20% Off Graduation Invitations >   Easter Clearance >

Mother's Day · Weddings · New Arrivals

Free Shipping Orders $40+ with Code SPRING40

Excludes Custom Orders · Ends Monday April 24

Valentine Collection

Wild About You Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 32
Wild About You Valentine Card Kit
next
Can you spot the most paws-itively adorable Valentines? These pretty kitties are purrfect for all ... Read More
10000020
$19.95 $9.98

Tasty Treats Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 32
Tasty Treats Valentine Card Kit
previous / next
Everyone knows that they way to a person's heart is through the stomach, so treat ... Read More
10000016
$19.95 $9.98

Love Tokens

Set of 18
Love Tokens
previous / next
Ok, so you may have forgotten about Valentine's Day. Fear not! Meri Meri Love Tokens ... Read More
521701
$12.95 $6.48

Whale Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 32
Whale Valentine Card Kit
previous / next
You'll have a whale of a time making these, so water you waiting for? Dive ... Read More
10000019
$19.95 $9.98

Crazy Straws

Set of 8
Crazy Straws
previous / next
This party is about to get crazy! Set of 8 plastic straws in 4 different ... Read More
521698
$5.95 $2.98

Handbag Valentine Making Card Kit

Handbag Valentine Making Card Kit
previous / next
Valentine's Day is in the bag with these DIY handbag cards. These pretty purses go ... Read More
10000408
$19.95 $9.98

Wacky Dog & Cat Valentine's Card Set

Set of 28
Wacky Dog & Cat Valentine's Card Set
previous / next
Both cat people and dog people will agree that these cards are awesome. Set include ... Read More
10000007
$14.95 $12.50

Magic Valentine Cards

Set of 28
Magic Valentine Cards
previous / next
Make this Valentine's Day magical! Double-sided flat cards that come in four designs, accompanied by ... Read More
10000103
$16.50 $12.50

You Complete Me Puzzle

You Complete Me Puzzle
previous / next
Made from beautiful heat stamped wood and packaged in a blush gift box. Write a ... Read More
5060146592178
$14.95 $7.48

Conversation Hearts Gift Bags

Conversation Hearts Gift Bags
previous / next
Just for you Valentine! These gift bags are a fun and easy way to share ... Read More
48668629
$2.95 - $7.95
$1.48 - $3.98
Small $1.48
Medium $1.98
Large $3.98

Conversation Heart Faces Cellophane Bags

Set of 20
Conversation Heart Faces Cellophane Bags
previous / next
Fill these adorable food-safe cellophane bags with sweet Valentine treats! These clear bags are big ... Read More
48668642
$7.95 $3.98

Flamingo 4 Bar Heart Cards

Set of 10
Flamingo 4 Bar Heart Cards
previous / next
These die-cut, flamingo-colored heart cards, with room on one or both sides for your personal ... Read More
10000165
$8.95 $4.48

Scratch-Off Heart Stickers

Set of 18
Scratch-Off Heart Stickers
previous / next
Scratch off these stickers to reveal fun sentiments underneath! A great way to add some ... Read More
718813784894
$4.95 $2.48

XOXO Multipack Stickers

Set of 6
XOXO Multipack Stickers
previous / next
An exclusive set from My Mind's Eye, these cute stickers can be used for all ... Read More
699464206433
$6.95 $3.48

Jungle Cats Valentine Cards

Set of 28
Jungle Cats Valentine Cards
previous / next
Unleash your wild side this Valentine's Day! This set includes four unique card designs featuring ... Read More
10000104
$16.50 $12.50

Sassy Heart Valentine Cards

Set of 28
Sassy Heart Valentine Cards
previous / next
These double-sided flat cards are accompanied by assorted envelopes in four colors. Four unique card ... Read More
10000105
$21.50 $12.50

Doggone Fun Valentine Cards

Set of 28
Doggone Fun Valentine Cards
previous / next
Valentines for the dog-lover to send love to their friends! This set of Valentines includes ... Read More
10000102
$16.50 $12.50

Bee Kind Stationery

Set of 10
Bee Kind Stationery
previous / next
We are sure you have a swarm of friends to send Valentines to! Show them ... Read More
10000106
$17.95 $12.50

Mustache Valentine Card Craft Kit

Mustache Valentine Card Craft Kit
previous / next
Our dapper Valentine dudes are such fun! Heart shapes, googly eyes, pre-cut hats and mustaches ... Read More
4071295608
$16.95 $8.48

All-Star Valentines Craft Kit

All-Star Valentines Craft Kit
previous / next
Have a ball sending Valentine's Day greetings with these all-star sports themed cards. Craft kit ... Read More
4071295743
$14.95 $7.48

Fruit Friends Valentine Craft Kit

Fruit Friends Valentine Craft Kit
previous / next
These assorted fruit valentines are the perfect treat to share with friends! Includes printed stickers ... Read More
4071295708
$19.95 $9.98

Cavallini Bicycle Valentine Card

Cavallini Bicycle Valentine Card
previous / next
Take your Valentine for a spin with this sweet bicycle note card from Cavallini. Printed ... Read More
806984
$3.95 $1.98

Meat Loaf You Valentine Card

Meat Loaf You Valentine Card
previous / next
This enthusiastic entrée will bring a smile to your sweetheart's face. Blank inside. Scallop die-cut ... Read More
569809
$5.95 $2.98

Letterpress I Heart You Because Gift Tags

Set of 10
Letterpress I Heart You Because Gift Tags
previous / next
Cute letterpress cards that can be tucked into #1 baby envelopes, or used as gift ... Read More
3909991384
$4.95 $2.48

Red Heart Cards with Blossom Envelopes

Set of 10
Red Heart Cards with Blossom Envelopes
previous / next
Scribble sweet nothings on this adorable stationery. The die-cut heart cards set the perfect tone ... Read More
34326532
$8.95 $4.48

Coral Heart Cards with Antique Gold Envelopes

Set of 10
Coral Heart Cards with Antique Gold Envelopes
previous / next
Scribble sweet nothings on this pretty stationery. The die-cut heart cards set the perfect tone ... Read More
3439330201
$8.95 $4.48

Llama A2 Valentine Cards

Set of 10
Llama A2 Valentine Cards
previous / next
Our popular Llama design will be a huge hit with your lucky Valentines! Write your ... Read More
4661008159
$12.95 $12.50

Heart Air Balloon Craft Kit

Pack of 12
Heart Air Balloon Craft Kit
previous / next
Up, up, and away! Decorating with this kit will have you floating on air! Paper ... Read More
10000017
$14.95 $7.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Mr. & Mrs. Trivia Game

Mr. & Mrs. Trivia Game
previous / next
Mr. & Mrs. Trivia Game contains 70 different questions that make a fun activity for ... Read More
10000481
$7.95 $3.98

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Conversation Hearts XOXO Washi Tape

Set of 2
Conversation Hearts XOXO Washi Tape
previous / next
This set of two patterned washi tape rolls offers you an easy way to decorate ... Read More
900558
$7.95 $3.98

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

XOXO Heart Assorted Washi Tape

Set of 5
XOXO Heart Assorted Washi Tape
previous / next
An exclusive set of tapes from My Mind's Eye, these cute washi's can be used ... Read More
699464206440
$11.95 $5.98

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

XOXO Holographic Stickers

Set of 72
XOXO Holographic Stickers
previous
Holographic foil makes these fun X's and O's pop! Use to create handmade cards, adorn ... Read More
718813784887
$4.95 $2.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Valentine Collection

Our Valentine collection features unique gifts for all ages from pretty presents for your favorite gal pal to sweet sentiments for the one you love. Unique Valentine candy and playful toys are fun for kids, and exclusive gifts featuring Paper Source artwork are one of a kind designs that anyone will love.

Arrow pointing to top