20% Off Personalized Stationery →
30% Off Custom Holiday Photo Cards →
Save 20% on Greeting Cards when you purchase 5+ →
Free Standard Shipping on Orders $50+ →
Save 10% when you sign up for SMS alerts →
  • Go to slide 1
  • Go to slide 2
  • Go to slide 3
  • Go to slide 4
  • Go to slide 5
Login My Favorites

Cart

Your cart is empty

Gifts

Sort by

3585 Results

Filters
Party Dogs & Cats Electronic Gift Card
Party Dogs & Cats Electronic Gift Card Sale price$0.00
Light Up ChickLight Up Chick
Light Up Chick Sale price$4.50
Sold outAmuseable Bubble Tea Plush - In Store ExclusiveAmuseable Bubble Tea Plush - In Store Exclusive
Amuseable Bubble Tea Plush - In Store Exclusive Sale price$33.00
Wacky Waving Inflatable Tube Guy: (The Original)Wacky Waving Inflatable Tube Guy: (The Original)
Wacky Waving Inflatable Tube Guy: (The Original) Sale price$12.95
(1.0)
Save 20%Custom Journal - Upload Your OwnCustom Journal - Upload Your Own
Custom Journal - Upload Your OwnPaper Source Sale price$15.96 Regular price$19.95
Middle Finger Tiny HandMiddle Finger Tiny Hand
Middle Finger Tiny Hand Sale price$3.50
Embroidered Wildwood GuestbookEmbroidered Wildwood Guestbook
Embroidered Wildwood GuestbookRifle Paper Co. Sale price$50.00
The New York Times Mini Crosswords, Volume 1: 150 Easy Fun-Sized PuzzlesThe New York Times Mini Crosswords, Volume 1: 150 Easy Fun-Sized Puzzles
The New York Times Mini Crosswords, Volume 1: 150 Easy Fun-Sized Puzzles Sale price$10.99
Confetti Birthday Cake Greeting Card PuzzleConfetti Birthday Cake Greeting Card Puzzle
Confetti Birthday Cake Greeting Card Puzzle Sale price$7.50
Diet Coke Glass Ornament
Diet Coke Glass Ornament Sale price$19.99
Save 20%12-Month Deco Floral Custom Planner12-Month Deco Floral Custom Planner
12-Month Deco Floral Custom PlannerPaper Source Sale price$31.96 Regular price$39.95
Twinkling Tree Thinking PuttyTwinkling Tree Thinking Putty
Twinkling Tree Thinking Putty Sale price$3.99
Pink Neon Canopy Flat Wrap
Pink Neon Canopy Flat WrapRifle Paper Co. Sale price$6.50
Sold outAmuseable Monstera Plant Plush - In Store ExclusiveAmuseable Monstera Plant Plush - In Store Exclusive
Amuseable Monstera Plant Plush - In Store Exclusive Sale price$75.00
Regal Blue Border NotesetRegal Blue Border Noteset
Regal Blue Border Noteset

Set of 20

Sale price$34.00
Sage Nodpod Eye Mask
Sage Nodpod Eye MaskPaper Source Sale price$38.00
Tinsel Trees Physical Gift Card
Tinsel Trees Physical Gift Card Sale price$0.00
Sold outAmuseables Rose Bouquet - In Store Exclusive
Amuseables Rose Bouquet - In Store Exclusive Sale price$55.00
Charcuterie Board Ornament
Charcuterie Board Ornament Sale price$16.99
Save 11%One Question a Day for Kids: A Three-Year Journal: Create Your Own Personal Time Capsule
One Question a Day for Kids: A Three-Year Journal: Create Your Own Personal Time Capsule Sale price$16.00 Regular price$18.00
Garden Party Gel PensGarden Party Gel Pens
Garden Party Gel Pens

Set of 4

Sale price$18.50
Cake Slice Coin PouchCake Slice Coin Pouch
Cake Slice Coin PouchPaper Source Sale price$14.99
Shower Dish and Steamer SetShower Dish and Steamer Set
Shower Dish and Steamer SetPaper Source

Set of 4

Sale price$29.99
World's Smallest OperationWorld's Smallest Operation
World's Smallest Operation Sale price$8.99
Christmas Good Boys Electronic Gift Card
Christmas Good Boys Electronic Gift Card Sale price$0.00
Merry & Bright Thinking PuttyMerry & Bright Thinking Putty
Merry & Bright Thinking Putty Sale price$3.99
Sold outLittle Snowman Plush - In Store Exclusive
Little Snowman Plush - In Store Exclusive Sale price$25.00
National Parks Wrap & Poster
National Parks Wrap & PosterCavallini & Co. Sale price$9.50
Orange Mushroom Ambient Light
Orange Mushroom Ambient Light Sale price$27.50
Happy Birthday Physical Gift Card
Happy Birthday Physical Gift Card Sale price$0.00
Sold outVivacious Vegetable Eggplant Plush - In Store Exclusive
Vivacious Vegetable Eggplant Plush - In Store Exclusive Sale price$55.00
Save 24%Cavallini & Co - National Parks 1,000 Piece Jigsaw PuzzleCavallini & Co - National Parks 1,000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
Cavallini & Co - National Parks 1,000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle Sale price$18.99 Regular price$24.95
(3.3)
Wreath Light Up Glasses
Wreath Light Up Glasses Sale price$12.99
Festive Tree SquishyFestive Tree Squishy
Festive Tree Squishy Sale price$5.99
Greenery Wreath with Red Poms
Greenery Wreath with Red Poms Sale price$34.99
MAGNA-TILES microMAGS Travel Set, 26-Piece Magnetic Construction Set, The ORIGINAL Magnetic Building BrandMAGNA-TILES microMAGS Travel Set, 26-Piece Magnetic Construction Set, The ORIGINAL Magnetic Building Brand
MAGNA-TILES microMAGS Travel Set, 26-Piece Magnetic Construction Set, The ORIGINAL Magnetic Building Brand Sale price$19.99
Taylor Swift: A Little Golden Book BiographyTaylor Swift: A Little Golden Book Biography
Taylor Swift: A Little Golden Book Biography Sale price$5.99
Rifle Paper Co. Vintage Blossoms Flat Wrap
Rifle Paper Co. Vintage Blossoms Flat WrapRifle Paper Co. Sale price$6.50
Premium Chanukah Candles Blue Light Blue & WhitePremium Chanukah Candles Blue Light Blue & White
Premium Chanukah Candles Blue Light Blue & White Sale price$15.99
Sink Yeti SpongeSink Yeti Sponge
Sink Yeti Sponge Sale price$9.99
Wendy Gold USA State Flowers 1000 Piece PuzzleWendy Gold USA State Flowers 1000 Piece Puzzle
Wendy Gold USA State Flowers 1000 Piece Puzzle Sale price$17.99
(3.1)
Sold outCowboy Boot MatchesCowboy Boot Matches
Cowboy Boot Matches Sale price$22.00
Bunny Wind Up Toy
Bunny Wind Up Toy Sale price$4.99
Christmas Tree Rubik's CubeChristmas Tree Rubik's Cube
Christmas Tree Rubik's Cube Sale price$11.99
Romantic Floral ToteRomantic Floral Tote
Romantic Floral Tote Sale price$24.99
Butterfly Glass Trinket Dish
Butterfly Glass Trinket Dish Sale price$16.50
Spooky Jokes Card Deck
Spooky Jokes Card Deck Sale price$5.50
Squishmas SquishkinsSquishmas Squishkins
Squishmas Squishkins Sale price$5.99

Unique Gift Ideas

Shop our specially curated selection of unique gifts for all ages and occasions. We’ve got gifts for every holiday and season including birthdays, Christmas, Hanukkah, Easter, Father’s Day, Mother’s Day, and more. Whether you’re searching for a gift for grandma, your sister, or coworkers, our gift ideas will inspire giving in a fun and personal way! Browse through a variety of themed gifts including calendars and planners, journals and candles, and drinkware to find the perfect gift for your teen, husband, or wine loving friend. Explore our selection of trending books, décor, useful gadgets, adult games and puzzles, and toys for kids.

Discover uncommon gifts at Paper Source. Whether you’re looking for gift ideas for your girlfriend, parents, or your teacher, we have plenty of wonderful gifts under $20 and $30. From wine glasses and slippers that mom would love to coffee mugs and socks for dad, find gifts for everyone on your shopping list. Check out our personalized gift guide for more gift ideas!