Save up to 40% on Personalized Stationery →
20% Off 5 or more Greeting Cards →
Hundreds of Gifts, Crafts & more on sale! Shop Paper Cuts →
Free Standard Shipping on orders $60+ →
10% Off when you sign up for SMS alerts →
  • Go to slide 1
  • Go to slide 2
  • Go to slide 3
  • Go to slide 4
  • Go to slide 5
Login My Favorites

Cart

Your cart is empty

All products

Sort by

16871 Results

Sold outSave 30%Smells Like Summer Scented CandleSmells Like Summer Scented Candle
Smells Like Summer Scented CandlePaper Source Sale price$13.99 Regular price$19.99
Modern Diamond Custom Embosser PlateModern Diamond Custom Embosser Plate
Modern Diamond Custom Embosser PlatePaper Source Sale price$31.50 Each
Peppermint Border Holiday Gift Tag Label
Peppermint Border Holiday Gift Tag LabelPaper Source Sale price$0.35 Each
Warm Stripe Custom JournalWarm Stripe Custom Journal
Warm Stripe Custom JournalPaper Source Sale price$19.95
Sophisticat Stationery
Sophisticat StationeryPaper Source Sale price$2.03 Each
Key Custom Stamp and Stamp Tool
Key Custom Stamp and Stamp ToolPaper Source Sale price$39.95
Watercolor Stripes Custom JournalWatercolor Stripes Custom Journal
Watercolor Stripes Custom JournalPaper Source Sale price$19.95
Smiling Pumpkin Plates
Smiling Pumpkin PlatesPaper Source

Set of 10

Sale price$10.50
Citrus Floral Custom JournalCitrus Floral Custom Journal
Citrus Floral Custom JournalPaper Source Sale price$19.95
Sold outCarver Jack o' Lantern 5" Palm Pals
Carver Jack o' Lantern 5" Palm Pals Sale price$9.99
Cuddly KittenCuddly Kitten
Cuddly Kitten Sale price$24.99
Scroll Bracket Custom StampStep-by-step video detailing how to replace the custom stamp plate.
Scroll Bracket Custom StampPaper Source Sale price$29.95
Border Caps Couple Custom Stamp and Stamp Tool
Border Caps Couple Custom Stamp and Stamp ToolPaper Source Sale price$39.95
Laurel Frame Custom StampStep-by-step video detailing how to replace the custom stamp plate.
Laurel Frame Custom StampPaper Source Sale price$29.95
Thin Line Graduation Party InvitationThin Line Graduation Party Invitation
Thin Line Graduation Party InvitationPaper Source Sale price$3.19 Each
Brushstroke Underscore Custom Stamp and Stamp ToolStep-by-step video detailing how to replace the custom stamp plate.
Brushstroke Underscore Custom Stamp and Stamp ToolPaper Source Sale price$39.95
Sold outVivacious Pumpkin Plush - In Store Exclusive
Vivacious Pumpkin Plush - In Store Exclusive Sale price$23.00
Our House Custom StampStep-by-step video detailing how to replace the custom stamp plate.
Our House Custom StampPaper Source Sale price$29.95
2026-2027 Paper Source Grid 17 Month Calendar2026-2027 Paper Source Grid 17 Month Calendar
2026-2027 Paper Source Grid 17 Month CalendarPaper Source Sale price$22.99
2026-2027 Paper Source Tapestries Weekly Desk Planner2026-2027 Paper Source Tapestries Weekly Desk Planner
2026-2027 Paper Source Tapestries Weekly Desk PlannerPaper Source Sale price$34.99
Botanical Birthday CardBotanical Birthday Card
Botanical Birthday Card Sale price$6.50
Assorted Striped Party Hats Set of 8Assorted Striped Party Hats Set of 8
Assorted Striped Party Hats Set of 8 Sale price$13.50
Spring Florals Double Sided Flat Wrap
Spring Florals Double Sided Flat Wrap Sale price$6.50
Lunar New Year Year of the Horse Envelope SetLunar New Year Year of the Horse Envelope Set
Lunar New Year Year of the Horse Envelope SetPaper Source

Set of 10

Sale price$15.50
Birthday Girl Balloons Specialty Glitter Card
Birthday Girl Balloons Specialty Glitter Card Sale price$12.50
Birthday Star Birthday CardBirthday Star Birthday Card
Birthday Star Birthday Card Sale price$7.50
Paper Mache Floral Tree Ornament
Paper Mache Floral Tree Ornament Sale price$9.99
Menorah Paper GlassesMenorah Paper Glasses
Menorah Paper Glasses Sale price$11.50
To Know You Love Card
To Know You Love Card Sale price$7.50
Sold outWhite Vintage Ceramic Christmas Tree Night Light
White Vintage Ceramic Christmas Tree Night Light Sale price$24.99
Sold outFolding Leather Wireless Phone Charging StandFolding Leather Wireless Phone Charging Stand
Folding Leather Wireless Phone Charging Stand Sale price$26.99
Watercolor Stripes Mixed Personalized Notepads
Watercolor Stripes Mixed Personalized NotepadsPaper Source Sale price$35.00
Jingle All The Way Christmas Card
Jingle All The Way Christmas Card Sale price$6.50
Sold outPink Roller Suitcase Glass Ornament
Pink Roller Suitcase Glass Ornament Sale price$24.99
Parmesan Glass Ornament
Parmesan Glass Ornament Sale price$24.99
Holiday Village Cookbook Stand
Holiday Village Cookbook Stand Sale price$29.99
Thanksgiving Trees Thanksgiving Card
Thanksgiving Trees Thanksgiving Card Sale price$6.50
Halloween Charm BraceletHalloween Charm Bracelet
Halloween Charm BraceletPaper Source Sale price$10.99
ANNIV So Far So Good
ANNIV So Far So Good Sale price$7.50
Sold outBLUEY S11 FIGURE 4PK COSTUME PARTYBLUEY S11 FIGURE 4PK COSTUME PARTY
BLUEY S11 FIGURE 4PK COSTUME PARTY Sale price$16.99
Smoko Miffy Goes Pastel Blind Box FigureSmoko Miffy Goes Pastel Blind Box Figure
Smoko Miffy Goes Pastel Blind Box Figure Sale price$15.00
Dying Young Birthday Card
Dying Young Birthday Card Sale price$6.50
Sold outCactus Sunset Thank You Card
Cactus Sunset Thank You Card Sale price$6.50
Alphabet Soup Love Card
Alphabet Soup Love Card Sale price$7.50
Aster Paper Wrapped Picture FrameAster Paper Wrapped Picture Frame
Aster Paper Wrapped Picture FrameRifle Paper Co. Sale price$24.00
Cat GlassesCat Glasses
Cat GlassesPaper Source Sale price$10.99
Tank the Shark, The Woobles Beginner Crochet Kit - ExclusiveTank the Shark, The Woobles Beginner Crochet Kit - Exclusive
Tank the Shark, The Woobles Beginner Crochet Kit - Exclusive Sale price$34.99
Reel Cool Dad Socks ExclusiveReel Cool Dad Socks Exclusive
Reel Cool Dad Socks ExclusivePaper Source Sale price$9.99