Save 25% on Select Stationery Sets →
Save up to 40% on Personalized Stationery →
Save 20% on Greeting Cards when you purchase 5+ →
Free Standard Shipping on Orders $50+ →
  • Go to slide 1
  • Go to slide 2
  • Go to slide 3
  • Go to slide 4
Login My Favorites

Cart

Your cart is empty

Gifts

Sort by

3465 Results

Filters
Drinking Buddies Elf BuddiesDrinking Buddies Elf Buddies
Drinking Buddies Elf Buddies Sale price$14.99
Rainbow Glow Dough
Rainbow Glow Dough Sale price$7.50
Gold Reindeer Headband
Gold Reindeer Headband Sale price$10.50
Teaching Is A Work Of Heart Letterpress Card
Teaching Is A Work Of Heart Letterpress Card Sale price$6.50
Elf 11-Inch Santa Hat
Elf 11-Inch Santa Hat Sale price$13.99
I Apple Teachers Greeting Card
I Apple Teachers Greeting Card Sale price$4.95
Sold outLittle Frog Plush - In Store Exclusive
Little Frog Plush - In Store Exclusive Sale price$25.00
Tarot Flat Wrap & Poster
Tarot Flat Wrap & Poster Sale price$9.50
Sold outCat with Bunny Ears Easter Card
Cat with Bunny Ears Easter Card Sale price$5.50
How Did You Know That?How Did You Know That?
How Did You Know That? Sale price$22.50
Sold outBunny in Carrot Pullback ToyBunny in Carrot Pullback Toy
Bunny in Carrot Pullback Toy Sale price$9.99
Greenery Throw BlanketGreenery Throw Blanket
Greenery Throw Blanket Sale price$39.99
(5.0)
Super Rainbow Squish Ball
Super Rainbow Squish Ball Sale price$12.95
Kids Penguin Plush SocksKids Penguin Plush Socks
Kids Penguin Plush Socks Sale price$16.99
Dog Days MugDog Days Mug
Dog Days Mug Sale price$24.50
Traditional Pom Star Tree Topper
Traditional Pom Star Tree Topper Sale price$17.50
Texas Cowgirl Ornament
Texas Cowgirl Ornament Sale price$21.99
Dragons and Wizards Crew Socks
Dragons and Wizards Crew Socks Sale price$16.99
Custom Embosser Gift SetCustom Embosser Gift Set
Custom Embosser Gift Set Sale price$60.00
Save 30%Bunny Light Up Squish ToyBunny Light Up Squish Toy
Bunny Light Up Squish Toy Sale price$4.55 Regular price$6.50
Bernie Sanders Ornament
Bernie Sanders Ornament Sale price$22.50
Tiny T-Rex Plush
Tiny T-Rex Plush Sale price$19.99
Sold outSave 10%The Cheese Board Deck: 50 Cards for Styling Spreads, Savory and SweetThe Cheese Board Deck: 50 Cards for Styling Spreads, Savory and Sweet
The Cheese Board Deck: 50 Cards for Styling Spreads, Savory and Sweet

Illustrated

Sale price$17.99 Regular price$20.00
Harry Styles Felt Ornament
Harry Styles Felt Ornament Sale price$19.99
Pride Flag Glass Ornament
Pride Flag Glass Ornament Sale price$19.99
HATCH N GROW YETIHATCH N GROW YETI
HATCH N GROW YETI Sale price$10.99
2025-2026 Paper Source Flower Vase Tall Wall Calendar2025-2026 Paper Source Flower Vase Tall Wall Calendar
2025-2026 Paper Source Flower Vase Tall Wall Calendar Sale price$29.99
Sold outWell-Kept Midnight Screen Wipes
Well-Kept Midnight Screen Wipes Sale price$6.50
Frog Hoppy Easter Card
Frog Hoppy Easter Card Sale price$5.50
Ceramic Haunted House Incense and Tealight HolderCeramic Haunted House Incense and Tealight Holder
Ceramic Haunted House Incense and Tealight Holder Sale price$16.99
Sold outAmuseable Pretzel Plush - In Store Exclusive
Amuseable Pretzel Plush - In Store Exclusive Sale price$60.00
Party Dogs & Cats Physical Gift Card
Party Dogs & Cats Physical Gift Card Sale price$0.00
Pomegranate Wrap & Poster
Pomegranate Wrap & Poster Sale price$9.50
The Moth Presents: A Game of StorytellingThe Moth Presents: A Game of Storytelling
The Moth Presents: A Game of Storytelling

update from ONIX

Sale price$17.99
Mouse with Snowflake Sweater Ornament
Mouse with Snowflake Sweater Ornament Sale price$17.99
Mini Zombie Party Thinking Putty
Mini Zombie Party Thinking Putty Sale price$3.99
LEGO LEL Seasons Hedgehog Picnic Date 40711LEGO LEL Seasons Hedgehog Picnic Date 40711
LEGO LEL Seasons Hedgehog Picnic Date 40711 Sale price$12.99
12-Month Rainbow Supplies Custom Planner12-Month Rainbow Supplies Custom Planner
12-Month Rainbow Supplies Custom PlannerPaper Source Sale price$39.95
The NEW Worst-Case Scenario Survival Handbook: Expert Advice for Extreme SituationsThe NEW Worst-Case Scenario Survival Handbook: Expert Advice for Extreme Situations
The NEW Worst-Case Scenario Survival Handbook: Expert Advice for Extreme Situations Sale price$19.95
Fern Frog PouchFern Frog Pouch
Fern Frog Pouch Sale price$19.99
Halloween Guessing Game Machine
Halloween Guessing Game Machine Sale price$13.50
How to Catch a Yeti (How to Catch... Series)How to Catch a Yeti (How to Catch... Series)
How to Catch a Yeti (How to Catch... Series) Sale price$10.99
Borrow My Pen SetBorrow My Pen Set
Borrow My Pen Set

Set of 8

Sale price$10.50
Split Monogram Black Luggage Tag
Split Monogram Black Luggage TagPaper Source

Set of 2

Sale price$19.99
Love from BlueyLove from Bluey
Love from Bluey Sale price$9.99
Espresso Martini Glass Ornament
Espresso Martini Glass Ornament Sale price$19.99
Balsam & Cedar Glass Ornament CandleBalsam & Cedar Glass Ornament Candle
Balsam & Cedar Glass Ornament Candle Sale price$31.99
Save 30%Tayto Potato Christmas Tree Mochi Plush
Tayto Potato Christmas Tree Mochi Plush Sale price$29.40 Regular price$42.00

Unique Gift Ideas

Shop our specially curated selection of unique gifts for all ages and occasions. We’ve got gifts for every holiday and season including birthdays, Christmas, Hanukkah, Easter, Father’s Day, Mother’s Day, and more. Whether you’re searching for a gift for grandma, your sister, or coworkers, our gift ideas will inspire giving in a fun and personal way! Browse through a variety of themed gifts including calendars and planners, journals and candles, and drinkware to find the perfect gift for your teen, husband, or wine loving friend. Explore our selection of trending books, décor, useful gadgets, adult games and puzzles, and toys for kids.

Discover uncommon gifts at Paper Source. Whether you’re looking for gift ideas for your girlfriend, parents, or your teacher, we have plenty of wonderful gifts under $20 and $30. From wine glasses and slippers that mom would love to coffee mugs and socks for dad, find gifts for everyone on your shopping list. Check out our personalized gift guide for more gift ideas!