20% Off Personalized Stationery →
30% Off Custom Holiday Photo Cards →
Save 20% on Greeting Cards when you purchase 5+ →
Free Standard Shipping on Orders $50+ →
25% Off Holiday Card Sets →
  • Go to slide 1
  • Go to slide 2
  • Go to slide 3
  • Go to slide 4
  • Go to slide 5
Login My Favorites

Cart

Your cart is empty

Gifts

Sort by

3584 Results

Filters
Hey Clay Advent CalendarHey Clay Advent Calendar
Hey Clay Advent Calendar Sale price$32.99
Festive Nail StickersFestive Nail Stickers
Festive Nail Stickers

Set of 160

Sale price$6.99
Valentine's Day Beaded Bracelets
Valentine's Day Beaded Bracelets

Set of 3

Sale price$12.99
Golf Tool
Golf Tool Sale price$25.00
Save 20%Paper Bag Triangle Custom JournalPaper Bag Triangle Custom Journal
Paper Bag Triangle Custom JournalPaper Source Sale price$15.96 Regular price$19.95
Save 20%Bombshell Mixed Personalized Notepads
Bombshell Mixed Personalized NotepadsPaper Source Sale price$28.00 Regular price$35.00
I Should Have Known That! Trivia GameI Should Have Known That! Trivia Game
I Should Have Known That! Trivia Game Sale price$20.00
A Guide to Midwestern Conversation
A Guide to Midwestern Conversation Sale price$16.99
Cloud Fuzzy Crew SocksCloud Fuzzy Crew Socks
Cloud Fuzzy Crew SocksPaper Source Sale price$16.50
Allium Yellow Embroidered Canvas Tote BagAllium Yellow Embroidered Canvas Tote Bag
Allium Yellow Embroidered Canvas Tote Bag Sale price$32.99
Grey Cat Hot/Cold PillowGrey Cat Hot/Cold Pillow
Grey Cat Hot/Cold PillowPaper Source Sale price$29.99
Liberty Rachel II Lavender Heat PillowLiberty Rachel II Lavender Heat Pillow
Liberty Rachel II Lavender Heat Pillow Sale price$34.99
Sold outSave 30%Lite Brite OrnamentLite Brite Ornament
Lite Brite Ornament Sale price$13.99 Regular price$19.99
Mindful Crafts: Meditative Marbling KitMindful Crafts: Meditative Marbling Kit
Mindful Crafts: Meditative Marbling Kit Sale price$29.95
(5.0)
ReversoReverso
Reverso Sale price$5.99
Nutcracker Push PuppetsNutcracker Push Puppets
Nutcracker Push Puppets Sale price$11.99
(1.0)
Things To Do With Dad CouponsThings To Do With Dad Coupons
Things To Do With Dad Coupons Sale price$6.99
Coffee Pot OrnamentCoffee Pot Ornament
Coffee Pot Ornament Sale price$17.99
Light Up Bunnies, AssortedLight Up Bunnies, Assorted
Light Up Bunnies, Assorted Sale price$4.99
Bees & Honey 2 Wrap & Poster
Bees & Honey 2 Wrap & PosterCavallini & Co. Sale price$9.50
Holiday Bath Fizzers Set of 6
Holiday Bath Fizzers Set of 6

Set of 63

Sale price$16.99
Sold out10" Felted Christmas Tree
10" Felted Christmas Tree Sale price$12.99
Sold outBeautiful Bugs (Paint by Sticker Kids Series)Beautiful Bugs (Paint by Sticker Kids Series)
Beautiful Bugs (Paint by Sticker Kids Series) Sale price$9.95
Fidget Cube By Antsy Labs Series 4 by ZURUFidget Cube By Antsy Labs Series 4 by ZURU
Fidget Cube By Antsy Labs Series 4 by ZURU Sale price$6.99
Nostalgic Lidded Tree CandleNostalgic Lidded Tree Candle
Nostalgic Lidded Tree Candle Sale price$19.99
Hydrangea Trinket DishHydrangea Trinket Dish
Hydrangea Trinket Dish Sale price$18.50
Pop Tart Glass Ornament
Pop Tart Glass Ornament Sale price$18.99
Bloody Mary Glass Ornament
Bloody Mary Glass Ornament Sale price$19.99
Extraordinary Things to Cut Out and Collage
Extraordinary Things to Cut Out and Collage Sale price$19.99
(4.3)
USA Map Wrap & Poster
USA Map Wrap & PosterCavallini & Co. Sale price$9.50
Chaos Coordinator Socks
Chaos Coordinator Socks Sale price$10.99
Mirror Ball Ornament, Set of 3
Mirror Ball Ornament, Set of 3

Set of 3

Sale price$18.99
Epic Stretch AstronautEpic Stretch Astronaut
Epic Stretch Astronaut Sale price$14.50
Save 20%From the Desk of Personalized Notepad Set
From the Desk of Personalized Notepad SetPaper Source Sale price$28.00 Regular price$35.00
Confetti CrayonsConfetti Crayons
Confetti Crayons

Set of 12

Sale price$8.99
Tayto Potato Cat Blind BoxTayto Potato Cat Blind Box
Tayto Potato Cat Blind Box Sale price$15.00
Cheese Wedge OrnamentCheese Wedge Ornament
Cheese Wedge Ornament Sale price$17.99
Braided Bow HeadbandBraided Bow Headband
Braided Bow HeadbandPaper Source Sale price$15.99
Sold outAmuseable Rainbow Birthday Cake Plush - In Store ExclusiveAmuseable Rainbow Birthday Cake Plush - In Store Exclusive
Amuseable Rainbow Birthday Cake Plush - In Store Exclusive Sale price$38.00
Holiday Charades with PropsHoliday Charades with Props
Holiday Charades with Props Sale price$19.99
How To Speak CatHow To Speak Cat
How To Speak Cat Sale price$12.50
Holiday Squish ToysHoliday Squish Toys
Holiday Squish Toys

Set of 6

Sale price$10.50
Heart Window Gel ClingsHeart Window Gel Clings
Heart Window Gel Clings

Set of 9

Sale price$9.99
Season's Greetings Physical Gift Card
Season's Greetings Physical Gift Card Sale price$0.00
Book Club KeychainBook Club Keychain
Book Club KeychainRifle Paper Co. Sale price$18.50
Sold outAdult Sock Monkey SockAdult Sock Monkey Sock
Adult Sock Monkey Sock Sale price$19.99
Sold outRifle Paper Co. Mayfair Floral Notepad
Rifle Paper Co. Mayfair Floral NotepadRifle Paper Co. Sale price$12.50
Mineralogie Wrap & Poster
Mineralogie Wrap & PosterCavallini & Co. Sale price$9.50

Unique Gift Ideas

Shop our specially curated selection of unique gifts for all ages and occasions. We’ve got gifts for every holiday and season including birthdays, Christmas, Hanukkah, Easter, Father’s Day, Mother’s Day, and more. Whether you’re searching for a gift for grandma, your sister, or coworkers, our gift ideas will inspire giving in a fun and personal way! Browse through a variety of themed gifts including calendars and planners, journals and candles, and drinkware to find the perfect gift for your teen, husband, or wine loving friend. Explore our selection of trending books, décor, useful gadgets, adult games and puzzles, and toys for kids.

Discover uncommon gifts at Paper Source. Whether you’re looking for gift ideas for your girlfriend, parents, or your teacher, we have plenty of wonderful gifts under $20 and $30. From wine glasses and slippers that mom would love to coffee mugs and socks for dad, find gifts for everyone on your shopping list. Check out our personalized gift guide for more gift ideas!