Stores open one hour early on Father's Day! Find Your Store →
Save up to 40% on Personalized Stationery →
20% Off 5 or more Greeting Cards →
Free Standard Shipping on orders $60+ →
10% Off when you sign up for SMS alerts →
  • Go to slide 1
  • Go to slide 2
  • Go to slide 3
  • Go to slide 4
  • Go to slide 5
Login My Favorites

Cart

Your cart is empty

Our Favorite Gifts

Explore our handpicked recommendations of top gifts for every occasion from birthdays to anniversaries and every holiday in between.

Sort by

154 Results

Filters
Regal Blue Border NotesetRegal Blue Border Noteset
Regal Blue Border Noteset

Set of 20

Sale price$34.00
Cucumber Eye GelsCucumber Eye Gels
Cucumber Eye GelsPaper Source Sale price$10.50
Single Initial Monogram Custom StampStep-by-step video detailing how to replace the custom stamp plate.
Single Initial Monogram Custom StampPaper Source Sale price$29.95
Monogram Laurel Stationery
Monogram Laurel StationeryPaper Source Sale price$2.03 Each
Tranquility Custom JournalTranquility Custom Journal
Tranquility Custom JournalPaper Source Sale price$19.95
The Art of Memory Collecting: 15 Scrapbook, Collage, Trinket and Zine Projects For Crafting Treasured Moments
The Art of Memory Collecting: 15 Scrapbook, Collage, Trinket and Zine Projects For Crafting Treasured Moments Sale price$24.99
Satin Heatless Curling SetSatin Heatless Curling Set
Satin Heatless Curling Set Sale price$18.00
Sarasa Clip Vintage Dark PensSarasa Clip Vintage Dark Pens
Sarasa Clip Vintage Dark Pens

Set of 5

Sale price$12.99
Boots Custom JournalBoots Custom Journal
Boots Custom JournalPaper Source Sale price$19.95
Boots Mixed Personalized NotepadsBoots Mixed Personalized Notepads
Boots Mixed Personalized NotepadsPaper Source Sale price$35.00
Lavender Mint Shower Steamers
Lavender Mint Shower Steamers Sale price$17.00
Bamboo Bath Tub CaddyBamboo Bath Tub Caddy
Bamboo Bath Tub CaddyPaper Source Sale price$39.99
Rifle Paper Co. Menagerie Embroidered Heirloom Photo AlbumRifle Paper Co. Menagerie Embroidered Heirloom Photo Album
Rifle Paper Co. Menagerie Embroidered Heirloom Photo AlbumRifle Paper Co. Sale price$50.00
ClickArt Pastel Marker PenClickArt Pastel Marker Pen
ClickArt Pastel Marker Pen

Set of 12

Sale price$24.99
Copperplate Monogram A2 Stationery
Copperplate Monogram A2 StationeryPaper Source Sale price$2.50 Each
Fidget Cube By Antsy Labs Series 4 by ZURUFidget Cube By Antsy Labs Series 4 by ZURU
Fidget Cube By Antsy Labs Series 4 by ZURU Sale price$6.99
Weighted Lap BlanketWeighted Lap Blanket
Weighted Lap BlanketPaper Source Sale price$39.99
Golf Tool
Golf Tool Sale price$25.00
Paper Bag Triangle Custom JournalPaper Bag Triangle Custom Journal
Paper Bag Triangle Custom JournalPaper Source Sale price$19.95
Felt Catchall Set
Felt Catchall Set

Set of 2

Sale price$14.99
Merry & Bright Electronic Gift Card
Merry & Bright Electronic Gift Card Sale price$0.00
Bellzi Brontosaurus Dinosaur PlushBellzi Brontosaurus Dinosaur Plush
Bellzi Brontosaurus Dinosaur Plush Sale price$19.99
Hydrangea Trinket DishHydrangea Trinket Dish
Hydrangea Trinket DishRifle Paper Co. Sale price$18.50
Typewriter Personalized Notepad Set
Typewriter Personalized Notepad SetPaper Source Sale price$35.00
Cool Cats MugCool Cats Mug
Cool Cats MugRifle Paper Co. Sale price$24.50
How To Speak CatHow To Speak Cat
How To Speak Cat Sale price$12.50
The New York Times Simply Having a Wonderful Crossword Time: 200 Easy to Hard Puzzles
The New York Times Simply Having a Wonderful Crossword Time: 200 Easy to Hard Puzzles Sale price$14.00
Merry Christmas Electronic Gift Card
Merry Christmas Electronic Gift Card Sale price$0.00
Save 50%Lavender Paper Wasp Undated PlannerLavender Paper Wasp Undated Planner
Lavender Paper Wasp Undated Planner Sale price$14.97 Regular price$29.95
Wind Down KitWind Down Kit
Wind Down Kit Sale price$35.50
Floral Stationery
Floral StationeryPaper Source Sale price$2.03 Each
Lonely Planet Epic Hikes of the Americas: 200 Amazing Treks & Trails Travel Planning Tips & Advice Easy & Challenging Adventures Beautiful Photography & MapsLonely Planet Epic Hikes of the Americas: 200 Amazing Treks & Trails Travel Planning Tips & Advice Easy & Challenging Adventures Beautiful Photography & Maps
Lonely Planet Epic Hikes of the Americas: 200 Amazing Treks & Trails Travel Planning Tips & Advice Easy & Challenging Adventures Beautiful Photography & Maps Sale price$35.00
Rose Quartz Stone Eye MaskRose Quartz Stone Eye Mask
Rose Quartz Stone Eye MaskPaper Source Sale price$34.00
Cream Paper Wasp Lined JournalCream Paper Wasp Lined Journal
Cream Paper Wasp Lined Journal Sale price$19.95
Curled Up Cat Hair Clip
Curled Up Cat Hair ClipPaper Source Sale price$14.99
uni One P. Asst. 2 CT
uni One P. Asst. 2 CT

Set of 2

Sale price$15.99
Bombshell Mixed Personalized Notepads
Bombshell Mixed Personalized NotepadsPaper Source Sale price$35.00
Flower Market Custom JournalFlower Market Custom Journal
Flower Market Custom JournalPaper Source Sale price$19.95
Mountainside Mixed Personalized Notepads
Mountainside Mixed Personalized NotepadsPaper Source Sale price$35.00
Swivel Charcuterie Board SetSwivel Charcuterie Board Set
Swivel Charcuterie Board SetPaper Source Sale price$34.99
Booze & Vinyl Country: 100+ Spirited Music-and-Drink PairingsBooze & Vinyl Country: 100+ Spirited Music-and-Drink Pairings
Booze & Vinyl Country: 100+ Spirited Music-and-Drink Pairings Sale price$26.00
National Parks Tote Bag
National Parks Tote BagCavallini & Co. Sale price$19.50
National Parks Small Journals
National Parks Small JournalsCavallini & Co. Sale price$12.50
Parks of the US Bucket List Water BottleParks of the US Bucket List Water Bottle
Parks of the US Bucket List Water Bottle Sale price$58.00
Rustic Home Sweet Home Paddle Cutting Board
Rustic Home Sweet Home Paddle Cutting BoardPaper Source Sale price$34.99
Save 30%Stabilo Point 88 Fineliner Pen SetStabilo Point 88 Fineliner Pen Set
Stabilo Point 88 Fineliner Pen Set

Set of 30

Sale price$28.70 Regular price$41.00
Green Paper Wasp Lined JournalGreen Paper Wasp Lined Journal
Green Paper Wasp Lined Journal Sale price$19.95
Starry Silicone Reusable Eye GelsStarry Silicone Reusable Eye Gels
Starry Silicone Reusable Eye GelsPaper Source Sale price$14.00
Sweet Streams Sleep MaskSweet Streams Sleep Mask
Sweet Streams Sleep Mask Sale price$42.50
Mini Bear Hair Clips
Mini Bear Hair ClipsPaper Source

Set of 2

Sale price$9.99

TOP GIFTS FOR 2026

Need a gift but don’t have any ideas? Spend less time searching for the perfect birthday, anniversary, graduation, retirement or housewarming gift with our curated gift ideas from Paper Source. Whether you’re looking for a gift for Valentine’s Day, Christmas or Hanukkah, spend more time gifting with our selection of the best gifts for 2026. Our list includes top presents for everyone’s age and interest and for your budget. Discover the best gifts below $20, $30 and under $50 all in one place.

Browse through our fun, trendy and useful gift suggestions that will provide inspiration for presents for friends, family, significant others and coworkers. From popular toys like LEGO Flowers and Jellycat stuffed animals to cool party games, stylish journals and planners, and adorable ambient lights, we have a variety of options. Perfect for kids, teens, spouses and your grandparents, this gift collection has something special for everyone.

Whether you’re shopping for a small gift to simply show someone you care or you’re looking for a larger gift for a special occasion, find it here. Shop unique gifts like affirmation card decks, luxurious scented candles, quirky books, novelty mugs, amusing puzzles, quality leather and guided journals, vibrant wall calendars, much-needed self-care tools, squishy stress-relief toys and of course Paper Source gift cards!

10 Best Gift Ideas for 2026

2026 Great Big Calendar

Country Farm Champs de France Glass Candle

Bamboo Bath Tub Caddy

Custom Embosser Gift Set

Linen Sleep Mask

Uni-ball One P. Gel Pen

Colorful Border A6 Stationery

Bro Mask

The Five Minute Journal

Desktop Therapist