50% Off Calendars & Planners >  Valentine Clearance >

Easter · Weddings · New Arrivals

Free Standard Shipping on Orders $50+    ends February 28 · details >

Valentine Collection

Mix & Match Critter Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 36
Mix & Match Critter Valentine Card Kit
next
You’ll have a whole lot of fun pairing a top and bottom half to create ... Read More
10002927
$19.95 $11.97

Fish Valentines Card Kit

Pack of 32
Fish Valentines Card Kit
previous / next
This year, your Valentines will be the catch of the day! With 32 cute fish ... Read More
10002928
$19.95 $11.97

Dino-mite Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 32
Dino-mite Valentine Card Kit
previous / next
A t-riffic Valentine is within arm's reach with these fierce friends! The smiles on these ... Read More
10000021
$19.95 $11.97

Alien Valentines Card Kit

Pack of 32
Alien Valentines Card Kit
previous / next
Who wouldn’t be over the moon to get one of these adorable aliens? They're the ... Read More
10002926
$19.95 $11.97

Airplanes Kids Valentine Pack

Pack of 28
Airplanes Kids Valentine Pack
previous / next
The Valentine Airplanes Card Pack includes four styles of fun paper airplane Valentines that kids ... Read More
643356047369
$14.95 $8.97

Card in a Drawer Valentine Card

Card in a Drawer Valentine Card
previous / next
This cute Valentine's Day card is perfect for your significant other. Features the words, "Someday, ... Read More
815429013506
$3.95 $2.37

Letterpress A2 Love Pizzas Valentine Card

Letterpress A2 Love Pizzas Valentine Card
previous / next
It's hard to love anything more than pizza, but this card is meant for someone ... Read More
3909991377
$4.95 $2.97

Be Mine Valentine Card

Be Mine Valentine Card
previous / next
This heartfelt and handmade card features a sweet little bumble bee with delicate script spelling ... Read More
456341
$6.95 $4.17

Made For Each Otter A6 Valentine Card

Made For Each Otter A6 Valentine Card
previous / next
Nothing says love like two otters floating together; they are one of the few animals ... Read More
4661008014
$3.95 $2.37

Meat Loaf You Valentine Card

Meat Loaf You Valentine Card
previous / next
This enthusiastic entrée will bring a smile to your sweetheart's face this Valentine's Day. It ... Read More
569809
$5.95 $3.57

Whale Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 32
Whale Valentine Card Kit
previous / next
You'll have a whale of a time making these adorable, whale Valentines! Show your friends ... Read More
10000019
$19.95 $11.97

Jungle Cats Valentine Cards

Set of 28
Jungle Cats Valentine Cards
previous / next
Send some wild Valentine wishes with this set of 28 unique, double sided card designs ... Read More
10000104
$16.50 $9.90

Dinosaur Valentine Set

Set of 28
Dinosaur Valentine Set
previous / next
This pack of Dino-themed Valentines includes four unique card designs featuring fun dinosaurs and punny ... Read More
10002627
$16.50 $9.90

Magic Valentine Cards

Set of 28
Magic Valentine Cards
previous / next
Make this Valentine's Day magical with these double-sided flat cards that come in four designs, ... Read More
10000103
$16.50 $8.25

Dino Love Card

Dino Love Card
previous / next
Well we're doing just fine without the dinosaurs, but if you didn't have this special ... Read More
4661008343
$5.95 $3.57

Greenery Valentine Card

Greenery Valentine Card
previous / next
A beautiful watercolor floral pops with gold foil details on this card that elegantly wishes ... Read More
10002616
$4.95 $2.97

Moon & Back Banner Valentine Card

Moon & Back Banner Valentine Card
previous / next
Now they'll never have to ask because they'll know just how much they're loved. This ... Read More
569808
$5.95 $3.57

Pizza My Heart Card

Pizza My Heart Card
previous / next
Share a slice of pizza, topped with heart-shaped pepperoni, with that special someone. Single card. ... Read More
4661008346
$3.95 $2.37

I Love You This Much Valentine Card

I Love You This Much Valentine Card
previous / next
This adorable Valentine's Day card is decorated with heart gems and buttons. Blank inside and ... Read More
456220
$6.95 $4.17

S'more Greeting Card

S'more Greeting Card
previous / next
Test out your pick up lines by giving this clever and cute S'mores card on ... Read More
10002935
$6.95 $4.17

Look At My Phone Valentine Card

Look At My Phone Valentine Card
previous / next
Send an honest sentiment this Valentine's Day with this delightfully true card for modern couples. ... Read More
569803
$4.95 $2.97

Rifle Paper Co. Boatload Postcards

Set of 10
Rifle Paper Co. Boatload Postcards
previous / next
Send a boatload of love with these adorable Valentine postcards from Rifle Paper Co. Set ... Read More
807324
$13.50 $8.10

Blossom Heart 4 Bar Letterpress Stationery

Set of 8
Blossom Heart 4 Bar Letterpress Stationery
previous / next
A blossom heart letterpress printed onto our luxe paper makes this a simple, sweet Valentines ... Read More
39299995
$10.50 $6.30

Love & Hugs 4 Bar Valentine Cards

Set of 10
Love & Hugs 4 Bar Valentine Cards
previous / next
Send love and hugs this Valentine's Day with this sweet little card. Blank inside and ... Read More
4661008149
$11.95 $7.17

Bunny With Hearts & Kisses Valentine Card

Bunny With Hearts & Kisses Valentine Card
previous / next
Our beloved bunny, covered in kisses, arrives to wish you the Happiest Valentine's Day! Blank ... Read More
807288
$5.95 $3.57

Bear Hug A2 Valentine Card

Bear Hug A2 Valentine Card
previous / next
Send sweet bear hugs this Valentine's Day with this delightful card featuring Paper Source artwork. ... Read More
4661008156
$3.95 $2.37

Rifle Paper Co. Heart Bouquet Valentine Card

Rifle Paper Co. Heart Bouquet Valentine Card
previous / next
Play up the romance of the holiday by presenting your Valentine with this gorgeous card ... Read More
10000300
$5.95 $3.57

Smiled Because You Knew Valentine Card

Smiled Because You Knew Valentine Card
previous / next
No one knows romance better than William Shakespeare. 400 years ago he documented the phenomena ... Read More
10000296
$5.95 $3.57

Foil Magical Unicorn A2 Valentine Card

Foil Magical Unicorn A2 Valentine Card
previous / next
This unicorn card is filled with Valentine's magic! Adorned with foil throughout, you can write ... Read More
4661008133
$4.95 $2.97

Meow and Purr-ever Card

Meow and Purr-ever Card
previous / next
Show your favorite cat-lover how much you love them with our "I love you meow ... Read More
10002623
$4.95 $2.97

Favorite Valentine Dad A2 Card

Favorite Valentine Dad A2 Card
previous / next
A sweet and precious Valentine sentiment for a child to share with Dad. Blank inside. ... Read More
4661008158
$3.95 $2.37

Greatest Adventure Letterpress A6 Valentine Card

Greatest Adventure Letterpress A6 Valentine Card
previous / next
These cute letterpress cards can be tucked into #1 baby envelopes, or used as gift ... Read More
3929991205
$5.95 $3.57

Stinkin Great Skunk Valentine Card

Stinkin Great Skunk Valentine Card
previous / next
Show your love this Valentine's day with our adorable, too stinkin' cute skunk. Blank inside ... Read More
4661007818
$3.95 $2.37

Love My Best Friend Letterpress A2 Valentine Card

Love My Best Friend Letterpress A2 Valentine Card
previous / next
Show your significant other how much you love him/her with this adorable, best friends Valentine ... Read More
3929991286
$4.95 $2.97

Cavallini Vintage Valentine Postcards

Set of 12
Cavallini Vintage Valentine Postcards
previous / next
Add some sophistication to your Valentine's Day greetings with this tin of 12 assorted Cavallini ... Read More
456115
$13.95 $8.37

Favorite Sushi Valentine Card

Favorite Sushi Valentine Card
previous / next
Perfect for the sushi lover, this Valentine card says, "You're all of my favorite things ... Read More
10002631
$3.95 $2.37

Llama A2 Valentine Cards

Set of 10
Llama A2 Valentine Cards
previous / next
Our popular Llama design will be a huge hit with your lucky Valentines! Write your ... Read More
4661008159
$12.95 $7.77

Hogs & Kisses A2 Valentine Card

Hogs & Kisses A2 Valentine Card
previous / next
These cute, playful pigs are sure to melt your sweetie's heart this Valentine's Day. Write ... Read More
4661008137
$3.95 $2.37

Paws-itively Amazing Valentine Card

Paws-itively Amazing Valentine Card
previous / next
This fun Valentine's Day card features an adorable bull dog illustration with the words, 'You ... Read More
10002620
$3.95 $2.37

You Jump I Jump Valentine Card

You Jump I Jump Valentine Card
previous / next
You're so stupid, Rose! Tell someone you love them with the most romantic way possible, ... Read More
10002937
$5.95 $3.57

Hot Dog Valentine Card

Hot Dog Valentine Card
previous / next
Our perfectly playful dachshund is ready for Valentine's Day! Printed on recycled paper. Inside has ... Read More
4661007813
$3.95 $2.37

Felines For You Valentine Card

Felines For You Valentine Card
previous / next
Do you have feelings? Do you or your loved one also love Cats? Then look ... Read More
10002938
$4.95 $2.97

Love Doing Absolutely Nothing Card

Love Doing Absolutely Nothing Card
previous / next
You know you've found the one when their company is all you really need to ... Read More
4661008353
$3.95 $2.37

Sea Lion Greeting Card

Sea Lion Greeting Card
previous / next
Use this sea lion pick up line card for multiple occasions, especially on Valentine's Day! ... Read More
10002939
$5.95 $3.57

Amusement Park Valentine Set

Set of 28
Amusement Park Valentine Set
previous / next
This fun set of Valentines includes four unique card designs featuring cute critters and sweet ... Read More
10002629
$16.50 $9.90

Cavallini Bicycle Valentine Card

Cavallini Bicycle Valentine Card
previous / next
Take your Valentine for a spin with this sweet bicycle note card from Cavallini. Printed ... Read More
806984
$3.95 $2.37

Fish in the Sea Greeting Card

Fish in the Sea Greeting Card
previous / next
This charming, two-color, letterpress card features fish illustrations with the words, "You're the only fish ... Read More
10002624
$4.95 $2.97

You're My Lobster Greeting Card

You're My Lobster Greeting Card
previous / next
Did you know lobster refers to the person of whom another is meant to be ... Read More
10002940
$5.95 $3.57

Llama A2 Valentine Card

Llama A2 Valentine Card
previous / next
Our popular Llama design will be a huge hit with your lucky Valentine! Write your ... Read More
4661008138
$3.95 $2.37

Love & Hugs 4 Bar Valentine Card

Love & Hugs 4 Bar Valentine Card
previous / next
Send love and hugs this Valentine's Day with this sweet little card. Paired with a ... Read More
4661008148
$3.25 $1.95

Watercolor Big Hug A2 Valentine Card

Watercolor Big Hug A2 Valentine Card
previous / next
A sweet watercolor greeting shares a playful sentiment for Valentine's Day! Blank inside and paired ... Read More
4661008150
$3.95 $2.37

Studarsaurus Valentine Card

Studarsaurus Valentine Card
previous / next
Remind them of the stud they are woth this studasaurus card. Perfect for Valentine's Day ... Read More
10002943
$4.95 $2.97

Mixtape Postcards

Mixtape Postcards
previous / next
Show your love by sending a mixtape this Valentine's Day. These fun postcards are perfect ... Read More
10002632
$12.50 $7.50

Grandmas Heart Balloons Valentine Card

Grandmas Heart Balloons Valentine Card
previous / next
Don't forget about Grandma this Valentine's Day! Send this beautiful card with gold foil accents. ... Read More
10002617
$4.95 $2.97

Blink If You Love Me Valentine Card

Blink If You Love Me Valentine Card
previous / next
Ask your valentine to show you the love with this funny Valentine's Day card. The ... Read More
10002944
$4.95 $2.97

99% of Socks Single Valentine Card

99% of Socks Single Valentine Card
previous / next
Let's just go with the sure thing. This snarky card features an adorable, detailed watercolor ... Read More
10002996
$4.95 $2.97

Love is Strong Valentine Card

Love is Strong Valentine Card
previous / next
Paper Source designed two-color letterpress. Blank inside. Paired with red envelope. Card size: 4-1/4" x ... Read More
10002626
$4.95 $2.97

Trunk with Love Valentine Card

Trunk with Love Valentine Card
previous / next
Like the elephant, "I'm trunk with love" for this adorable Valentine. If you are in ... Read More
10000295
$4.95 $2.97

Love your Fanny Valentine Card

Love your Fanny Valentine Card
previous / next
You can love someone for a multitude of reasons. Flatter your sweetie, and make 'em ... Read More
10000297
$4.95 $2.97

Cavallini Valentines Vintage Postcards

12 postcards
Cavallini Valentines Vintage Postcards
previous / next
Send your Valentines this year with this tin of 12 Cavallini, vintage, glitter postcards! Featuring ... Read More
10000380
$13.95 $8.37

I'd Pick You Foil Card

I'd Pick You Foil Card
previous / next
This sweet sentiment is sure to bring a tear to the eye of your beloved ... Read More
4661008354
$4.95 $2.97

Superheroes Valentines Card Kit

Pack of 32
Superheroes Valentines Card Kit
previous / next
Send your Valentine’s Day greetings with these powerful superheroes! Customize your superhero friends with different ... Read More
10003121
$19.95 $11.97

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Doggone Fun Valentine Cards

Set of 28
Doggone Fun Valentine Cards
previous / next
These Valentines are perfect for the dog-lover to send love to their friends! This set ... Read More
10000102
$16.50 $9.90

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Soul Sister Valentine Card

Soul Sister Valentine Card
previous / next
There is nothing quite like a strong female friendship. Share this card with the gal ... Read More
10000360
$5.95 $3.57

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Thanks Mom A2 Valentine Card

Thanks Mom A2 Valentine Card
previous / next
Don't forget to thank mom this Valentine's Day and let her know how much you ... Read More
4661008132
$3.95 $2.37

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Red Heart Cards with Blossom Envelopes

Set of 10
Red Heart Cards with Blossom Envelopes
previous / next
Scribble sweet nothings on this adorable stationery. The die-cut heart cards set the perfect tone ... Read More
34326532
$8.95 $5.37

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Red Heart Cards with Fuchsia Envelopes

Set of 10
Red Heart Cards with Fuchsia Envelopes
previous / next
Scribble sweet nothings on this adorable stationery. The die-cut heart cards set the perfect tone ... Read More
3434470204
$8.95 $5.37

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Multi Hearts Valentine Card

Multi Hearts Valentine Card
previous / next
Send heaps of hearts this Valentine's Day with this sweet card that features the words ... Read More
10002618
$5.95 $3.57

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Gold Foil A2 Painted Heart Valentine Card

Gold Foil A2 Painted Heart Valentine Card
previous / next
"With You Is Where I Want To Be" - a sweet sentiment written in gold ... Read More
4661008146
$4.95 $2.97

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Cavallini Valentine's Mailing Set

Set of 24
Cavallini Valentine's Mailing Set
previous / next
This charming tin has everything you need to send your Valentine love this year. Featuring ... Read More
456116
$24.95 $14.97

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Love Ya Oodles Poodle Card

Love Ya Oodles Poodle Card
previous / next
This neatly groomed poodle is feeling the love. Share some of your own with that ... Read More
4661008340
$3.95 $2.37

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Everything is Alright Valentine Card

Everything is Alright Valentine Card
previous / next
Show the ones you love that everything is alright when you're together with this colorful ... Read More
10002619
$3.95 $2.37

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Rifle Paper Co. Sending My Heart Valentine Postcards

Set of 10
Rifle Paper Co. Sending My Heart Valentine Postcards
previous / next
Send your loved ones a lovely postage stamp-edged Valentine postcards by Rifle Paper Co. ... Read More
10000290
$13.50 $8.10

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Beautiful Wife Valentine Card

Beautiful Wife Valentine Card
previous
Your beautiful wife is sure to appreciate the wonderful bouquet that adorns this card. Warm ... Read More
10000361
$5.95 $3.57

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Valentine Collection

Our Valentine collection features unique gifts for all ages from pretty presents for your favorite gal pal to sweet sentiments for the one you love. Unique Valentine candy and playful toys are fun for kids, and exclusive gifts featuring Paper Source artwork are one of a kind designs that anyone will love.

Arrow pointing to top