25-50% Off Custom Stamps >

Photo Cards · Personalized Gifts · Holiday Shop

Free Standard Shipping on Orders $50+    ends January 25 · details >

Unique Gifts

Pizza Slice Ornament

Pizza Slice Ornament
next
This glass pizza slice ornament features a glitter crust and is perfect for any pizza ... Read More
10001915
$14.95 $8.97

Unicorn Magic Ornament

Unicorn Magic Ornament
previous / next
Spread a little holiday magic with this shimmery unicorn ornament! A pretty gold banner wraps ... Read More
512116
$15.95 $9.57

Cat With Glasses Ornament

Cat With Glasses Ornament
previous / next
The ideal ornament for the cat lover! Featuring a darling embroidered kitten wearing spunky spectacles. ... Read More
512122
$14.95 $8.97

Dreamcatcher Ornament

Dreamcatcher Ornament
previous / next
Dream on this holiday with this glittery dream catcher ornament! Stunning metallic accents add a ... Read More
512158
$16.95 $10.17

Skiing Dog Paper Mache Ornament

Skiing Dog Paper Mache Ornament
previous / next
For the winter sport lovers and the puppy fans, this paper mache ornament features a ... Read More
10002156
$14.95 $8.97

Silver Poodle Ornament

Silver Poodle Ornament
previous / next
Calling all poodle lovers! Decorate your tree with this silver poodle ornament adorned with white ... Read More
10002198
$16.95 $10.17

Ice Cream Ornament

Ice Cream Ornament
previous / next
Enjoy your favorite treat even in the chilly months with this sparkly glass ice cream ... Read More
512131
$9.95 $5.97

Gold Bunny Ballerina Ornament

Gold Bunny Ballerina Ornament
previous / next
This sweet ballerina bunny ornament is the perfect choice for the classic tree! With floppy ... Read More
512120
$14.95 $8.97

Small Gold Pineapple Ornament

Small Gold Pineapple Ornament
previous / next
This small gold pineapple ornament is made of glass and features gold foil leaves which ... Read More
10001759
$9.95 $5.97

Hedgehog Ball Ornament

Hedgehog Ball Ornament
previous / next
Decorate your tree with this adorably painted hedgehog ornament!3 inch diameter ... Read More
10002154
$9.95 $5.97

Bottle Brush Fox Ornament

Bottle Brush Fox Ornament
previous / next
One of our favorite woodland critters, this ornament is shaped like a fox with orange ... Read More
10002158
$9.95 $5.97

Joy Beaded Ornament

Joy Beaded Ornament
previous / next
This beaded joy ornament will add sparkle to your holiday décor.5" x 3 1/2" ... Read More
10002286
$12.95 $7.77

Taco Ornament

Taco Ornament
previous / next
Have tacos all season long with this quirky glass ornament shaped like a taco! Paper ... Read More
10002129
$7.95 $4.77

Beer Glass Ornament

Beer Glass Ornament
previous / next
This beer glass ornament hangs from a piece of twine and features glitter foam at ... Read More
10001758
$9.95 $5.97

Gold Palm Tree Ornament

Gold Palm Tree Ornament
previous / next
Decorate your tree with this glass palm tree featuring a rose gold trunk and gold ... Read More
10001760
$14.95 $8.97

Bright Green Pickle Ornament

Bright Green Pickle Ornament
previous / next
What a pickle! This bright green ornament looks just like a crunchy pickle.4 inches long ... Read More
10001917
$12.95 $7.77

Gold Glass Christmas Tree Ornament

Gold Glass Christmas Tree Ornament
previous / next
This beautiful glass ornament features a gold Christmas tree and gold sparkles giving it maximum ... Read More
10002196
$12.95 $7.77

Votes for Women Ornament

Votes for Women Ornament
previous / next
The story behind this little porcelain and gold ornament is one to be proud of: ... Read More
10002982
$19.95 $11.97

Golden Wishbone Ornament

Golden Wishbone Ornament
previous / next
Make a wish this holiday! A gold metallic wishbone features an affirmative message, "You're Golden". ... Read More
512113
$16.95 $10.17

Roxie Reindeer Plush Toy

Roxie Reindeer Plush Toy
previous / next
Roxie Reindeer is ready to fly in her snuggly, huggable coat. This lovable lass has ... Read More
512162
$34.95 $20.97

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Train Advent Calendar

Train Advent Calendar
previous / next
This beautiful advent calendar comes in the form of a railway station with three inner ... Read More
636997225586
$34.95 $20.97

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Candy Cane Pop Rocks

Candy Cane Pop Rocks
previous / next
Santa likes to feed Candy Cane Pop Rocks to his reindeer...it puts a little extra ... Read More
530040
$1.50 $0.90

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Teeny Tiny Nativity Kit

Teeny Tiny Nativity Kit
previous / next
Bring back the magic of the holiday season with the Teeny-Tiny Nativity Kit! In a ... Read More
10000161
$9.95 $5.97

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Skiing Santa Wind up

Skiing Santa Wind up
previous / next
This little Santa is the perfect stocking stuffer. Wind him up and watch him ski ... Read More
10002134
$2.95 $1.77

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Coal Hard Candy

Coal Hard Candy
previous / next
This tasty, cinnamon-flavored candy makes a perfect stocking stuffer! Give even those on the naughty ... Read More
10002765
$4.95 $2.97

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Chocolate Marshmallow Stirrers

Pack of 6
Chocolate Marshmallow Stirrers
previous / next
Perfect for flavoring any hot beverage; simply place in your drink, stir and enjoy! Includes ... Read More
521406
$8.95 $5.37

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Holiday Magic Butterfly

Holiday Magic Butterfly
previous / next
Place this magic butterfly in a greeting card or book and watch the unsuspecting recipient ... Read More
10002952
$6.95 $4.17

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Holiday Village Tea

Holiday Village Tea
previous / next
Made exclusively for Paper Source, this Republic of Tea tin features an adorable holiday village. ... Read More
10002281
$14.95 $8.97

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Sugarfina Reindeer Noses

Sugarfina Reindeer Noses
previous / next
An ode to Rudolph, these juicy raspberry jellies are coated in tiny red non-perils. A ... Read More
10002763
$9.95 $5.97

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Reindeer Glitter Sunglasses

Reindeer Glitter Sunglasses
previous / next
Be the most glamorous reindeer in the room with these gold glitter shades! Perfect for ... Read More
512133
$7.95 $4.77

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Narwhal Ornament

Narwhal Ornament
previous / next
This friendly narwhal ornament is designed exclusively by Paper Source. Featuring metallic accents and beautiful ... Read More
512143
$14.95 $8.97

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Small Penguin Ornament

Small Penguin Ornament
previous / next
This little penguin will add a nice finishing touch to your Christmas treee. ... Read More
512160
$9.95 $5.97

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Glass Whale Ornament

Glass Whale Ornament
previous / next
Celebrate the holidays with this wonderful glass ornament. A unique maritime icon to hang from ... Read More
521364
$14.95 $8.97

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Santa Merman Ornament

Santa Merman Ornament
previous / next
This ornament features a Santa merman! Paper Source Exclusive.5 inches long ... Read More
10002155
$7.95 $4.77

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Pink Flamingo Felt Ornament

Pink Flamingo Felt Ornament
previous
Decorate your tree with this pink, felt flamingo ornament! Paper Source Exclusive.6 inches tall ... Read More
10002193
$12.95 $7.77

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.
Arrow pointing to top