Shop Halloween Collection >

2018 Planners · Weddings · Halloween

Free Shipping All Orders $50+ with code TRICKORTREAT

Offer ends Monday, October 23! shop Halloween >

Candy Gifts

Sugarfina Juice Cleanse Mini

Sugarfina Juice Cleanse Mini
next
In need of a pick-me-up? A shot of "green juice" baby gummy bears will do ... Read More
10002684
$3.95

Mini Honey Bear Jar

Mini Honey Bear Jar
previous / next
Mini Honey Bear holds 3oz. of USA honey. Paper Source exclusive. Artwork says "You're So ... Read More
10001928
$5.95

Reindeer Nose Gummy Cube

Reindeer Nose Gummy Cube
previous / next
An ode to Rudolph, these juicy raspberry jellies are coated in tiny red non-perils. A ... Read More
10002763
$9.95

Halloween Pop Rocks

Halloween Pop Rocks
previous / next
Classic Pop Rocks transformed for Halloween! Enjoy pumpkin patch orange and green popping candy for ... Read More
433397
$1.50

Coal Hard Candy

2 oz
Coal Hard Candy
previous / next
This tasty, cinnamon-flavored candy makes a perfect stocking stuffer! Give even those on the naughty ... Read More
10002765
$4.95

Sugarfina Champagne Bears

3.3 oz.
Sugarfina Champagne Bears
previous / next
Infused with bubbly champagne, these sophisticated bears from Sugarfina sparkle in flavors of Brut and ... Read More
521424
$9.95

PopInsanity Caramel Chocolate Sea Salt Popcorn

PopInsanity Caramel Chocolate Sea Salt Popcorn
previous / next
Savor this richly cooked caramel popcorn with Mediterranean sea salt! This tasty treat is gourmet ... Read More
10002761
$14.95

Holiday Village Tea

5 inches tall 2 inch diameter
Holiday Village Tea
previous / next
Made exclusively for Paper Source, this Republic of Tea tin comes with 50 black tea ... Read More
10002281
$14.95

Sugarfina Bourbon Bears

Sugarfina Bourbon Bears
previous / next
Sugarfina's tasty Bourbon Bears in Paper Source designed and exclusive packaging! Imported from Germany, these ... Read More
10001232
$9.95

Sugarfina Rosé Gummies

4 oz.
Sugarfina Rosé Gummies
previous / next
Can't get enough Rosé? This gummy is for you! Sugarfina's Rosé Gummies feature exclusive packaging ... Read More
521703
$9.95

Holiday Village Travel Tea Tin

2.5 inch diameter
Holiday Village Travel Tea Tin
previous / next
Made exclusively for Paper Source, this travel-sized Republic of Tea tin comes with 6 black ... Read More
10002282
$6.95

Candy Cane Pop Rocks

Candy Cane Pop Rocks
previous / next
Santa likes to feed Candy Cane Pop Rocks to his reindeer...it puts a little extra ... Read More
530040
$1.50

Halloween Gummy Kabob Candy

Halloween Gummy Kabob Candy
previous / next
These yummy gummy kabobs are a candy lover's dream! Featuring fun Halloween candies in all ... Read More
131000
$4.95

Holiday Gummy Kabob Candy

Holiday Gummy Kabob Candy
previous / next
These yummy gummy kabobs are a candy lover's dream! Featuring fun holiday candies in all ... Read More
131001
$4.95

Pumpkin Spice Tea

Pumpkin Spice Tea
previous / next
Pumpkin spice and everything nice! Made by The Republic of Tea, one cup of this ... Read More
10001887
$15.95

Honey Spoons

Set of 6
Honey Spoons
previous / next
Perfect for flavoring any hot beverage, simply place a honey spoon in your drink, wait ... Read More
521420
$9.95

Gravy Candy

Gravy Candy
previous / next
Can't get enough with your mashed potatoes? Try this gravy candy but be warned - ... Read More
10001764
$4.95

Edible Eyes

Edible Eyes
previous / next
Getting your kids to eat their veggies will be a breeze with these stick on ... Read More
520621
$9.95

Chocolate Marshmallow Stirrers

Pack of 6
Chocolate Marshmallow Stirrers
previous / next
Perfect for flavoring any hot beverage; simply place in your drink, stir and enjoy! Includes ... Read More
521406
$8.95

Unicorn Lollipops

Unicorn Lollipops
previous / next
Pink, blue, or white unicorn shaped lollipops from Melville Candy. Assorted fruit flavors. Come wrapped ... Read More
10001514
$2.95

Chocolate Magic Milk Straws

Set of 6
Chocolate Magic Milk Straws
previous / next
Magic Milk Straws are yummy straws filled with flavor beads that transform white milk into ... Read More
497154
$3.95

Hot Sauce Kit

Hot Sauce Kit
previous / next
The Homemade Hot Sauce Kit includes the tools and ingredients you need to make two ... Read More
10002845
$45.00

Ginger Chews

Ginger Chews
previous / next
Unlock the amazing powers of ginger in a little chew! Individually wrapped.Size - 1.5 oz. ... Read More
521418
$3.95

Peppermint Spoons

Set of 6
Peppermint Spoons
previous / next
While stirring up your favorite hot cocoa, add a touch of peppermint with these yummy ... Read More
10000027
$9.95

Sugarfina Lrg Martini Almonds

Sugarfina Lrg Martini Almonds
previous / next
Don't worry, there aren't any actual olives in this candy... just smartly-dressed, chocolate-covered almonds masquerading ... Read More
10000000
$19.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Sugarfina Sparkle Pops

Sugarfina Sparkle Pops
previous / next
Sugarfina's delicious Sparkle Pop Chocolates wrapped in Paper Source exclusive packaging - a match made ... Read More
10000482
$9.95 $4.98

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Junior Mints Halloween

Junior Mints Halloween
previous / next
A classic candy takes on a spooky theme! Savor these Halloween edition Junior Mints with ... Read More
10001716
$2.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Toasty Marshmallow Toasters

Toasty Marshmallow Toasters
previous / next
No need to waste time searching for tree branches - these marshmallow toasting sticks are ... Read More
10001575
$19.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Box of Boogers Gummy Candies

Box of Boogers Gummy Candies
previous / next
Fun Halloween candy, these tangy gummy boogies look and feel like real chunks of snot. ... Read More
434119
$3.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Sugarfina Zombie Brains

Sugarfina Zombie Brains
previous
Everyone will be wanting brains this Halloween! ... Read More
10002372
$8.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.
Arrow pointing to top