Free Shipping Orders $40+ · Use Code FLURRY40 · excludes custom · ends December 11

+30% Off Holiday Favorites!

View Order By Dates to Receive by December 24 >

Holiday Shop · Wedding · Stationery

Custom Stamps

One Stop Holiday Sale! · 30% Off Custom Stamps

Exclusions Apply · Ends December 11
Order by December 12 with Ground Shipping to Receive by December 24

Custom Stamp Gift Box

Stamp machine & custom stamp plate
Custom Stamp Gift Box
next
Give the gift of a custom stamp with our new gift set. Each lovely package ... Read More
814753012612
$39.95 $27.96

Arctic Critter Custom Stamp

Arctic Critter Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489650
$20.96 - $27.96

Snowflake Splatter Custom Stamp

Snowflake Splatter Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489657
$20.96 - $27.96

Merry Christmas Script Custom Stamp

Merry Christmas Script Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489652
$20.96 - $27.96

Holly Leaves Custom Stamp

Holly Leaves Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489647
$20.96 - $27.96

Ho Ho Ho Hat Custom Stamp

Ho Ho Ho Hat Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489656
$20.96 - $27.96

Heart Be Light Custom Stamp

Heart Be Light Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489654
$20.96 - $27.96

Snowglobe Village Custom Stamp

Snowglobe Village Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489648
$20.96 - $27.96

Fall Leaf Circle Custom Stamp

Fall Leaf Circle Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489659
$20.96 - $27.96

Fall Leaves Custom Stamp

Fall Leaves Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489658
$20.96 - $27.96

Bottle Brush Custom Stamp

Bottle Brush Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489655
$20.96 - $27.96

Happiest Holidays Custom Stamp

Happiest Holidays Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489651
$20.96 - $27.96

Starry Night Custom Stamp

Starry Night Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489649
$20.96 - $27.96

Happy Hanukkah Custom Stamp

Happy Hanukkah Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489653
$20.96 - $27.96

Dreidel Circle Custom Stamp

Dreidel Circle Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489660
$20.96 - $27.96

Circle Monogram Custom Stamp

Circle Monogram Custom Stamp
previous / next
Our self-inking stamps are an easy way to add your return address to envelopes. Just ... Read More
478124
$29.95 - $39.95
$20.96 - $27.96

Single Initial Monogram Custom Stamp - PS design

Single Initial Monogram Custom Stamp - PS design
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489166
$29.95 - $39.95
$20.96 - $27.96

Hand Drawn Border Custom Stamp

Hand Drawn Border Custom Stamp
previous / next
Our self-inking stamps are an easy way to add your return address to envelopes. Just ... Read More
489523
$29.95 - $39.95
$20.96 - $27.96

Dotted Circle Custom Stamp

Dotted Circle Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489579
$29.95 - $39.95
$20.96 - $27.96

Scroll Monogram Circle Custom Stamp

Scroll Monogram Circle Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489626
$29.95 - $39.95
$20.96 - $27.96

Gilded Marble Custom Stamp

Gilded Marble Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489687
$20.96 - $27.96

Fleur Custom Stamp

Fleur Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489686
$20.96 - $27.96

Arboretum Custom Stamp

Arboretum Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489663
$20.96 - $27.96

Jackson Custom Stamp

Jackson Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489672
$20.96 - $27.96

Emerald Custom Stamp

Emerald Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489684
$20.96 - $27.96

Studio Custom Stamp

Studio Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489674
$20.96 - $27.96

Topiary Custom Stamp

Topiary Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489664
$20.96 - $27.96

Metropolitan Custom Stamp

Metropolitan Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489671
$20.96 - $27.96

Sunrise Custom Stamp

Sunrise Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489673
$20.96 - $27.96

Emerald Couple Custom Stamp

Emerald Couple Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489679
$20.96 - $27.96

Peony Custom Stamp

Peony Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489669
$20.96 - $27.96

Indigo Trellis Couple Custom Stamp

Indigo Trellis Couple Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489677
$20.96 - $27.96

Wildflower Custom Stamp

Wildflower Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489661
$20.96 - $27.96

Midnight Meadow Custom Stamp

Midnight Meadow Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489670
$20.96 - $27.96

Colette Custom Stamp

Colette Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489685
$20.96 - $27.96

Golden Blooms Custom Stamp

Golden Blooms Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489688
$20.96 - $27.96

Hand Brush Custom Stamp

Hand Brush Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489676
$20.96 - $27.96

Limon Custom Stamp

Limon Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489662
$20.96 - $27.96

Gallery Custom Stamp

Gallery Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489668
$20.96 - $27.96

Hand Script Couple Custom Stamp - PS design

Hand Script Couple Custom Stamp - PS design
previous / next
Our self-inking stamps are an easy way to add your return address to envelopes. Just ... Read More
489552
$29.95 - $39.95
$20.96 - $27.96

Bold Line Typography Custom Stamp

Bold Line Typography Custom Stamp
previous / next
Our self-inking stamps are an easy way to add your return address to envelopes. Just ... Read More
489524
$29.95 - $39.95
$20.96 - $27.96

Modern Script Custom Stamp

Modern Script Custom Stamp
previous / next
Our self-inking stamps are an easy way to add your return address to envelopes. Just ... Read More
478157
$29.95 - $39.95
$20.96 - $27.96

Ampersand Custom Stamp - PS design

Ampersand Custom Stamp - PS design
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
479007
$29.95 - $39.95
$20.96 - $27.96

Playbill Custom Stamp - PS design

Playbill Custom Stamp - PS design
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
479008
$29.95 - $39.95
$20.96 - $27.96

Baby Sign Custom Stamp

Baby Sign Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489618
$29.95 - $39.95
$20.96 - $27.96

Flourish Script And Custom Stamp

Flourish Script And Custom Stamp
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489584
$29.95 - $39.95
$20.96 - $27.96

Harmony Custom Stamp - PS design

Harmony Custom Stamp - PS design
previous / next
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
489113
$29.95 - $39.95
$20.96 - $27.96

Bulletin Custom Stamp - PS design

Bulletin Custom Stamp - PS design
previous
Self-inking stamps with Paper Source custom designs are an easy way to add your return ... Read More
479003
$29.95 - $39.95
$20.96 - $27.96

Custom Stamps

Make Return Addressing Easy! Choose from a variety of return address stamps & other styles, including Paper Source exclusive designs. Self-inking custom stamps are the easiest way to address envelopes, create gift tags, thank you notes, and so much more. The stamping machine comes with a black water-based ink pad and the design of your choice. Just press down to create a crisp stamp image. Stamp 800 to 1000 impressions without skipping a beat. Once you have a stamp machine, you can purchase additional custom stamp designs (plates) and change them out as you please. Our custom stamps are truly the perfect gift!

Arrow pointing to top