30% Off Personalized Stationery →
50% Off Custom Holiday Photo Cards →
25% Off Holiday Card Sets →
Save 20% on Greeting Cards when you purchase 5+ →
Free Standard Shipping on Orders $50+ →
  • Go to slide 1
  • Go to slide 2
  • Go to slide 3
  • Go to slide 4
  • Go to slide 5
Login My Favorites

Cart

Your cart is empty

Halloween Gift Ideas & Décor

Browse our Halloween collection to find naughty & nice Halloween decorations, gifts, greeting cards and more!
Gifts Gifts
Crafts Crafts
Wrap & Party Wrap & Party
Cards Cards

Receive your treats in time!
Standard Shipping: Tuesday 10/21 Noon ET
Express Shipping: Friday 10/24 Noon ET
Expedited Shipping: Monday 10/27 Noon ET

Sort by

212 Results

Filters
Itty Bitty Betty BlobItty Bitty Betty Blob
Itty Bitty Betty Blob Sale price$18.99
(5.0)
Jack-O-Lantern Wine Bag
Jack-O-Lantern Wine BagPaper Source Sale price$7.95
Trick or Treat on Scary StreetTrick or Treat on Scary Street
Trick or Treat on Scary Street Sale price$18.99
Milo Skeleton MicroMilo Skeleton Micro
Milo Skeleton Micro Sale price$11.99
I Will Read to You: A Story About Books, Bedtime, and Monsters
I Will Read to You: A Story About Books, Bedtime, and Monsters Sale price$18.99
Green and Purple Dual Stripe Napkin S/20
Green and Purple Dual Stripe Napkin S/20Paper Source Sale price$8.50
Sleepy Hollow House Halloween Card
Sleepy Hollow House Halloween Card Sale price$6.50
Oh My Gourd ApronOh My Gourd Apron
Oh My Gourd Apron Sale price$29.95
624013337.jpg
Cornelius Scarecrow 5" Palm Pals Sale price$9.99
Trick or Treat 36 Piece Floor Puzzle
Trick or Treat 36 Piece Floor Puzzle Sale price$21.99
50 Must-Watch Scary Movies Bucket List 1000-piece Puzzle
50 Must-Watch Scary Movies Bucket List 1000-piece Puzzle Sale price$24.99
Psycho Killer by Michael Wilkinson and Mitch YoungPsycho Killer by Michael Wilkinson and Mitch Young
Psycho Killer by Michael Wilkinson and Mitch Young Sale price$24.99
Poppy Playtime - Factory Frenzy GamePoppy Playtime - Factory Frenzy Game
Poppy Playtime - Factory Frenzy Game Sale price$19.99
623221038.jpg623221039.jpg
Teddy Ghost Halloween Card Sale price$5.50
Mini Haunted House Thinking Putty
Mini Haunted House Thinking Putty Sale price$3.99
Pull Back: Vintage Hearse with SpookiesPull Back: Vintage Hearse with Spookies
Pull Back: Vintage Hearse with Spookies Sale price$8.99
Mini Skeleton Thinking Putty
Mini Skeleton Thinking Putty Sale price$3.99
Cats in Costumes Assorted Halloween PensCats in Costumes Assorted Halloween Pens
Cats in Costumes Assorted Halloween Pens Sale price$3.99
Ghosts in Forest Halloween Card
Ghosts in Forest Halloween Card Sale price$4.50
Glow in the Dark Jack-O' Lantern StickersGlow in the Dark Jack-O' Lantern Stickers
Glow in the Dark Jack-O' Lantern Stickers

Set of 30

Sale price$5.95

Halloween Collection

Monsters, spiders, and vampires- Oh my! Seeking spooky and fun Halloween finds for Halloween 2025? We have the tricks and treats that will let the ghoul times roll! Halloween craft supplies and Halloween stickers that are bewitching! Stir up some hocus pocus for your Halloween party with gourd goodies! We have Halloween plates and Halloween decorations, online and in-store. Cast a spell with our Halloween garland. Brew the best Halloween baskets & Halloween gift bags in town! Celebrate a Happy Halloween with the boo friend that would never ghost you by shopping Halloween cards. Halloween wrapping paper is a wicked find for spooky art or great gifting. Explore retro Halloween & nostalgic treats. Carve out time to perfect your pumpkin with paper. Concoct a potion with our personalized Halloween party invitations and Halloween washi tape. Add metallic touches that will make your guests go batty! Black cats & witches know where the magic is at, shop Paper Source for all your Halloween must-haves!