ... Read More
443964
$6.50

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.