Shop in stores for Valentine's Day: Early hours now available! Find Your Store →
Up to 40% Off Personalized Stationery →
20% Off Greeting Cards when you buy 5 or more →
50% Off 2026 Calendars & Planners →
Free Standard Shipping on Orders $50+ →
  • Go to slide 1
  • Go to slide 2
  • Go to slide 3
  • Go to slide 4
  • Go to slide 5
Login My Favorites

Cart

Your cart is empty

Gifts

Gifts

Shop our unique collection of gifts for everyone young and old including personalized gifts like journals and planners, calendars, games, puzzles, children’s toys, beauty and wellness essentials, kitchen tools and quirky gifts that they will thank you for with a smile.  

Gifts for Her

Gifts for Kids

Our Favorite Gifts

Gifts for Him

The Best Toys & Plush

625666110.jpg625168831.jpg
MAGNA-TILES® microMAGS Spring Garden Travel Set 24-Piece Magnetic Construction Set, The Original Magnetic Building Brand Sale price$19.99
624225908.jpg624225910.jpg
Tayto Chubby Cats Blind Box Figure Sale price$15.00
625750683.jpg625666115.jpg
MAGNA-TILES® Hamster Ball 13-Piece Magnetic Construction Set, The Original Magnetic Building Brand Sale price$17.99
Orange Mushroom Ambient Light
Orange Mushroom Ambient Light Sale price$27.50
Crags 300 CoralCrags 300 Coral
Crags 300 Coral Sale price$26.99
3Doodler Candy 3D Pen Set for Kids, Create with Real Candy You Can Eat, Easy to Use, Activity Guide and Refill Candy Included, Boys & Girls Ages 6+3Doodler Candy 3D Pen Set for Kids, Create with Real Candy You Can Eat, Easy to Use, Activity Guide and Refill Candy Included, Boys & Girls Ages 6+
3Doodler Candy 3D Pen Set for Kids, Create with Real Candy You Can Eat, Easy to Use, Activity Guide and Refill Candy Included, Boys & Girls Ages 6+ Sale price$59.99
MAGNA-TILES microMAGS Travel Set, 26-Piece Magnetic Construction Set, The ORIGINAL Magnetic Building BrandMAGNA-TILES microMAGS Travel Set, 26-Piece Magnetic Construction Set, The ORIGINAL Magnetic Building Brand
MAGNA-TILES microMAGS Travel Set, 26-Piece Magnetic Construction Set, The ORIGINAL Magnetic Building Brand Sale price$19.99
Spudsters Bee PlushSpudsters Bee Plush
Spudsters Bee Plush Sale price$19.99
Paint & Peel Jelly StickersPaint & Peel Jelly Stickers
Paint & Peel Jelly Stickers Sale price$22.99
3Doodler Start+ Essentials 3D Pen Set for Kids, Easy to Use, Learn from Home Art Activity Set, Educational STEM Toy for Boys & Girls Ages 6+3Doodler Start+ Essentials 3D Pen Set for Kids, Easy to Use, Learn from Home Art Activity Set, Educational STEM Toy for Boys & Girls Ages 6+
3Doodler Start+ Essentials 3D Pen Set for Kids, Easy to Use, Learn from Home Art Activity Set, Educational STEM Toy for Boys & Girls Ages 6+ Sale price$59.99
Azalea PlushAzalea Plush
Azalea Plush Sale price$19.99
624509891.jpg624509945.jpg
mofusand Meow Pants Blind Box Sale price$8.00
Shop All Toys & Plush

Sweet Gifting Moments

Valentine's Day Gifts

Games & Puzzles

LEGO Sets
625080684.jpg625018542.jpg
Sweet Little Jewelry Box Sale price$34.95
625081100.jpg625081110.jpg
Romeo and Juliet Wherefore Art Thou Heart Tote Bag Sale price$24.99
624452825.jpg624452815.jpg
Strawberry Farm Beaded Tote Sale price$32.99
625080683.jpg625080931.jpg
Getaway Toiletry Bag, Cherry Lips Sale price$26.95
624378506.jpg
Fuzzy Strawberry Sock - AdultPaper Source Sale price$16.99
624378505.jpg624378977.jpg
Cherry Mini Hair Clips- Set of 2Paper Source Sale price$9.99
625080688.jpg625080939.jpg
Lola Pink Beaded Hair Clip Sale price$28.00
625080692.jpg
Cup Cozy Crochet with Heart Sale price$16.99
Valentines Squishies, Set of 6
Valentines Squishies, Set of 6

Set of 6

Sale price$10.99
624058476.jpg
Bucket List Scratch Book - Dates Edition Sale price$29.99
Shop Valentine's Day Gifts

Fresh Start to the New Year

623901769.jpg

Beauty & Wellness

Candles & Diffusers

Journals & Notebooks

Fashion Accessories
Save 50%2026 Pressed Flowers A3 Wall Calendar2026 Pressed Flowers A3 Wall Calendar
2026 Pressed Flowers A3 Wall Calendar Sale price$15.99 Regular price$31.99
Save 50%2026 Dear Hancock Bunny Calendar-Hare at the Caf2026 Dear Hancock Bunny Calendar-Hare at the Caf
2026 Dear Hancock Bunny Calendar-Hare at the Caf Sale price$11.50 Regular price$23.00
Save 50%2026 Paper Source Catitude Desk Easel Calendar2026 Paper Source Catitude Desk Easel Calendar
2026 Paper Source Catitude Desk Easel Calendar Sale price$10.99 Regular price$21.99
Save 50%2026 Wildwood Brass Easel Desk Calendar2026 Wildwood Brass Easel Desk Calendar
2026 Wildwood Brass Easel Desk Calendar Sale price$19.00 Regular price$38.00
Save 50%2025-2026 Paper Source Family Wall Calendar2025-2026 Paper Source Family Wall Calendar
2025-2026 Paper Source Family Wall CalendarPaper Source Sale price$14.99 Regular price$29.99
Save 50%2026 Paper Source Mushroom Letterpress Desk Easel Calendar2026 Paper Source Mushroom Letterpress Desk Easel Calendar
2026 Paper Source Mushroom Letterpress Desk Easel Calendar Sale price$13.49 Regular price$26.99
Save 50%2026 Mountain Art Wall Calendar2026 Mountain Art Wall Calendar
2026 Mountain Art Wall Calendar Sale price$15.99 Regular price$31.99
Save 50%624029664.jpg624029663.jpg
2026 Wicked 2 Wall Calendar Sale price$9.99 Regular price$19.99
Save 50%2026 Texts from Mittens the Cat Day-to-Day Calendar2026 Texts from Mittens the Cat Day-to-Day Calendar
2026 Texts from Mittens the Cat Day-to-Day Calendar Sale price$8.99 Regular price$17.99
Save 50%2026 Daily Bitch, The Boxed/Daily Calendar2026 Daily Bitch, The Boxed/Daily Calendar
2026 Daily Bitch, The Boxed/Daily Calendar Sale price$9.49 Regular price$18.99
Shop 2026 Calendars

Shop by Category

Home Décor
624462483.jpg

Bags & Totes

Journals

Activities

Kids' Toys & Games

Books

Personalized Gifts

Gift Cards
Sloth Ambient Light
Sloth Ambient Light Sale price$27.50
Swan Bottle OpenerSwan Bottle Opener
Swan Bottle Opener Sale price$19.99
Live Laugh Loathe Cross Stitch Kit
Live Laugh Loathe Cross Stitch Kit Sale price$20.00
Farfalle Bowtie Pasta Enamel Keychain
Farfalle Bowtie Pasta Enamel Keychain Sale price$16.00
Huckleberry Landscape Paint
Huckleberry Landscape Paint Sale price$21.00
Fred Use Your Noodle - Lasagna BookmarkFred Use Your Noodle - Lasagna Bookmark
Fred Use Your Noodle - Lasagna Bookmark Sale price$9.00
Little Letters for Lunch: Keep it short and sweet.Little Letters for Lunch: Keep it short and sweet.
Little Letters for Lunch: Keep it short and sweet. Sale price$9.95
Gold Bling MicrophoneGold Bling Microphone
Gold Bling Microphone Sale price$56.00
The Secret Thoughts of CatsThe Secret Thoughts of Cats
The Secret Thoughts of Cats Sale price$13.95
The Secret Thoughts of DogsThe Secret Thoughts of Dogs
The Secret Thoughts of Dogs Sale price$13.95
The Little Frog's Guide to Self-Care: Affirmations, Self-Love and Life Lessons According to the Internet's Beloved Mushroom FrogThe Little Frog's Guide to Self-Care: Affirmations, Self-Love and Life Lessons According to the Internet's Beloved Mushroom Frog
The Little Frog's Guide to Self-Care: Affirmations, Self-Love and Life Lessons According to the Internet's Beloved Mushroom Frog Sale price$11.99
The Little Book of Foreign Swear Words
The Little Book of Foreign Swear Words Sale price$9.99
Edibles: Small Bites for the Modern Cannabis KitchenEdibles: Small Bites for the Modern Cannabis Kitchen
Edibles: Small Bites for the Modern Cannabis Kitchen Sale price$19.95
Bob Ross Sticky Notes
Bob Ross Sticky Notes Sale price$7.99
Emergency Dad Jokes
Emergency Dad Jokes Sale price$12.00
Fuzzies by Alex Hague, Justin Vickers, Wolfgang WarschFuzzies by Alex Hague, Justin Vickers, Wolfgang Warsch
Fuzzies by Alex Hague, Justin Vickers, Wolfgang Warsch Sale price$17.99
How To Speak CatHow To Speak Cat
How To Speak Cat Sale price$12.50
Be Present Gel Phone ClingsBe Present Gel Phone Clings
Be Present Gel Phone Clings

Set of 4

Sale price$12.99
Swearing Helps Socks
Swearing Helps Socks Sale price$10.99
Chaos Coordinator Socks
Chaos Coordinator Socks Sale price$10.99
Shop Quirky Gifts

Shop by Price

Gifts under $50.
Gifts under $30.
Gifts under $20.
Gifts under $10.

Unique Gift Ideas

Shop our specially curated selection of unique gifts for all ages and occasions. We’ve got gifts for every holiday and season including birthdays, Christmas, Hanukkah, Easter, Father’s Day, Mother’s Day, and more. Whether you’re searching for a gift for grandma, your sister, or coworkers, our gift ideas will inspire giving in a fun and personal way! Browse through a variety of themed gifts including calendars and planners, journals and candles, and drinkware to find the perfect gift for your teen, husband, or wine loving friend. Explore our selection of trending books, décor, useful gadgets, adult games and puzzles, and toys for kids.

Discover uncommon gifts at Paper Source. Whether you’re looking for gift ideas for your girlfriend, parents, or your teacher, we have plenty of wonderful gifts under $20 and $30. From wine glasses and slippers that mom would love to coffee mugs and socks for dad, find gifts for everyone on your shopping list. Check out our personalized gift guide for more gift ideas!