Personalized

Colorful Type New Year New Years Photo Card Paper Source

$3.43 Each

Radiant Menorah Foil Frame Holiday Card Paper Source

$3.75 Each

Botanical Menorah Foil Frame Holiday Photo Card Paper Source

$3.75 Each

Holly and Stripes Party Invitation Paper Source

$3.25 Each

Scattered Snowflakes Foil Holiday Photo Card Paper Source

$3.75 Each

Candy Cane Argyle Holiday Photo Card Paper Source

$3.25 Each

Holiday Stamp Collage Holiday Photo Card Paper Source

$3.25 Each

Pinstripe Holiday Photo Card Paper Source

$3.25 Each

Caroling Gnomes Holiday Card Paper Source

$3.25 Each

Love Letter Return Address Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Estate Return Address Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Pirate Thank You Custom Stamp and Stamp Tool Paper Source

$39.95

Bistro Detail Custom Embosser Plate with Embossing Tool Paper Source

$60.00

Circle Ampersand Custom Embosser Plate with Embossing Tool Paper Source

$60.00 Each

Times Monogram Letterhead Custom Embosser Plate with Embossing Tool Paper Source

$60.00 Each

Vintage Swirl Letterhead Custom Embosser Plate with Embossing Tool Paper Source

$60.00 Each

Deco Return Address Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Tree of Life Bar Mitzvah Return Address Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Keepsake Letterhead Custom Embosser Plate with Embossing Tool Paper Source

$60.00 Each

Script Accent Custom Embosser Plate with Embossing Tool Paper Source

$60.00 Each

Vine Sans Surname Custom Embosser Plate and Embossing Tool Paper Source

$60.00 Each

Painted Snowflakes Holiday Gift Tag Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Holiday Flurry Gift Tag Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Peppermints Holiday Gift Tag Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Poinsettias Holiday Gift Tag Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Skate Pond Holiday Gift Tag Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

String Lights Holiday Gift Tag Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Micro Floral Holiday Gift Tag Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Peppermint Border Holiday Gift Tag Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Joy Holiday Gift Tag Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Beary Christmas Return Address Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Nordic Sweater Holiday Return Address Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Holiday Flurry Return Address Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Poinsettias Holiday Return Address Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Skate Pond Holiday Return Address Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Joy Holiday Return Address Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Peppermint Border Holiday Return Address Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Cardinal Holiday Return Address Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Dala Horse Return Address Labels Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Step-by-step video detailing how to replace the custom embosser plate.

Baby's Breath Custom Embosser Plate with Embossing Tool Paper Source

$60.00 Each

Love Letter Embosser Plate with Embossing Tool Paper Source

$60.00

Bakers Twine Holiday Gift Tag Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Peace Joy Love Brights Holiday Gift Tag Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Merry Christmas Gift Tag Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Pine Sprigs Return Address Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Ski Gnome Return Address Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Cardinal Return Address Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Big Dots Return Address Label Paper Source

$0.35 Each

Personalized Gifts

It’s impossible to deny that personalized gifts make the recipient feel special and cared for, and creating thoughtful and practical personalized items is something we’re proud of at Paper Source. We know that customizable gifts hold sentimental value and can be cherished for years to come which is why we offer so many options. Discover custom gifts for everyone from foodies to animal lovers and nature lovers to artists. From personalized stationery, planners, journals and notepads to custom embossers, stamps, stickers, art prints, cool barware and monogrammed travel accessories, there are so many custom gift ideas for friends, family and coworkers.

Personalized Stationery Gifts

Personalized stationery makes a unique gift that is timeless and practical. Stationery gifts are perfect for weddings, graduations, baby showers, milestone birthdays, housewarming gifts and other special occasions. We specialize in stationery, so our personalized notepads, notecards and letter paper are not just high-quality but thoughtfully designed by our in-house team here in Chicago. Classic, charming and playful, our custom planners, journals and notebooks make great gifts for business entrepreneurs, students, writers, moms and everyone in between. Customer embossers and stamps make fantastic gifts for people who like to get creative and enjoy adding a personal touch to everything they do.

Personalized Barware & Travel Gifts

Whether you’re looking for a personalized gift for a homebody or jetsetter, making gifts personalized and unique has never been easier. Just choose one of our premium bamboo cutting boards, coasters or luggage tags and we will take care of monogramming your friend’s or loved one’s initials. These useful yet sophisticated custom gifts will stand the test of time and always remind the gift recipient of your thoughtful gesture.

Personalized Gifts for Him Ideas

• Brown Tortoise Laser Cut Monogram Coasters

•Hand Drawn Scallop Paddle Cutting Board

•Tommaso Monogram Brown Luggage Tag

•12-Month Navy Watercolor Custom Planner

•Book Belongs Dots Custom Stamp

Personalized Gifts for Her Ideas

•City Windows Custom Journal

•Pearl Rose Laser Cut Monogram Coasters

•Filled Heart Two-Tone Cutting Board

•Book of Roses Custom Stamp

•12-Month Night Sky Custom Planner