Mother's Day is Sunday! Shop in stores for last-minute gifts.
Save on Personalized Stationery! The more you buy, the more you save!
Free Standard Shipping on Orders $50+
Save 20% on Greeting Cards when you purchase 5+
  • Go to slide 1
  • Go to slide 2
  • Go to slide 3
  • Go to slide 4
Login My Favorites

Cart View cart

Your cart is empty

Paper Source: Stationery, Gifts, Wrap & More

Sort by

13577 Results

I Chews You Valentine's Day Card
I Chews You Valentine's Day Card Sale price$5.50
Ice Cream Trucks Classroom Valentine Card SetIce Cream Trucks Classroom Valentine Card Set
Ice Cream Trucks Classroom Valentine Card Set Sale price$19.50
Sold out2025 Paper Source Guava Chicago Ave Medium Weekly Spiral Planner2025 Paper Source Guava Chicago Ave Medium Weekly Spiral Planner
2025 Paper Source Guava Chicago Ave Medium Weekly Spiral Planner Sale price$29.99
Elegant Greenery Birds Holiday Card SetElegant Greenery Birds Holiday Card Set
Elegant Greenery Birds Holiday Card Set Sale price$24.50
Envelope Template KitEnvelope Template Kit
Envelope Template Kit Sale price$15.50
Satin Antique Gold 1" 10YD
Satin Antique Gold 1" 10YD Sale price$8.00
Garden Party Blue Wrapping PaperGarden Party Blue Wrapping Paper
Garden Party Blue Wrapping Paper Sale price$11.00
Happy Birthday Electronic Gift Card
Happy Birthday Electronic Gift Card Sale price$0.00
Sold out2025 Paper Source Brown Weekly Planner2025 Paper Source Brown Weekly Planner
2025 Paper Source Brown Weekly Planner Sale price$29.99
Metallic Fringe Ribbon 1/2" 10 YD
Metallic Fringe Ribbon 1/2" 10 YD Sale price$13.50
Colorful Watercolor Dots Stone Wrapping PaperColorful Watercolor Dots Stone Wrapping Paper
Colorful Watercolor Dots Stone Wrapping Paper Sale price$10.50
Forest Green Replacement Inkpad for Custom Stamps
Forest Green Replacement Inkpad for Custom StampsThree Designing Women Sale price$5.95
Sold out2025 Paper Source Desk Art Easel Calendar
2025 Paper Source Desk Art Easel Calendar Sale price$19.99
Skinny Red & Gold Cotton Ribbon
Skinny Red & Gold Cotton Ribbon Sale price$10.50
Sold outCupcake Sprinkles Birthday CardCupcake Sprinkles Birthday Card
Cupcake Sprinkles Birthday Card Sale price$6.50
Garland Tree Gift Tags S/10
Garland Tree Gift Tags S/10 Sale price$10.50
Simply Modern Custom Stamp and Stamp Tool
Simply Modern Custom Stamp and Stamp ToolPaper Source Sale price$39.95
Creature Stirring Holiday Card Set
Creature Stirring Holiday Card Set Sale price$17.50
Happy Birthday Dual Roll Stone Paper Roll WrapHappy Birthday Dual Roll Stone Paper Roll Wrap
Happy Birthday Dual Roll Stone Paper Roll Wrap Sale price$18.50
Watercolor Shapes Birthday Card
Watercolor Shapes Birthday Card Sale price$5.50
XMAS A2 Cedar Branch Holiday Card Set
XMAS A2 Cedar Branch Holiday Card Set Sale price$18.50
Save 30%Frasier Fir Gift Tags
Frasier Fir Gift Tags Sale price$6.30 Regular price$9.00
Vintage Christmas StickersVintage Christmas Stickers
Vintage Christmas Stickers Sale price$15.50
MED Rifle Penguin Village Gift Bag
MED Rifle Penguin Village Gift Bag Sale price$6.50
Save 30%Flower Pencils Valentine Card Kit
Flower Pencils Valentine Card Kit Sale price$17.50 Regular price$25.00
Birthday Cake Wrapping PaperBirthday Cake Wrapping Paper
Birthday Cake Wrapping Paper Sale price$11.00
Skinny Cotton Ribbon Cream/Gold 50yd
Skinny Cotton Ribbon Cream/Gold 50yd Sale price$10.50
Boop Nose Card
Boop Nose Card Sale price$6.50
Sold out2025 Paper Source Catitude Desk Easel2025 Paper Source Catitude Desk Easel
2025 Paper Source Catitude Desk Easel Sale price$19.99
Newport Navy Replacement Inkpad for Custom Stamps
Newport Navy Replacement Inkpad for Custom StampsPaper Source Sale price$5.95
XMAS A6 Gold Foil Type Tree Holiday Card Set
XMAS A6 Gold Foil Type Tree Holiday Card Set Sale price$19.50
A7 Superfine White Envelopes
A7 Superfine White Envelopes Sale price$6.50
Balloon Animals Stone Wrapping PaperBalloon Animals Stone Wrapping Paper
Balloon Animals Stone Wrapping Paper Sale price$10.50
Cat Bookmarks Valentine Card Kit
Cat Bookmarks Valentine Card Kit Sale price$22.50
Sold out2025 Dear Hancock Bunny Desk Calendar2025 Dear Hancock Bunny Desk Calendar
2025 Dear Hancock Bunny Desk Calendar Sale price$21.00
MED Robin's Gift Bag
MED Robin's Gift Bag Sale price$8.50
Velvet Bows 4" S/6
Velvet Bows 4" S/6 Sale price$12.50
Heart Eyes Cat Valentine's Day Card
Heart Eyes Cat Valentine's Day Card Sale price$6.50
Rarest of them All Birthday Card
Rarest of them All Birthday Card Sale price$6.50
Stripe/Red/Fa la la Tissue Pack S/16
Stripe/Red/Fa la la Tissue Pack S/16 Sale price$10.50
LRG Rifle Willowberry Gift Bag
LRG Rifle Willowberry Gift Bag Sale price$9.50
Skinny Cotton Ribbon Green/Gold 50yd
Skinny Cotton Ribbon Green/Gold 50yd Sale price$10.50
Electronic Gift Card
Electronic Gift Card Sale price$0.00
Blue Wave Stone Wrapping PaperBlue Wave Stone Wrapping Paper
Blue Wave Stone Wrapping Paper Sale price$10.50
Tiny Birthday Delights Stone Wrapping PaperTiny Birthday Delights Stone Wrapping Paper
Tiny Birthday Delights Stone Wrapping Paper Sale price$10.50
Gold Vines on Cream Stone Wrapping Paper
Gold Vines on Cream Stone Wrapping Paper Sale price$10.50
Monogram Border A6 Stationery
Monogram Border A6 StationeryPaper Source Sale price$2.71 Each
LEGO Heart Ornament 40638LEGO Heart Ornament 40638
LEGO Heart Ornament 40638 Sale price$12.99