25-50% Off Custom Stamps >

Photo Cards · Personalized Gifts · Holiday Shop

Free Standard Shipping on Orders $50+    ends January 25 · details >

Valentine Collection

Mix & Match Critter Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 36
Mix & Match Critter Valentine Card Kit
next
You’ll have a whole lot of fun pairing a top and bottom half to create ... Read More
10002927
$19.95

Fish Valentines Card Kit

Pack of 32
Fish Valentines Card Kit
previous / next
This year, your Valentines will be the catch of the day! With 32 cute fish ... Read More
10002928
$19.95

Red Glitter Heart Box

Red Glitter Heart Box
previous / next
This festive heart-shaped box features a sparkly, red design that's perfect for the season! Use ... Read More
10002747
$5.95

Superheroes Valentines Card Kit

Pack of 32
Superheroes Valentines Card Kit
previous / next
Send your Valentine’s Day greetings with these powerful superheroes! Customize your superhero friends with different ... Read More
10003121
$19.95

Heart Box of Assorted Chocolates

Heart Box of Assorted Chocolates
previous / next
Nothing beats a box of chocolates! Gift one of these heart shaped boxes filled with ... Read More
10003085
$9.95

Dino-mite Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 32
Dino-mite Valentine Card Kit
previous / next
A t-riffic Valentine is within arm's reach with these fierce friends! The smiles on these ... Read More
10000021
$19.95

Hot Pink Heart Sunglasses

Hot Pink Heart Sunglasses
previous / next
You're sure to feel the love this Valentine's Day with these Paper Source exclusive, hot ... Read More
10002643
$6.95

Heart Junior Mints

Heart Junior Mints
previous / next
Snack on your favorite Junior Mints candy in heart shapes! A perfect treat for Valentine's ... Read More
071720539620
$2.95

Hello Love Super Sticker Pack

Hello Love Super Sticker Pack
previous / next
Spread the love with this heart-y sticker collection of red foil lips, long stemmed roses, ... Read More
10002666
$9.95

Alien Valentines Card Kit

Pack of 32
Alien Valentines Card Kit
previous / next
Who wouldn’t be over the moon to get one of these adorable aliens? They're the ... Read More
10002926
$19.95

Puppies & Kittens Valentine Craft Kit

Pack of 28
Puppies & Kittens Valentine Craft Kit
previous / next
Send sweet greetings this Valentine's Day with these furry friends! Complete with playful stickers that ... Read More
4071295711
$19.95

Scratch Off Jokes Kids Valentine Pack

Pack of 28
Scratch Off Jokes Kids Valentine Pack
previous / next
These Valentine joke cards are sure to be the classroom favorite this year! Scratch off ... Read More
643356051595
$14.95

Heart Wind Up

Heart Wind Up
previous / next
This little pink heart is the perfect addition to a Valentine's Day goody bag or ... Read More
10002692
$3.95

Rainbows & Sunshines Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 32
Rainbows & Sunshines Valentine Card Kit
previous / next
The forecast for Valentine’s Day this year? Sunny with a chance of smiles! Have fun ... Read More
10002931
$19.95

Airplanes Kids Valentine Pack

Pack of 28
Airplanes Kids Valentine Pack
previous / next
The Valentine Airplanes Card Pack includes four styles of fun paper airplane Valentines that kids ... Read More
643356047369
$14.95

Robot Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 32
Robot Valentine Card Kit
previous / next
Gear up to give your pals the perfect Valentines! Mix and match to create a ... Read More
10002929
$19.95

Plantable Hearts

Plantable Hearts
previous / next
These adorable pink, red, and white paper hearts are embedded with the seeds of wildflower ... Read More
491665
$8.95

Bubbles Multi Pack

Set of 8
Bubbles Multi Pack
previous / next
You are never too old to play with bubbles! This set of eight clear bubbles ... Read More
521695
$9.95

Cupid Mini Boo

Cupid Mini Boo
previous / next
Give a Boo to your boo with this adorable little Valentine's Day stuffed Boo puppy ... Read More
10002828
$14.95

Whale Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 32
Whale Valentine Card Kit
previous / next
You'll have a whale of a time making these adorable, whale Valentines! Show your friends ... Read More
10000019
$19.95

Flick 'em Sports Valentines

Flick 'em Sports Valentines
previous / next
Featuring 28 cleverly designed cards and envelopes, this Super Valentine Fun Pack lets your child ... Read More
10002137
$14.95

Milk & Cookies Valentines

Milk & Cookies Valentines
previous / next
Add some sweetness to your kids' classroom Valentine exchanges with this scratch and sniff milk ... Read More
10002138
$14.95

Shark Love Valentine's Card Set

Set of 24
Shark Love Valentine's Card Set
previous / next
This unique set of 24 cards features four friendly sharks, each with its own Valentine ... Read More
10000009
$19.95

Pink Soapstone Heart

Pink Soapstone Heart
previous / next
This hot pink heart is made of Soapstone from Kenya and is a loving gift ... Read More
10002827
$4.95

Card in a Drawer Valentine Card

Card in a Drawer Valentine Card
previous / next
This cute Valentine's Day card is perfect for your significant other. Features the words, "Someday, ... Read More
815429013506
$3.95

Unicorn Rainbow Charms Valentines

Unicorn Rainbow Charms Valentines
previous / next
Perfect for classroom Valentine exchanges, this fun Valentine pack of 28 includes four styles of ... Read More
10002136
$14.95

Jungle Cats Valentine Cards

Set of 28
Jungle Cats Valentine Cards
previous / next
Send some wild Valentine wishes with this set of 28 unique, double sided card designs ... Read More
10000104
$16.50

Letterpress A2 Love Pizzas Valentine Card

Letterpress A2 Love Pizzas Valentine Card
previous / next
It's hard to love anything more than pizza, but this card is meant for someone ... Read More
3909991377
$4.95

Doggone Fun Valentine Cards

Set of 28
Doggone Fun Valentine Cards
previous / next
These Valentines are perfect for the dog-lover to send love to their friends! This set ... Read More
10000102
$16.50

Be Mine Valentine Card

Be Mine Valentine Card
previous / next
This heartfelt and handmade card features a sweet little bumble bee with delicate script spelling ... Read More
456341
$6.95

Sugarfina Flamingo Gummies

Sugarfina Flamingo Gummies
previous / next
Treat your taste buds with these delicious, Sugarfina, pink flamingo gummies in Paper Source exclusive ... Read More
10003371
$9.95

Dinosaur Valentine Set

Set of 28
Dinosaur Valentine Set
previous / next
This pack of Dino-themed Valentines includes four unique card designs featuring fun dinosaurs and punny ... Read More
10002627
$16.50

Rainbow Hearts Valentine Card

Rainbow Hearts Valentine Card
previous / next
This sweet Valentine's Day card features beautiful, rainbow, watercolor painted hearts with gold foil accents. ... Read More
10002613
$4.95

Meat Loaf You Valentine Card

Meat Loaf You Valentine Card
previous / next
This enthusiastic entrée will bring a smile to your sweetheart's face this Valentine's Day. It ... Read More
569809
$5.95

Made For Each Otter A6 Valentine Card

Made For Each Otter A6 Valentine Card
previous / next
Nothing says love like two otters floating together; they are one of the few animals ... Read More
4661008014
$3.95

I Like You Cherry Much Tea

I Like You Cherry Much Tea
previous / next
Indulge in this delicious Republic of Tea spring cherry green tea! Featuring an adorable Paper ... Read More
10002691
$14.95

Felt Heart Pouch

Felt Heart Pouch
previous / next
Fill this red and pink felt pouch with goodies this Valentine's Day! A perfect gift ... Read More
10002864
$9.95

Strawberry Champagne Lollipops

Set of 4
Strawberry Champagne Lollipops
previous / next
Enjoy these sophisticated and gourmet strawberry and champagne lollipops! Complete with four lollipops on wooden ... Read More
521702
$9.95

Magic Valentine Cards

Set of 28
Magic Valentine Cards
previous / next
Make this Valentine's Day magical with these double-sided flat cards that come in four designs, ... Read More
10000103
$16.50 $8.25

Meri Meri Colorful Hearts and Glitter Sticker Pack

Meri Meri Colorful Hearts and Glitter Sticker Pack
previous / next
Decorate your Valentine's Day gifts and crafting projects with these colorful and glitter heart stickers. ... Read More
10002605
$7.95

Tasty Treats Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 32
Tasty Treats Valentine Card Kit
previous / next
Everyone knows that they way to a person's heart is through the stomach, so treat ... Read More
10000016
$19.95

Fairy Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 32
Fairy Valentine Card Kit
previous / next
Delight your friends with these enchanting and sweet, fairy Valentines! You can even choose each ... Read More
10002930
$19.95

Outer Space Valentines and Tattoos

Pack of 24
Outer Space Valentines and Tattoos
previous / next
Send your love letters into space with this fabulous Meri Meri Valentine's Day card set ... Read More
10002875
$19.95

Dino Love Card

Dino Love Card
previous / next
Well we're doing just fine without the dinosaurs, but if you didn't have this special ... Read More
4661008343
$5.95

Greenery Valentine Card

Greenery Valentine Card
previous / next
A beautiful watercolor floral pops with gold foil details on this card that elegantly wishes ... Read More
10002616
$4.95

Moon & Back Banner Valentine Card

Moon & Back Banner Valentine Card
previous / next
Now they'll never have to ask because they'll know just how much they're loved. This ... Read More
569808
$5.95

Lucky Night Bear Valentine Card

Lucky Night Bear Valentine Card
previous / next
Show your love with this humorous Valentine's day card - perfect for sending to your ... Read More
10002934
$5.95

Pizza My Heart Card

Pizza My Heart Card
previous
Share a slice of pizza, topped with heart-shaped pepperoni, with that special someone. Single card. ... Read More
4661008346
$3.95

Valentine Collection

Our Valentine collection features unique gifts for all ages from pretty presents for your favorite gal pal to sweet sentiments for the one you love. Unique Valentine candy and playful toys are fun for kids, and exclusive gifts featuring Paper Source artwork are one of a kind designs that anyone will love.

Arrow pointing to top