Free Standard Shipping $60+ →
Login My Favorites

Cart

Your cart is empty

Halloween Gift Ideas & Décor

Browse our Halloween collection to find naughty & nice Halloween decorations, gifts, greeting cards and more!
Gifts Gifts
Crafts Crafts
Wrap & Party Wrap & Party
Cards Cards

Sort by

210 Results

Filters
Hal the Jack-o-Lantern Glow in the Dark Learn to Crochet kitHal the Jack-o-Lantern Glow in the Dark Learn to Crochet kit
Hal the Jack-o-Lantern Glow in the Dark Learn to Crochet kit Sale price$29.99
Costume Pups Asst PensCostume Pups Asst Pens
Costume Pups Asst Pens Sale price$3.99
Mini Glitter Moon & Star Sticker SheetMini Glitter Moon & Star Sticker Sheet
Mini Glitter Moon & Star Sticker Sheet Sale price$6.00
Snake Claw ClipSnake Claw Clip
Snake Claw ClipPaper Source Sale price$14.99
Mini Witch Party Hats Set of 8Mini Witch Party Hats Set of 8
Mini Witch Party Hats Set of 8 Sale price$15.50
MAGNA-TILES microMAGS Spooky Travel Set 26-Piece Magnetic Construction Set, The Original Magnetic Building BrandMAGNA-TILES microMAGS Spooky Travel Set 26-Piece Magnetic Construction Set, The Original Magnetic Building Brand
MAGNA-TILES microMAGS Spooky Travel Set 26-Piece Magnetic Construction Set, The Original Magnetic Building Brand Sale price$19.99
Puffy Pumpkin Sticker SheetPuffy Pumpkin Sticker Sheet
Puffy Pumpkin Sticker Sheet Sale price$7.50
Catcula Punching PenCatcula Punching Pen
Catcula Punching Pen Sale price$6.00
Puffy Cat & Pumpkin Sticker SheetPuffy Cat & Pumpkin Sticker Sheet
Puffy Cat & Pumpkin Sticker Sheet Sale price$7.50
Cat in Pumpkin Medium Gift Bag
Cat in Pumpkin Medium Gift Bag Sale price$6.50
Halloween Cat Book CoverHalloween Cat Book Cover
Halloween Cat Book Cover Sale price$24.99
Plush Harvest Pumpkin HeadbandPlush Harvest Pumpkin Headband
Plush Harvest Pumpkin Headband Sale price$12.99
UnderwearwolfUnderwearwolf
Underwearwolf Sale price$19.99
Cat and Dog Skeleton Party CrackersCat and Dog Skeleton Party Crackers
Cat and Dog Skeleton Party Crackers Sale price$22.50
Cat in Pumpkin Statement Earring
Cat in Pumpkin Statement Earring Sale price$29.99
It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie BrownIt's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown
It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown Sale price$14.99
Bat SocksBat Socks
Bat SocksPaper Source Sale price$14.99
Halloween 26' Confetti PouchHalloween 26' Confetti Pouch
Halloween 26' Confetti Pouch Sale price$7.00
Spooktacular Bats Halloween CardSpooktacular Bats Halloween Card
Spooktacular Bats Halloween Card Sale price$7.50
Bat Halloween Memo PadBat Halloween Memo Pad
Bat Halloween Memo Pad Sale price$10.99
Paint Your Own Halloween Kit - Haunted House, Jack O'Lantern, WitchPaint Your Own Halloween Kit - Haunted House, Jack O'Lantern, Witch
Paint Your Own Halloween Kit - Haunted House, Jack O'Lantern, Witch Sale price$24.99
Assorted Halloween Cat and Pumpkin PlatesAssorted Halloween Cat and Pumpkin Plates
Assorted Halloween Cat and Pumpkin Plates Sale price$10.50
Assorted Halloween Party PicksAssorted Halloween Party Picks
Assorted Halloween Party Picks Sale price$14.50
Halloween Cat and Pumpkin Surprise BallsHalloween Cat and Pumpkin Surprise Balls
Halloween Cat and Pumpkin Surprise BallsPaper Source Sale price$22.50
Fun Ghost Sticker SheetFun Ghost Sticker Sheet
Fun Ghost Sticker Sheet Sale price$8.00
Ghost Tayto Potato Ambient LightGhost Tayto Potato Ambient Light
Ghost Tayto Potato Ambient Light Sale price$22.00
Halloween Felt Pom WreathHalloween Felt Pom Wreath
Halloween Felt Pom Wreath Sale price$29.99
Happy Halloween Felt garlandHappy Halloween Felt garland
Happy Halloween Felt garland Sale price$20.50
Witch Hat Decor
Witch Hat DecorPaper Source

Set of 3

Sale price$24.50
Ghost Sticky NotesGhost Sticky Notes
Ghost Sticky Notes Sale price$10.50
Eerie-sistibly Woobly Haunted House Box Learn to Crochet kitEerie-sistibly Woobly Haunted House Box Learn to Crochet kit
Eerie-sistibly Woobly Haunted House Box Learn to Crochet kit Sale price$174.99
Zippered Toile PouchZippered Toile Pouch
Zippered Toile PouchPaper Source Sale price$17.99
Halloween Mini Hair ClipsHalloween Mini Hair Clips
Halloween Mini Hair ClipsPaper Source Sale price$9.99
Halloween Fingernail Friends
Halloween Fingernail Friends Sale price$4.99
Spooky Cat Felt GarlandSpooky Cat Felt Garland
Spooky Cat Felt Garland Sale price$20.50
Kittens in Costumes KitKittens in Costumes Kit
Kittens in Costumes Kit Sale price$20.00
Cat and Pumpkin Honeycomb Table DecorCat and Pumpkin Honeycomb Table Decor
Cat and Pumpkin Honeycomb Table Decor Sale price$24.50
Assorted Halloween Animal Treat Bags
Assorted Halloween Animal Treat Bags Sale price$17.50
Halloween Portraits Medium Gift Bag
Halloween Portraits Medium Gift BagPaper Source Sale price$6.50
Kitten in Costume Die Cut Halloween Card
Kitten in Costume Die Cut Halloween Card Sale price$6.50
Skeleton Drop EarringsSkeleton Drop Earrings
Skeleton Drop Earrings Sale price$29.99
Halloween Critter Gel ClingsHalloween Critter Gel Clings
Halloween Critter Gel Clings Sale price$12.99
Carving Critters Halloween Card
Carving Critters Halloween Card Sale price$5.50
Ghost Pup Embroidery KitGhost Pup Embroidery Kit
Ghost Pup Embroidery Kit Sale price$29.99
Halloween Candy Halloween Card
Halloween Candy Halloween Card Sale price$6.50
Trick or Treat Shaker Sticker SheetTrick or Treat Shaker Sticker Sheet
Trick or Treat Shaker Sticker Sheet Sale price$8.00
Open at Your Own Risk Medium Gift Bag
Open at Your Own Risk Medium Gift Bag Sale price$7.50
Cat and Dog in Costumes Sticker SheetCat and Dog in Costumes Sticker Sheet
Cat and Dog in Costumes Sticker Sheet Sale price$8.00

Halloween Collection

Monsters, spiders, and vampires- Oh my! Seeking spooky and fun Halloween finds for Halloween 2025? We have the tricks and treats that will let the ghoul times roll! Halloween craft supplies and Halloween stickers that are bewitching! Stir up some hocus pocus for your Halloween party with gourd goodies! We have Halloween plates and Halloween decorations, online and in-store. Cast a spell with our Halloween garland. Brew the best Halloween baskets & Halloween gift bags in town! Celebrate a Happy Halloween with the boo friend that would never ghost you by shopping Halloween cards. Halloween wrapping paper is a wicked find for spooky art or great gifting. Explore retro Halloween & nostalgic treats. Carve out time to perfect your pumpkin with paper. Concoct a potion with our personalized Halloween party invitations and Halloween washi tape. Add metallic touches that will make your guests go batty! Black cats & witches know where the magic is at, shop Paper Source for all your Halloween must-haves!