Free Standard Shipping $60+ →
Login My Favorites

Cart

Your cart is empty

Halloween Gift Ideas & Décor

Browse our Halloween collection to find naughty & nice Halloween decorations, gifts, greeting cards and more!
Gifts Gifts
Crafts Crafts
Wrap & Party Wrap & Party
Cards Cards

Shop the Full Collection

Sort by

264 Results

Mr Spice Hoppie RabbitMr Spice Hoppie Rabbit
Mr Spice Hoppie Rabbit Sale price$34.99
Rewined Pumpkin Martini Candle 6 oz
Rewined Pumpkin Martini Candle 6 oz Sale price$25.99
Puffy Pumpkin Sticker SheetPuffy Pumpkin Sticker Sheet
Puffy Pumpkin Sticker Sheet Sale price$7.50
Halloween Glitter Greetings PostcardsHalloween Glitter Greetings Postcards
Halloween Glitter Greetings PostcardsCavallini & Co.

Set of 12

Sale price$17.50
Costume Pups Asst PensCostume Pups Asst Pens
Costume Pups Asst Pens Sale price$3.99
Catcula Punching PenCatcula Punching Pen
Catcula Punching Pen Sale price$6.00
Charcoal Mini Scented Candle TinCharcoal Mini Scented Candle Tin
Charcoal Mini Scented Candle Tin Sale price$12.00
Felted ghost dog ornamentFelted ghost dog ornament
Felted ghost dog ornamentPaper Source Sale price$9.99
Gone Batty Potholder and Towel Gift Set
Gone Batty Potholder and Towel Gift Set Sale price$19.99
Halloween Sound MachineHalloween Sound Machine
Halloween Sound Machine Sale price$12.99
Spooky Shower SteamersSpooky Shower Steamers
Spooky Shower SteamersPaper Source Sale price$14.99
Black and Clear Beaded Spider BraceletBlack and Clear Beaded Spider Bracelet
Black and Clear Beaded Spider Bracelet Sale price$12.99
Mini Glitter Moon & Star Sticker SheetMini Glitter Moon & Star Sticker Sheet
Mini Glitter Moon & Star Sticker Sheet Sale price$6.00
Spellbinding Halloween Key Chain PouchSpellbinding Halloween Key Chain Pouch
Spellbinding Halloween Key Chain Pouch Sale price$8.99
Puffy ghost Sticker SheetPuffy ghost Sticker Sheet
Puffy ghost Sticker Sheet Sale price$7.50
Halloween 26' Confetti PouchHalloween 26' Confetti Pouch
Halloween 26' Confetti Pouch Sale price$7.00
LEGO Iconic Altar of the Dead 40811LEGO Iconic Altar of the Dead 40811
LEGO Iconic Altar of the Dead 40811 Sale price$14.99
Monster House Halloween CardMonster House Halloween Card
Monster House Halloween Card Sale price$9.50
Halloween Charm BraceletHalloween Charm Bracelet
Halloween Charm Bracelet Sale price$12.99
Sage Woods CandleSage Woods Candle
Sage Woods Candle Sale price$40.00
Assorted Halloween Animal Treat Bags
Assorted Halloween Animal Treat Bags Sale price$17.50
Melting WitchMelting Witch
Melting Witch Sale price$14.99
Plush Harvest Pumpkin HeadbandPlush Harvest Pumpkin Headband
Plush Harvest Pumpkin Headband Sale price$12.99
Hal the Jack-o-Lantern Glow in the Dark Learn to Crochet kitHal the Jack-o-Lantern Glow in the Dark Learn to Crochet kit
Hal the Jack-o-Lantern Glow in the Dark Learn to Crochet kit Sale price$29.99
Rewined Espresso Martini Candle 3.5 oz
Rewined Espresso Martini Candle 3.5 oz Sale price$17.99
Ghostly Tissue Paper
Ghostly Tissue Paper Sale price$6.50
Mini Skeletons with Hats 3 Ass't Styles
Mini Skeletons with Hats 3 Ass't Styles Sale price$7.99
Spellbinding Halloween Lip Balm and Hand Lotion SetSpellbinding Halloween Lip Balm and Hand Lotion Set
Spellbinding Halloween Lip Balm and Hand Lotion Set Sale price$13.99
Halloween Window Gel Clings Set of 12Halloween Window Gel Clings Set of 12
Halloween Window Gel Clings Set of 12Paper Source Sale price$12.99
Pomme Rouge Bubble Glass Candle
Pomme Rouge Bubble Glass Candle Sale price$20.00
Botanical Moth Paint by NumbersBotanical Moth Paint by Numbers
Botanical Moth Paint by Numbers Sale price$32.99
MIDNIGHT SLEEPING KITMIDNIGHT SLEEPING KIT
MIDNIGHT SLEEPING KITPaper Source Sale price$19.99
Assorted Halloween Cat and Pumpkin PlatesAssorted Halloween Cat and Pumpkin Plates
Assorted Halloween Cat and Pumpkin Plates Sale price$10.50
GLOPLAY Halloween EssentialsGLOPLAY Halloween Essentials
GLOPLAY Halloween Essentials Sale price$14.99
Michael Storrings Haunted Amusement Park 500 Piece PuzzleMichael Storrings Haunted Amusement Park 500 Piece Puzzle
Michael Storrings Haunted Amusement Park 500 Piece Puzzle Sale price$17.99
DIY Miniature House Kit: Dark CastleDIY Miniature House Kit: Dark Castle
DIY Miniature House Kit: Dark Castle Sale price$29.99
Coffin Skeleton Halloween Card
Coffin Skeleton Halloween Card Sale price$7.50
Halloween Cat Book CoverHalloween Cat Book Cover
Halloween Cat Book Cover Sale price$24.99
Cauldron Trick-Or-Treat Basket
Cauldron Trick-Or-Treat BasketPaper Source Sale price$13.99
It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie BrownIt's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown
It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown Sale price$14.99
Mystical Throw BlanketMystical Throw Blanket
Mystical Throw BlanketPaper Source Sale price$34.99
Sneakie the Soft Spider
Sneakie the Soft Spider Sale price$17.99
Fortune Telling CardsFortune Telling Cards
Fortune Telling Cards Sale price$7.99
Thrilling Frankenstein Halloween Card
Thrilling Frankenstein Halloween Card Sale price$6.50
Vintage Halloween Postcard SetVintage Halloween Postcard Set
Vintage Halloween Postcard Set Sale price$17.50
Cat Skeleton PillowCat Skeleton Pillow
Cat Skeleton Pillow Sale price$24.99
Trick or Treat Halloween Medium Gift Bag
Trick or Treat Halloween Medium Gift Bag Sale price$7.50
Grumpy Monkey Up All NightGrumpy Monkey Up All Night
Grumpy Monkey Up All Night Sale price$9.99

Halloween Collection

Monsters, spiders, and vampires- Oh my! Seeking spooky and fun Halloween finds for Halloween 2026? We have the tricks and treats that will let the ghoul times roll! Halloween craft supplies and Halloween stickers that are bewitching! Stir up some hocus pocus for your Halloween party with gourd goodies! We have Halloween plates and Halloween decorations, online and in-store. Cast a spell with our Halloween garland. Brew the best Halloween baskets & Halloween gift bags in town! Celebrate a Happy Halloween with the boo friend that would never ghost you by shopping Halloween cards. Halloween wrapping paper is a wicked find for spooky art or great gifting. Explore retro Halloween & nostalgic treats. Carve out time to perfect your pumpkin with paper. Concoct a potion with our personalized Halloween party invitations and Halloween washi tape. Add metallic touches that will make your guests go batty! Black cats & witches know where the magic is at, shop Paper Source for all your Halloween must-haves!