Shop in stores for last-minute Halloween treats →
Save up to 40% on Personalized Stationery →
Save 20% on Greeting Cards when you purchase 5+ →
Free Standard Shipping on Orders $50+ →
Save 10% when you sign up for SMS alerts →
  • Go to slide 1
  • Go to slide 2
  • Go to slide 3
  • Go to slide 4
  • Go to slide 5
Login My Favorites

Cart

Your cart is empty

Halloween Gift Ideas & Décor

Browse our Halloween collection to find naughty & nice Halloween decorations, gifts, greeting cards and more!
Gifts Gifts
Crafts Crafts
Wrap & Party Wrap & Party
Cards Cards

Receive your treats in time!
Standard Shipping: Tuesday 10/21 Noon ET
Express Shipping: Friday 10/24 Noon ET
Expedited Shipping: Monday 12/27 Noon ET

Sort by

212 Results

Filters
Ghost Critters Cello Treat BagsGhost Critters Cello Treat Bags
Ghost Critters Cello Treat BagsPaper Source

Set of 15

Sale price$9.50
Halloween Masks Paper Craft Kit
Halloween Masks Paper Craft Kit Sale price$19.50
Candy Corn Flat Wrap
Candy Corn Flat Wrap Sale price$6.50
Vintage Icons Halloween Card
Vintage Icons Halloween Card Sale price$6.50
Glitter Bat Sunglasses
Glitter Bat SunglassesPaper Source Sale price$10.99
Sugar Skull Halloween StickersSugar Skull Halloween Stickers
Sugar Skull Halloween Stickers Sale price$7.00
Jack-O-Lantern Pumpkin Treat BagsJack-O-Lantern Pumpkin Treat Bags
Jack-O-Lantern Pumpkin Treat BagsPaper Source

Set of 8

Sale price$16.50
Ghoul Fish! Card GameGhoul Fish! Card Game
Ghoul Fish! Card Game Sale price$9.99
5 Foot Glow In The Dark Hanging Skeleton5 Foot Glow In The Dark Hanging Skeleton
5 Foot Glow In The Dark Hanging Skeleton Sale price$24.50
Spooky Season Halloween Card
Spooky Season Halloween Card Sale price$7.50
Skull Candles
Skull Candles

Set of 3

Sale price$16.99
Halloween Cats Flat Wrap
Halloween Cats Flat WrapPaper Source Sale price$7.50
Halloween Dog Witch Hat
Halloween Dog Witch Hat Sale price$7.99
Cubebot Skeleton MicroCubebot Skeleton Micro
Cubebot Skeleton Micro Sale price$11.99
Holographic Webs and Spiders Banner
Holographic Webs and Spiders Banner Sale price$16.50
Bone Appetit Oven Mitt & Pot Holder Set
Bone Appetit Oven Mitt & Pot Holder Set Sale price$14.99
Happy Halloween Skull BannerHappy Halloween Skull Banner
Happy Halloween Skull BannerPaper Source Sale price$20.50
Skulls and Mums Flat Wrap
Skulls and Mums Flat WrapPaper Source Sale price$7.50
Fangtastic Bats Halloween Card
Fangtastic Bats Halloween Card Sale price$7.50
Spider On Pumpkin Halloween Card
Spider On Pumpkin Halloween Card Sale price$7.50
(5.0)
Costume Cats Treat Bags
Costume Cats Treat Bags Sale price$11.50
Fine Paper Pumpkin Stationery SetFine Paper Pumpkin Stationery Set
Fine Paper Pumpkin Stationery Set

Set of 10

Sale price$17.50
MED Bat Party Gift Bag
MED Bat Party Gift BagPaper Source Sale price$6.50
Ghost Critters Medium Gift Bag
Ghost Critters Medium Gift BagPaper Source Sale price$6.50
Skull String LightsSkull String Lights
Skull String Lights Sale price$20.50
Glitter Spider Party HatsGlitter Spider Party Hats
Glitter Spider Party Hats

Set of 4

Sale price$15.50
Skeleton Characters
Skeleton Characters Sale price$16.50
Decorative Orange Velvet Pumpkin
Decorative Orange Velvet Pumpkin Sale price$14.50
Monster Halloween Treat BagsMonster Halloween Treat Bags
Monster Halloween Treat BagsPaper Source

Set of 8

Sale price$16.50
Smiling Pumpkin Plates
Smiling Pumpkin PlatesPaper Source

Set of 10

Sale price$10.50
Bar Bones Drink MarkersBar Bones Drink Markers
Bar Bones Drink Markers

Set of 6

Sale price$12.99
Hanging Bats Halloween Garland Craft Kit
Hanging Bats Halloween Garland Craft Kit Sale price$17.50
Classic Halloween Icon Sticker SheetClassic Halloween Icon Sticker Sheet
Classic Halloween Icon Sticker Sheet Sale price$8.00
Halloween Spiderweb Decor KitHalloween Spiderweb Decor Kit
Halloween Spiderweb Decor Kit Sale price$17.50
Glow in the Dark Bat Wall Decor
Glow in the Dark Bat Wall Decor

Set of 30

Sale price$12.50
Dressed Up Cat Crackers
Dressed Up Cat Crackers

Set of 6

Sale price$20.50
Creep It Real Plates
Creep It Real PlatesPaper Source

Set of 10

Sale price$8.50
Skull Cocktail Napkins
Skull Cocktail NapkinsPaper Source

Set of 20

Sale price$10.50
Woodland Critter Pumpkin Decorating KitWoodland Critter Pumpkin Decorating Kit
Woodland Critter Pumpkin Decorating Kit

Set of 3

Sale price$12.95
Ghost Cat Halloween Card
Ghost Cat Halloween Card Sale price$6.50
Halloween Party Fan and Banner Set
Halloween Party Fan and Banner Set Sale price$25.50
Glitter Pumpkin Halloween Hang TagsGlitter Pumpkin Halloween Hang Tags
Glitter Pumpkin Halloween Hang TagsPaper Source

Set of 4

Sale price$8.50
Vintage Cat Pumpkin Stationery Set
Vintage Cat Pumpkin Stationery Set

Set of 10

Sale price$18.50
Jack-O-Lantern Trio Stamp
Jack-O-Lantern Trio Stamp Sale price$9.00
Die Cut Pumpkin Halloween Stationery Set
Die Cut Pumpkin Halloween Stationery Set

Set of 10

Sale price$17.50
Halloween Character Rosettes Kit
Halloween Character Rosettes Kit Sale price$16.95
Costumed Pumpkin Treat BagsCostumed Pumpkin Treat Bags
Costumed Pumpkin Treat BagsPaper Source

Set of 8

Sale price$15.95
Celebrate Gourd Times Halloween Card
Celebrate Gourd Times Halloween Card Sale price$5.95

Halloween Collection

Monsters, spiders, and vampires- Oh my! Seeking spooky and fun Halloween finds for Halloween 2025? We have the tricks and treats that will let the ghoul times roll! Halloween craft supplies and Halloween stickers that are bewitching! Stir up some hocus pocus for your Halloween party with gourd goodies! We have Halloween plates and Halloween decorations, online and in-store. Cast a spell with our Halloween garland. Brew the best Halloween baskets & Halloween gift bags in town! Celebrate a Happy Halloween with the boo friend that would never ghost you by shopping Halloween cards. Halloween wrapping paper is a wicked find for spooky art or great gifting. Explore retro Halloween & nostalgic treats. Carve out time to perfect your pumpkin with paper. Concoct a potion with our personalized Halloween party invitations and Halloween washi tape. Add metallic touches that will make your guests go batty! Black cats & witches know where the magic is at, shop Paper Source for all your Halloween must-haves!