Free Standard Shipping $60+ →
Login My Favorites

Cart

Your cart is empty

Halloween Gift Ideas & Décor

Browse our Halloween collection to find naughty & nice Halloween decorations, gifts, greeting cards and more!
Gifts Gifts
Crafts Crafts
Wrap & Party Wrap & Party
Cards Cards

Shop the Full Collection

Sort by

259 Results

Cat & Pumpkin Punch Needle KitCat & Pumpkin Punch Needle Kit
Cat & Pumpkin Punch Needle Kit Sale price$29.99
Miffy Halloween Pumpkin Costume 12"
Miffy Halloween Pumpkin Costume 12" Sale price$21.99
Beaded Frog PouchBeaded Frog Pouch
Beaded Frog PouchPaper Source Sale price$24.99
Edgar the Skeleton ExclusiveEdgar the Skeleton Exclusive
Edgar the Skeleton Exclusive

Get It Before It's Gone

Sale price$29.99
Bleeding Heart Beaded Tote BagBleeding Heart Beaded Tote Bag
Bleeding Heart Beaded Tote Bag Sale price$32.99
Scaredy Cat Bag Charm
Scaredy Cat Bag Charm Sale price$15.99
Liquid Ghost Boba Clear Signature Dome SlimeLiquid Ghost Boba Clear Signature Dome Slime
Liquid Ghost Boba Clear Signature Dome Slime Sale price$17.99
Little Pumpkin Silicone LightLittle Pumpkin Silicone Light
Little Pumpkin Silicone LightPaper Source Sale price$22.99
MAGNA-TILES microMAGS Spooky Travel Set 26-Piece Magnetic Construction Set, The Original Magnetic Building BrandMAGNA-TILES microMAGS Spooky Travel Set 26-Piece Magnetic Construction Set, The Original Magnetic Building Brand
MAGNA-TILES microMAGS Spooky Travel Set 26-Piece Magnetic Construction Set, The Original Magnetic Building Brand Sale price$19.99
Dead Inside MatchboxDead Inside Matchbox
Dead Inside Matchbox Sale price$19.99
Black and White Ghost Felt GarlandBlack and White Ghost Felt Garland
Black and White Ghost Felt Garland Sale price$24.50
Spider Ombre Taper CandlesSpider Ombre Taper Candles
Spider Ombre Taper Candles Sale price$16.99
Bat Candle Holder
Bat Candle Holder Sale price$12.99
Lidded Coffin Match Box
Lidded Coffin Match BoxPaper Source Sale price$19.99
Halloween Sticker BookHalloween Sticker Book
Halloween Sticker Book Sale price$12.99
Cat in Pumpkin Statement Earring
Cat in Pumpkin Statement Earring Sale price$29.99
Cat in Pumpkin Medium Gift Bag
Cat in Pumpkin Medium Gift Bag Sale price$6.50
Puffy Cat & Pumpkin Sticker SheetPuffy Cat & Pumpkin Sticker Sheet
Puffy Cat & Pumpkin Sticker Sheet Sale price$7.50
Shaped Skeleton Dachshund PillowShaped Skeleton Dachshund Pillow
Shaped Skeleton Dachshund Pillow Sale price$29.99
Pendant Teddy Bear Mr. BonesPendant Teddy Bear Mr. Bones
Pendant Teddy Bear Mr. Bones Sale price$24.99
Cheerware Witch Crafts 8oz Blue Milk Glass Mug
Cheerware Witch Crafts 8oz Blue Milk Glass Mug Sale price$25.00
Spider Web GarlandSpider Web Garland
Spider Web Garland Sale price$20.50
Cat and Dog Skeleton Party CrackersCat and Dog Skeleton Party Crackers
Cat and Dog Skeleton Party Crackers Sale price$22.50
Skeleton Dance Cocktail Napkin Set of 20Skeleton Dance Cocktail Napkin Set of 20
Skeleton Dance Cocktail Napkin Set of 20 Sale price$8.50
Halloween Toile Large Plate Set of 10Halloween Toile Large Plate Set of 10
Halloween Toile Large Plate Set of 10 Sale price$10.50
Assorted Trick or Treat Cocktail Napkins
Assorted Trick or Treat Cocktail Napkins Sale price$12.50
Mini Witch Party Hats Set of 8Mini Witch Party Hats Set of 8
Mini Witch Party Hats Set of 8 Sale price$15.50
Coco & Clyde Cats Honeycomb Door Hang Set of 2Coco & Clyde Cats Honeycomb Door Hang Set of 2
Coco & Clyde Cats Honeycomb Door Hang Set of 2 Sale price$18.50
Halloween Happy Ghosts Cello Bags Set of 15Halloween Happy Ghosts Cello Bags Set of 15
Halloween Happy Ghosts Cello Bags Set of 15 Sale price$9.50
Pumpkin Party Cups Pack of 8Pumpkin Party Cups Pack of 8
Pumpkin Party Cups Pack of 8 Sale price$10.50
LEGO Iconic Jack-O'-Lantern Pickup Truck 40822LEGO Iconic Jack-O'-Lantern Pickup Truck 40822
LEGO Iconic Jack-O'-Lantern Pickup Truck 40822 Sale price$14.99
Mr Spice Hoppie RabbitMr Spice Hoppie Rabbit
Mr Spice Hoppie Rabbit Sale price$34.99
Bellzi Fossil Rexxi Glow in the DarkBellzi Fossil Rexxi Glow in the Dark
Bellzi Fossil Rexxi Glow in the Dark Sale price$34.99
Rewined Pumpkin Martini Candle 6 oz
Rewined Pumpkin Martini Candle 6 oz Sale price$25.99
Puffy Pumpkin Sticker SheetPuffy Pumpkin Sticker Sheet
Puffy Pumpkin Sticker Sheet Sale price$7.50
Costume Pups Asst PensCostume Pups Asst Pens
Costume Pups Asst Pens Sale price$3.99
Catcula Punching PenCatcula Punching Pen
Catcula Punching Pen Sale price$6.00
Charcoal Mini Scented Candle TinCharcoal Mini Scented Candle Tin
Charcoal Mini Scented Candle Tin Sale price$12.00
Felted ghost dog ornamentFelted ghost dog ornament
Felted ghost dog ornamentPaper Source Sale price$9.99
Jeweled Critter PinsJeweled Critter Pins
Jeweled Critter PinsPaper Source Sale price$19.99
Gone Batty Potholder and Towel Gift Set
Gone Batty Potholder and Towel Gift Set Sale price$19.99
Halloween Sound MachineHalloween Sound Machine
Halloween Sound Machine Sale price$12.99
Halloween 26' Bat Nail StickersHalloween 26' Bat Nail Stickers
Halloween 26' Bat Nail Stickers Sale price$5.00
Spooky Shower SteamersSpooky Shower Steamers
Spooky Shower SteamersPaper Source Sale price$14.99
Black and Clear Beaded Spider BraceletBlack and Clear Beaded Spider Bracelet
Black and Clear Beaded Spider Bracelet Sale price$12.99
TEMPORARY TATOOS - GLOW IN THE DARKTEMPORARY TATOOS - GLOW IN THE DARK
TEMPORARY TATOOS - GLOW IN THE DARK Sale price$9.99
Eerie-sistibly Woobly Haunted House Box Learn to Crochet kitEerie-sistibly Woobly Haunted House Box Learn to Crochet kit
Eerie-sistibly Woobly Haunted House Box Learn to Crochet kit Sale price$174.99
Mini Glitter Moon & Star Sticker SheetMini Glitter Moon & Star Sticker Sheet
Mini Glitter Moon & Star Sticker Sheet Sale price$6.00

Halloween Collection

Monsters, spiders, and vampires- Oh my! Seeking spooky and fun Halloween finds for Halloween 2026? We have the tricks and treats that will let the ghoul times roll! Halloween craft supplies and Halloween stickers that are bewitching! Stir up some hocus pocus for your Halloween party with gourd goodies! We have Halloween plates and Halloween decorations, online and in-store. Cast a spell with our Halloween garland. Brew the best Halloween baskets & Halloween gift bags in town! Celebrate a Happy Halloween with the boo friend that would never ghost you by shopping Halloween cards. Halloween wrapping paper is a wicked find for spooky art or great gifting. Explore retro Halloween & nostalgic treats. Carve out time to perfect your pumpkin with paper. Concoct a potion with our personalized Halloween party invitations and Halloween washi tape. Add metallic touches that will make your guests go batty! Black cats & witches know where the magic is at, shop Paper Source for all your Halloween must-haves!