Free Standard Shipping $60+ →
Login My Favorites

Cart

Your cart is empty

Gifts By Categories

Sort by

2149 Results

Unicorn KidDough Kit
Unicorn KidDough Kit Sale price$22.99
Darcy Floral Tote Bag with Zipper ClosureDarcy Floral Tote Bag with Zipper Closure
Darcy Floral Tote Bag with Zipper Closure Sale price$34.00
Calico CatCalico Cat
Calico Cat Sale price$29.99
Sad Stuffies HenrietteSad Stuffies Henriette
Sad Stuffies Henriette Sale price$39.99
Sad Stuffies JackSad Stuffies Jack
Sad Stuffies Jack Sale price$39.99
Cat & Pumpkin Punch Needle KitCat & Pumpkin Punch Needle Kit
Cat & Pumpkin Punch Needle Kit Sale price$29.99
A Perfect Match Ceramic MatchboxA Perfect Match Ceramic Matchbox
A Perfect Match Ceramic Matchbox Sale price$19.99
Art Sack - Anna Hoyle Useless BooksArt Sack - Anna Hoyle Useless Books
Art Sack - Anna Hoyle Useless Books Sale price$14.00
Clixo - Tiny & MightyClixo - Tiny & Mighty
Clixo - Tiny & Mighty Sale price$14.99
Moon Phases Ceramic Candle Jasmine and Rose 8 Oz
Moon Phases Ceramic Candle Jasmine and Rose 8 Oz Sale price$32.00
Play Doh Blooms Meadow Bouquet KitPlay Doh Blooms Meadow Bouquet Kit
Play Doh Blooms Meadow Bouquet Kit Sale price$39.99
Edgar the Skeleton ExclusiveEdgar the Skeleton Exclusive
Edgar the Skeleton Exclusive

Get It Before It's Gone

Sale price$29.99
LEGO Iconic Jack-O'-Lantern Pickup Truck 40822LEGO Iconic Jack-O'-Lantern Pickup Truck 40822
LEGO Iconic Jack-O'-Lantern Pickup Truck 40822 Sale price$14.99
LEGO Iconic Altar of the Dead 40811LEGO Iconic Altar of the Dead 40811
LEGO Iconic Altar of the Dead 40811 Sale price$14.99
Kind Bag - Cream CrossbodyKind Bag - Cream Crossbody
Kind Bag - Cream Crossbody Sale price$44.95
Vitamin C Shower Filter - Lavender LandVitamin C Shower Filter - Lavender Land
Vitamin C Shower Filter - Lavender Land Sale price$29.00
White Vetiver Petite Scented CandleWhite Vetiver Petite Scented Candle
White Vetiver Petite Scented Candle Sale price$25.00
Pretty Anxious Zipper Pouch
Pretty Anxious Zipper Pouch Sale price$13.95
Baby PumpkinBaby Pumpkin
Baby Pumpkin Sale price$19.99
5" MILA DRUMSTICK5" MILA DRUMSTICK
5" MILA DRUMSTICK Sale price$11.99
Beginner's Quilling KitBeginner's Quilling Kit
Beginner's Quilling Kit Sale price$29.99
The Original MAGNA-TILES® microMAGS Cube Pack 9-Piece Magnetic Construction SetThe Original MAGNA-TILES® microMAGS Cube Pack 9-Piece Magnetic Construction Set
The Original MAGNA-TILES® microMAGS Cube Pack 9-Piece Magnetic Construction Set Sale price$19.99
The Tiny Bookshop Craft KitThe Tiny Bookshop Craft Kit
The Tiny Bookshop Craft Kit Sale price$17.99
Folktale Embroidered PouchFolktale Embroidered Pouch
Folktale Embroidered Pouch Sale price$24.99
That Cabin Life Stovetop SimmerThat Cabin Life Stovetop Simmer
That Cabin Life Stovetop Simmer Sale price$25.00
Gardenland Frog Trinket TrayGardenland Frog Trinket Tray
Gardenland Frog Trinket Tray Sale price$12.99
Turkey Wine Bottle StopperTurkey Wine Bottle Stopper
Turkey Wine Bottle Stopper Sale price$12.99
Folktale Midi MugFolktale Midi Mug
Folktale Midi Mug Sale price$14.99
Folktale Tote Bag
Folktale Tote Bag Sale price$29.99
The Crandle - Cranberry Sauce CandleThe Crandle - Cranberry Sauce Candle
The Crandle - Cranberry Sauce Candle Sale price$32.00
The Butter BookThe Butter Book
The Butter Book Sale price$19.95
Butter Stick with It Bookmark
Butter Stick with It Bookmark Sale price$10.00
Palo Santo and Sage Incense in Glass Jar -100 SticksVideo of Paper Source staff showing the Palo Santo Incense Jar.
Palo Santo and Sage Incense in Glass Jar -100 Sticks

Staff Favorite!

Sale price$22.00
Charcoal Mini Scented Candle TinCharcoal Mini Scented Candle Tin
Charcoal Mini Scented Candle Tin Sale price$12.00
Bitter Cherry Mini Scented Candle TinBitter Cherry Mini Scented Candle Tin
Bitter Cherry Mini Scented Candle Tin Sale price$12.00
Forage Canvas ToteForage Canvas Tote
Forage Canvas Tote Sale price$32.00
Mint Heel Repair DuoMint Heel Repair Duo
Mint Heel Repair Duo Sale price$22.00
Cats Are My Friends rectangular MagnetCats Are My Friends rectangular Magnet
Cats Are My Friends rectangular Magnet Sale price$4.99
Explore The Great Indoors rectangular MagnetExplore The Great Indoors rectangular Magnet
Explore The Great Indoors rectangular Magnet Sale price$4.99
Tales by the Campfire Candle - 8ozTales by the Campfire Candle - 8oz
Tales by the Campfire Candle - 8oz Sale price$27.95
The Pumpkin ThiefThe Pumpkin Thief
The Pumpkin Thief Sale price$18.99
Rewined Tea Candle Set
Rewined Tea Candle Set Sale price$34.99
Felted ghost dog ornamentFelted ghost dog ornament
Felted ghost dog ornamentPaper Source Sale price$9.99
Cat HumidifierCat Humidifier
Cat Humidifier Sale price$39.99
LEGO Ideas Floating Sea Otters 21366LEGO Ideas Floating Sea Otters 21366
LEGO Ideas Floating Sea Otters 21366 Sale price$119.99
The Skeleton and the CatThe Skeleton and the Cat
The Skeleton and the Cat Sale price$19.99
Cat in Pumpkin Statement Earring
Cat in Pumpkin Statement Earring Sale price$29.99
Save 20%2027 Paper Source Sage Weekly Pocket Planner2027 Paper Source Sage Weekly Pocket Planner
2027 Paper Source Sage Weekly Pocket Planner

Online Only

Paper Source Sale price$15.99 Regular price$19.99

By Category 

Need help finding the perfect gift? Easily shop our unique collection of gifts by category. If you know what your recipient likes, but want to see what the newest styles are, you can find it here by category. When you shop by category you’re sure to find the best deals on unique gifts like toys, games, books, sweets, treats, stylish accessories, and more.