25-50% Off Custom Stamps >

Photo Cards · Personalized Gifts · Holiday Shop

Free Standard Shipping on Orders $50+    ends January 25 · details >

Valentine Collection

Mix & Match Critter Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 36
Mix & Match Critter Valentine Card Kit
next
You’ll have a whole lot of fun pairing a top and bottom half to create ... Read More
10002927
$19.95

Fish Valentines Card Kit

Pack of 32
Fish Valentines Card Kit
previous / next
This year, your Valentines will be the catch of the day! With 32 cute fish ... Read More
10002928
$19.95

Superheroes Valentines Card Kit

Pack of 32
Superheroes Valentines Card Kit
previous / next
Send your Valentine’s Day greetings with these powerful superheroes! Customize your superhero friends with different ... Read More
10003121
$19.95

Dino-mite Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 32
Dino-mite Valentine Card Kit
previous / next
A t-riffic Valentine is within arm's reach with these fierce friends! The smiles on these ... Read More
10000021
$19.95

Alien Valentines Card Kit

Pack of 32
Alien Valentines Card Kit
previous / next
Who wouldn’t be over the moon to get one of these adorable aliens? They're the ... Read More
10002926
$19.95

Puppies & Kittens Valentine Craft Kit

Pack of 28
Puppies & Kittens Valentine Craft Kit
previous / next
Send sweet greetings this Valentine's Day with these furry friends! Complete with playful stickers that ... Read More
4071295711
$19.95

Rainbows & Sunshines Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 32
Rainbows & Sunshines Valentine Card Kit
previous / next
The forecast for Valentine’s Day this year? Sunny with a chance of smiles! Have fun ... Read More
10002931
$19.95

Robot Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 32
Robot Valentine Card Kit
previous / next
Gear up to give your pals the perfect Valentines! Mix and match to create a ... Read More
10002929
$19.95

Plantable Hearts

Plantable Hearts
previous / next
These adorable pink, red, and white paper hearts are embedded with the seeds of wildflower ... Read More
491665
$8.95

Whale Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 32
Whale Valentine Card Kit
previous / next
You'll have a whale of a time making these adorable, whale Valentines! Show your friends ... Read More
10000019
$19.95

Shark Love Valentine's Card Set

Set of 24
Shark Love Valentine's Card Set
previous / next
This unique set of 24 cards features four friendly sharks, each with its own Valentine ... Read More
10000009
$19.95

Tasty Treats Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 32
Tasty Treats Valentine Card Kit
previous / next
Everyone knows that they way to a person's heart is through the stomach, so treat ... Read More
10000016
$19.95

Fairy Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 32
Fairy Valentine Card Kit
previous / next
Delight your friends with these enchanting and sweet, fairy Valentines! You can even choose each ... Read More
10002930
$19.95

Outer Space Valentines and Tattoos

Pack of 24
Outer Space Valentines and Tattoos
previous / next
Send your love letters into space with this fabulous Meri Meri Valentine's Day card set ... Read More
10002875
$19.95

Valentines Day Doillies

Pack of 24
Valentines Day Doillies
previous / next
These elegant heart doilies look lovely as a gift topper or strung on baker's twine ... Read More
900106
$6.95

Flamingo 4 Bar Heart Cards

Set of 10
Flamingo 4 Bar Heart Cards
previous / next
These die-cut, flamingo-colored heart cards, with room on one or both sides for your personal ... Read More
10000165
$8.95

Wild About You Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 32
Wild About You Valentine Card Kit
previous / next
Can you spot the most paws-itively adorable Valentines? These pretty kitties are purrfect for all ... Read More
10000020
$19.95

Fuchsia Glitter Heart Stickers

Pack of 84
Fuchsia Glitter Heart Stickers
previous / next
Spark some love on all your projects with these fuchsia glitter heart stickers. A sweet ... Read More
900104
$4.95

Puffy Character Heart Stickers

Set of 50
Puffy Character Heart Stickers
previous / next
These cute little heart stickers come with a variety of faces and expressions! Use to ... Read More
10000421
$4.95

Red Heart Cotton Ribbon

Red Heart Cotton Ribbon
previous / next
This ribbon has a cute heart pattern perfect for adding that loving touch to any ... Read More
10002599
$7.95

Handbag Valentine Making Card Kit

Pack of 32
Handbag Valentine Making Card Kit
previous / next
Valentine's Day is in the bag with these DIY handbag cards. These pretty purses go ... Read More
10000408
$19.95

Cavallini Valentine Hearts Wrapping Paper

20" x 28"
Cavallini Valentine Hearts Wrapping Paper
previous / next
This charming paper features vintage Valentine imagery from the Cavallini archives. Wonderful for wrapping something ... Read More
428671
$4.95 $2.48

Small Solid Heart Rubber Stamp

Small Solid Heart Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Nothing says love better than a heart and we're sure this tiny heart will look ... Read More
871583
$5.95

Happy Valentine's Day Swirl Script Stamp

Happy Valentine's Day Swirl Script Stamp
previous / next
Wish anyone a Happy Valentine's Day with this message stamp. Use bright, bold inkpad colors ... Read More
10002670
$10.95

Red Tear Heart on Cream Fine Paper

19" x 30"
Red Tear Heart on Cream Fine Paper
previous / next
Beautiful heart shapes are torn from red paper and layered onto a cream Lokta paper ... Read More
103307
$6.95

Valentine's Day Stamp Set

Valentine's Day Stamp Set
previous / next
The Hero Arts Valentine Messages Mini Tub contains 12 woodblock stamps, a pink pigment ink ... Read More
10002673
$14.95

Mini Bear with Heart Rubber Stamp

Mini Bear with Heart Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Some things are even cuter when they're miniature. This bear is irresistible - send a ... Read More
871304
$5.50

Medium Solid Heart Rubber Stamp

Medium Solid Heart Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Nothing says love better than a heart and we're sure this regular heart will look ... Read More
871582
$6.95

Packed Party Love Roo Flat Wrap

19 1/2" x 27"
Packed Party Love Roo Flat Wrap
previous / next
This paper is as unique and fun as the person you're wrapping a gift for. ... Read More
10002561
$4.95

Heart Mini Rubber Stamp

Heart Mini Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Express your love with our heart rubber stamps. Our Mini Heart Rubber Stamp is oh ... Read More
800188
$4.75

Red, Pink, & Gold Marbled Fine Paper

Nepal
Red, Pink, & Gold Marbled Fine Paper
previous / next
This exquisite marble paper features stunning swirls of pink, red, and gold. The slightly sheer ... Read More
10002559
$8.00

You Are So Incredibly Awesome Rubber Stamp

You Are So Incredibly Awesome Rubber Stamp
previous / next
This sweet sentiment rubber stamp will sure to make your card design shine! ... Read More
871808
$6.95

Red Flocked Hearts on Gold Fine Paper

India
Red Flocked Hearts on Gold Fine Paper
previous / next
Wrap up all of your Valentine gifts with this charming paper featuring red hearts on ... Read More
10002558
$6.95

Love Script Rubber Stamp

Love Script Rubber Stamp
previous / next
The sweeping script on this stamp will add charm to all your Valentine's Day projects. ... Read More
871812
$7.95

Hearts Pattern Rubber Stamp

Hearts Pattern Rubber Stamp
previous / next
This clever rubber stamp allows you to stamp borders and repeated patterns with ease. Stamp ... Read More
871425
$11.95

XOXO Rubber Stamp

XOXO Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Add charm to all your Valentine's Day projects with this cute XOXO stamp! Stamp on ... Read More
10000114
$6.95

Red Heart on White Curling Ribbon

Red Heart on White Curling Ribbon
previous / next
This is the perfect accessory for Valentine's Day gift giving. With a fun heart pattern, ... Read More
10002598
$4.95

Conversation Hearts Wrapping Paper

Conversation Hearts Wrapping Paper
previous / next
Show your love with this Paper Source designed wrapping paper! Cute conversation hearts bring their ... Read More
465302
$3.95 - $8.95
$1.58 - $3.58
Roll Wrap $3.58
Flat Sheet $1.58

I Heart You Rubber Stamp

I Heart You Rubber Stamp
previous / next
The perfect sentiment for your sweetheart! Add a touch of love to cards, envelopes, and ... Read More
871821
$6.95

Flourish Heart Rubber Stamp

Flourish Heart Rubber Stamp
previous / next
This whimsical heart stamp will add style to Valentine's, stationery, even wedding place cards and ... Read More
439278
$12.50

Love You More Rubber Stamp

Love You More Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Show some love with this simple message that means so much. Use bright, bold inkpad ... Read More
871727
$7.95

Lip Rubber Stamp

Lip Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Add a kiss to your Valentines without messing up your lipstick. This stamp is great ... Read More
10000115
$6.95

Best Couple Ever Stamp

Best Couple Ever Stamp
previous / next
Perfect for engagement announcements and scrapbooks! This fun stamp can be used with our collection ... Read More
871820
$6.95

Conversation Hearts Wrapping Paper

Conversation Hearts Wrapping Paper
previous / next
Show your love with this Paper Source designed wrapping paper! Cute conversation hearts bring their ... Read More
44392750
$3.95 - $8.95
$1.58 - $3.58
Roll Wrap $3.58
Flat Sheet $1.58

Gold Hearts on Cream Fine Paper

20" x 30"
Gold Hearts on Cream Fine Paper
previous / next
An intricate design in gold and white meets century-old Nepalese craftsmanship with this butterfly print ... Read More
900550
$6.95 $2.78

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Bee Kind Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 32
Bee Kind Valentine Card Kit
previous / next
Nothing says "I've been thinking about you" like a homemade Valentine! This kit is the ... Read More
10000289
$19.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Heart Balloon Stamp

Heart Balloon Stamp
previous / next
Show your love in style with this cheerful heart balloons stamp. Fun to use with ... Read More
10002669
$10.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Love You Lots Stamp

Love You Lots Stamp
previous
Show someone how much you love them with this simple message that means so much. ... Read More
10002672
$8.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Valentine Collection

Our Valentine collection features unique gifts for all ages from pretty presents for your favorite gal pal to sweet sentiments for the one you love. Unique Valentine candy and playful toys are fun for kids, and exclusive gifts featuring Paper Source artwork are one of a kind designs that anyone will love.

Arrow pointing to top