20% Off Personalized Stationery →
30% Off Holiday Photo Cards →
Free Standard Shipping $60+ →
  • Go to slide 1
  • Go to slide 2
  • Go to slide 3
Login My Favorites

Cart

Your cart is empty

Gifts for Gift Exchanges

From white elephant exchanges to office parties and Secret Santa surprises, discover clever finds, playful picks, and thoughtful little gifts everyone will want to unwrap.

Sort by

83 Results

Floral Embroidered Rectangle Box
Floral Embroidered Rectangle Box Sale price$24.99
Swivel Cheese Board SetSwivel Cheese Board Set
Swivel Cheese Board SetPaper Source Sale price$42.99
Aster Paper Wrapped Picture FrameAster Paper Wrapped Picture Frame
Aster Paper Wrapped Picture FrameRifle Paper Co. Sale price$24.00
Penguin Village Porcelain OrnamentPenguin Village Porcelain Ornament
Penguin Village Porcelain Ornament Sale price$24.99
Happy Hats Beanie - Blue
Happy Hats Beanie - Blue Sale price$35.00
Rug MousepadRug Mousepad
Rug Mousepad Sale price$28.00
Book Lover Needle Point Ornament
Book Lover Needle Point OrnamentPaper Source Sale price$19.99
Inkerie Wireless Charger Grid
Inkerie Wireless Charger Grid Sale price$25.00
Fidget Cube By Antsy Labs Series 4 by ZURUFidget Cube By Antsy Labs Series 4 by ZURU
Fidget Cube By Antsy Labs Series 4 by ZURU Sale price$6.99
Butter CandleButter Candle
Butter Candle Sale price$14.99
Artichoke Recipe Tin
Artichoke Recipe TinRifle Paper Co. Sale price$38.00
Pack of 12 Artichoke Recipe Cards
Pack of 12 Artichoke Recipe CardsRifle Paper Co. Sale price$15.00
Harvest Reading ShawlHarvest Reading Shawl
Harvest Reading ShawlPaper Source Sale price$29.99
Year of Junk Journaling: 52 creative prompts to transform scraps of your life into art
Year of Junk Journaling: 52 creative prompts to transform scraps of your life into art Sale price$24.99
Miffy Christmas Dress with HatMiffy Christmas Dress with Hat
Miffy Christmas Dress with Hat Sale price$44.99
Cigar GlassCigar Glass
Cigar Glass Sale price$24.95
Festive Bows and Greenery BlanketFestive Bows and Greenery Blanket
Festive Bows and Greenery BlanketPaper Source Sale price$44.99
Pink and Green Rabbit SlippersPink and Green Rabbit Slippers
Pink and Green Rabbit Slippers

Staff Favorite!

Paper Source Sale price$26.99
Mood Alert Desktop PegboardMood Alert Desktop Pegboard
Mood Alert Desktop Pegboard Sale price$18.00
Tea Storage BoxTea Storage Box
Tea Storage BoxPaper Source Sale price$29.99
Vintage Jewelry BoxVintage Jewelry Box
Vintage Jewelry Box Sale price$34.99
Holiday Goose Plush ExclusiveHoliday Goose Plush Exclusive
Holiday Goose Plush Exclusive Sale price$24.99
Nodpod- The Weighted Blanket For Your Eyes- WisteriaNodpod- The Weighted Blanket For Your Eyes- Wisteria
Nodpod- The Weighted Blanket For Your Eyes- Wisteria

Staff Favorite!

Sale price$38.00
Gold Framed Art Magnets, Set of 2Gold Framed Art Magnets, Set of 2
Gold Framed Art Magnets, Set of 2Paper Source Sale price$24.99
Colorful Hand-Painted Ceramic Frame
Colorful Hand-Painted Ceramic FramePaper Source Sale price$24.99
The Collage Compendium: 2,000 Images to Cut Out & CollageThe Collage Compendium: 2,000 Images to Cut Out & Collage
The Collage Compendium: 2,000 Images to Cut Out & Collage Sale price$24.95
Starry Blue Knit BalaclavaStarry Blue Knit Balaclava
Starry Blue Knit BalaclavaPaper Source Sale price$29.99
Pumpkin Baker
Pumpkin Baker Sale price$14.99
Embroidered Photo Frame w/ Floral PatternEmbroidered Photo Frame w/ Floral Pattern
Embroidered Photo Frame w/ Floral PatternPaper Source Sale price$14.99
Snaili the SnailSnaili the Snail
Snaili the Snail Sale price$24.99
Ceramic Candle Night LightCeramic Candle Night Light
Ceramic Candle Night Light Sale price$29.99
Crags 300 CoralCrags 300 Coral
Crags 300 Coral Sale price$26.99
Sunset Light ProjectorSunset Light Projector
Sunset Light Projector Sale price$18.99
Resting my Eyes SlippersResting my Eyes Slippers
Resting my Eyes SlippersPaper Source Sale price$29.99
Scalloped Resin Photo Frame, Gold (4x6 Photo)Scalloped Resin Photo Frame, Gold (4x6 Photo)
Scalloped Resin Photo Frame, Gold (4x6 Photo)Paper Source Sale price$24.99
Between the Blooms 1000 Piece Foil Puzzle
Between the Blooms 1000 Piece Foil Puzzle Sale price$21.99
Retro Speaker
Retro SpeakerPaper Source Sale price$24.99
The Little Frog's Guide to Life: Love, Advice and Inspiration for Every Day from the Internet's Beloved Mushroom Frog
The Little Frog's Guide to Life: Love, Advice and Inspiration for Every Day from the Internet's Beloved Mushroom Frog Sale price$11.99
The Cocktail Cabinet: Whiskey
The Cocktail Cabinet: Whiskey Sale price$24.95
Heated Shoulder & Neck WrapHeated Shoulder & Neck Wrap
Heated Shoulder & Neck WrapPaper Source Sale price$29.99
Fall Floral Bedside CaddyFall Floral Bedside Caddy
Fall Floral Bedside CaddyPaper Source Sale price$28.99
First Rodeo Ceramic MugFirst Rodeo Ceramic Mug
First Rodeo Ceramic Mug Sale price$19.99
Dachshund WrapDachshund Wrap
Dachshund Wrap

Staff Favorite!

Sale price$29.99
Miffy 100 Piece Surprise PuzzleMiffy 100 Piece Surprise Puzzle
Miffy 100 Piece Surprise Puzzle Sale price$9.99
Home Sweet Home Porcelain Canister
Home Sweet Home Porcelain CanisterRifle Paper Co. Sale price$48.00
Rosemary Shower Dish & SteamerRosemary Shower Dish & Steamer
Rosemary Shower Dish & SteamerPaper Source Sale price$24.99
Five Minute Journal Green FloralFive Minute Journal Green Floral
Five Minute Journal Green Floral Sale price$33.00
Book Club Wine KitBook Club Wine Kit
Book Club Wine KitPaper Source Sale price$29.99