Save up to 40% on Personalized Stationery →
20% Off 5 or more Greeting Cards →
Hundreds of Gifts, Crafts & more on sale! Shop Paper Cuts →
Free Standard Shipping on orders $60+ →
10% Off when you sign up for SMS alerts →
  • Go to slide 1
  • Go to slide 2
  • Go to slide 3
  • Go to slide 4
  • Go to slide 5
Login My Favorites

Cart

Your cart is empty

Gifts

Sort by

4215 Results

Filters
Sold outFish Bowl SlimeFish Bowl Slime
Fish Bowl Slime Sale price$9.50
Bamboo Bath Tub CaddyBamboo Bath Tub Caddy
Bamboo Bath Tub CaddyPaper Source Sale price$39.99
Sold outJellycat Jack Plush - In Store ExclusiveJellycat Jack Plush - In Store Exclusive
Jellycat Jack Plush - In Store Exclusive Sale price$50.00
Sold outDaphne Pomeranian Plush - In Store ExclusiveDaphne Pomeranian Plush - In Store Exclusive
Daphne Pomeranian Plush - In Store Exclusive Sale price$40.00
MAGNATAB MINI SEASONAL: SNOWFLAKE
MAGNATAB MINI SEASONAL: SNOWFLAKE Sale price$9.99
Sold outMyrtle Hippopotamus Plush - In Store ExclusiveMyrtle Hippopotamus Plush - In Store Exclusive
Myrtle Hippopotamus Plush - In Store Exclusive Sale price$55.00
Sold outSanta and Elf Window Gel Clings
Santa and Elf Window Gel ClingsPaper Source

Set of 12

Sale price$9.99
Fidget Cube By Antsy Labs Series 4 by ZURUFidget Cube By Antsy Labs Series 4 by ZURU
Fidget Cube By Antsy Labs Series 4 by ZURU Sale price$6.99
Sold outBow Hair Claw ClipBow Hair Claw Clip
Bow Hair Claw ClipPaper Source Sale price$12.99
Cruising Fox Glass Ornament
Cruising Fox Glass Ornament Sale price$19.99
Arboretum Wrap & Poster
Arboretum Wrap & PosterCavallini & Co. Sale price$9.50
Sold outCanned Sadines Glass Ornament
Canned Sadines Glass Ornament Sale price$19.99
Bugs & Insects Flat Wrap & Poster
Bugs & Insects Flat Wrap & PosterCavallini & Co. Sale price$9.50
Sold outMarguerite Flat WrapMarguerite Flat Wrap
Marguerite Flat WrapRifle Paper Co. Sale price$6.50
Red HoHoHo Glasses
Red HoHoHo GlassesPaper Source Sale price$10.50
Sold outEaster Charm Bracelet
Easter Charm Bracelet Sale price$10.99
Sold outAmuseable Baseball Plush - In Store ExclusiveAmuseable Baseball Plush - In Store Exclusive
Amuseable Baseball Plush - In Store Exclusive Sale price$33.00
Make A Wish Flying Wish PaperMake A Wish Flying Wish Paper
Make A Wish Flying Wish Paper Sale price$13.50
Sold outSquishmas Groovy TreeSquishmas Groovy Tree
Squishmas Groovy Tree

Set of 15

Sale price$14.99
Sold outLEGO® Iconic Gingerbread Ornaments 40642 (Retiring Soon)LEGO® Iconic Gingerbread Ornaments 40642 (Retiring Soon)
LEGO® Iconic Gingerbread Ornaments 40642 (Retiring Soon) Sale price$12.99
Emergency Cat Sound MachineEmergency Cat Sound Machine
Emergency Cat Sound Machine Sale price$15.50
French Baguette Glass Ornament
French Baguette Glass Ornament Sale price$19.99
Sold outRifle Paper Co. Nutcracker Ornament
Rifle Paper Co. Nutcracker OrnamentRifle Paper Co. Sale price$24.50
Paper Bag Triangle Custom JournalPaper Bag Triangle Custom Journal
Paper Bag Triangle Custom JournalPaper Source Sale price$19.95
Paint A Ceramic Christmas Tree
Paint A Ceramic Christmas Tree Sale price$14.99
Sold outHuddles Kangaroo Plush - In Store ExclusiveHuddles Kangaroo Plush - In Store Exclusive
Huddles Kangaroo Plush - In Store Exclusive Sale price$45.00
Stripes Physical Gift Card
Stripes Physical Gift Card Sale price$0.00
Stinkin' Love You Skunk Kids Socks
Stinkin' Love You Skunk Kids SocksPaper Source Sale price$12.99
Custom Embosser Gift SetCustom Embosser Gift Set
Custom Embosser Gift SetPaper Source Sale price$60.00
Sold outNICE CUBE NEE DOHNICE CUBE NEE DOH
NICE CUBE NEE DOH Sale price$6.99
Plant Seeds Teacher Thank You Card
Plant Seeds Teacher Thank You Card Sale price$5.50
Sold outPassport Ornament
Passport Ornament Sale price$19.50
Spooky Temporary TattoosSpooky Temporary Tattoos
Spooky Temporary Tattoos

Set of 63

Sale price$4.99
Thank You Electronic Gift Card
Thank You Electronic Gift Card Sale price$0.00
On-the-Go Amusements: 50 Silly Scavenger Hunts for Everyone
On-the-Go Amusements: 50 Silly Scavenger Hunts for Everyone Sale price$8.95
Liberty Rachel II Lavender Heat PillowLiberty Rachel II Lavender Heat Pillow
Liberty Rachel II Lavender Heat Pillow Sale price$34.99
Cavallini & Co. Celestial Medium Gift Bag
Cavallini & Co. Celestial Medium Gift Bag Sale price$7.50
World Map Wrap & Poster
World Map Wrap & PosterCavallini & Co. Sale price$9.50
Sold outHoliday Window Gel ClingsHoliday Window Gel Clings
Holiday Window Gel ClingsPaper Source

Set of 12

Sale price$12.99
Sold outStrawberry Lip Balm
Strawberry Lip Balm Sale price$6.95
Cream Paper Wasp Lined JournalCream Paper Wasp Lined Journal
Cream Paper Wasp Lined Journal Sale price$19.95
Save 50%Lavender Paper Wasp Undated PlannerLavender Paper Wasp Undated Planner
Lavender Paper Wasp Undated PlannerPaper Source Sale price$14.97 Regular price$29.95
The Essential Compendium of Dad Jokes: The Best of the Worst Dad Jokes for the Painfully Punny Parent301 Jokes!The Essential Compendium of Dad Jokes: The Best of the Worst Dad Jokes for the Painfully Punny Parent301 Jokes!
The Essential Compendium of Dad Jokes: The Best of the Worst Dad Jokes for the Painfully Punny Parent301 Jokes! Sale price$16.95
Bad Corgi Adult SocksBad Corgi Adult Socks
Bad Corgi Adult SocksPaper Source Sale price$14.99
Sold outWind Up PumpkinWind Up Pumpkin
Wind Up PumpkinPaper Source Sale price$3.50
Reindeer Silicone Coin PouchReindeer Silicone Coin Pouch
Reindeer Silicone Coin Pouch Sale price$9.99
Light Up Bunnies, AssortedLight Up Bunnies, Assorted
Light Up Bunnies, AssortedPaper Source Sale price$4.99
Sold outSelfcare Dog Glass OrnamentSelfcare Dog Glass Ornament
Selfcare Dog Glass Ornament Sale price$19.99

Unique Gift Ideas

Shop our specially curated selection of unique gifts for all ages and occasions. We’ve got gifts for every holiday and season including birthdays, Christmas, Hanukkah, Easter, Father’s Day, Mother’s Day, and more. Whether you’re searching for a gift for grandma, your sister, or coworkers, our gift ideas will inspire giving in a fun and personal way! Browse through a variety of themed gifts including calendars and planners, journals and candles, and drinkware to find the perfect gift for your teen, husband, or wine loving friend. Explore our selection of trending books, décor, useful gadgets, adult games and puzzles, and toys for kids.

Discover uncommon gifts at Paper Source. Whether you’re looking for gift ideas for your girlfriend, parents, or your teacher, we have plenty of wonderful gifts under $20 and $30. From wine glasses and slippers that mom would love to coffee mugs and socks for dad, find gifts for everyone on your shopping list. Check out our personalized gift guide for more gift ideas!