15% Off Your Order when you spend $100+ with code SAVE15 →
50% Off Custom Holiday Photo Cards →
30% Off Personalized Stationery →
Free Standard Shipping on Orders $50+ →
Holiday extended hours have begun! Connect with your local store for details →
  • Go to slide 1
  • Go to slide 2
  • Go to slide 3
  • Go to slide 4
  • Go to slide 5
Login My Favorites

Cart

Your cart is empty

Gifts Under $50

Sort by

2521 Results

Filters
Save 30%Colorful Border A6 Stationery
Colorful Border A6 Stationery

Lowest price of the season!

Paper Source Sale price$1.13 Regular price$1.62
2026 Paper Source The Great Big Calendar2026 Paper Source The Great Big Calendar
2026 Paper Source The Great Big CalendarPaper Source Sale price$31.99
(5.0)
Party Animals Wrapping PaperParty Animals Wrapping Paper
Party Animals Wrapping PaperRifle Paper Co. Sale price$12.50
(4.0)
Rifle Paper Co. Birthday Candles Wrapping Paper624326859.jpg
Rifle Paper Co. Birthday Candles Wrapping PaperRifle Paper Co. Sale price$12.50
Winter Wonderland Holiday Card SetWinter Wonderland Holiday Card Set
Winter Wonderland Holiday Card Set

25% Off - Discount applied in cart

Cavallini & Co.

Set of 10

Sale price$17.50
(5.0)
Save 30%Ascot A6 Stationery
Ascot A6 Stationery

Lowest price of the season!

Paper Source Sale price$1.13 Regular price$1.62
Happy Birthday Electronic Gift Card
Happy Birthday Electronic Gift Card Sale price$0.00
Vintage Christmas StickersVintage Christmas Stickers
Vintage Christmas Stickers Sale price$15.50
Hal the Jack-o-Lantern Glow in the Dark Learn to Crochet kitHal the Jack-o-Lantern Glow in the Dark Learn to Crochet kit
Hal the Jack-o-Lantern Glow in the Dark Learn to Crochet kit Sale price$29.99
Birthday Cake Wrapping PaperBirthday Cake Wrapping Paper
Birthday Cake Wrapping PaperRifle Paper Co. Sale price$12.50
Electronic Gift Card
Electronic Gift Card Sale price$0.00
LEGO Heart Ornament 40638LEGO Heart Ornament 40638
LEGO Heart Ornament 40638 Sale price$12.99
Custom Stamp Gift SetCustom Stamp Gift Set
Custom Stamp Gift SetPaper Source Sale price$39.95
Bro Mask
Bro Mask Sale price$8.00
2026 Paper Source Wall Art Calendar2026 Paper Source Wall Art Calendar
2026 Paper Source Wall Art CalendarPaper Source Sale price$31.99
(3.0)
Save 30%12-Month Custom Planner - Upload Your Own12-Month Custom Planner - Upload Your Own
12-Month Custom Planner - Upload Your Own

Lowest price of the season!

Paper Source Sale price$27.96 Regular price$39.95
(5.0)
Small Roland Pine CandleSmall Roland Pine Candle
Small Roland Pine Candle Sale price$15.00
Fart Sound MachineFart Sound Machine
Fart Sound Machine Sale price$14.50
Silent Night, Starry Night 1000 piece PuzzleSilent Night, Starry Night 1000 piece Puzzle
Silent Night, Starry Night 1000 piece Puzzle Sale price$22.95
Punching Cheeky Santa PenPunching Cheeky Santa Pen
Punching Cheeky Santa Pen Sale price$6.00
Lidded Coffin Match Box
Lidded Coffin Match BoxPaper Source Sale price$19.99
The Screaming Christmas Goat: Ahhhhh!
The Screaming Christmas Goat: Ahhhhh! Sale price$14.95
Festive Holiday NecklaceFestive Holiday Necklace
Festive Holiday Necklace Sale price$11.99
(1.0)
Desktop TherapistDesktop Therapist
Desktop Therapist Sale price$29.50
2026 Paper Source Tall on the Wall Calendar2026 Paper Source Tall on the Wall Calendar
2026 Paper Source Tall on the Wall Calendar Sale price$34.99
(4.0)
Fine Paper Pressed Flower Stationery SetFine Paper Pressed Flower Stationery Set
Fine Paper Pressed Flower Stationery Set

Set of 10

Sale price$17.50
Holiday Critter Squishies, Set of 6Holiday Critter Squishies, Set of 6
Holiday Critter Squishies, Set of 6

Set of 6

Sale price$10.99
624144741.jpg623789597.jpg
Meg the Gingerbread Woman - B&N Exclusive Sale price$29.99
Dumpling Ambient LightDumpling Ambient Light
Dumpling Ambient Light Sale price$27.50
Gingerbread Man Headband
Gingerbread Man HeadbandPaper Source Sale price$10.50
Easter Squish ToysEaster Squish Toys
Easter Squish Toys

Set of 6

Sale price$10.50
2025-2026 Paper Source Light Blue Leather 18-Month Weekly Desk Planner2025-2026 Paper Source Light Blue Leather 18-Month Weekly Desk Planner
2025-2026 Paper Source Light Blue Leather 18-Month Weekly Desk PlannerPaper Source Sale price$34.99
(3.0)
Pet Impression Ornament KitPet Impression Ornament Kit
Pet Impression Ornament Kit Sale price$16.50
Plantable HeartsPlantable Hearts
Plantable HeartsPaper Source Sale price$12.00
Valentine's Day SquishiesValentine's Day Squishies
Valentine's Day Squishies

Set of 6

Sale price$10.50
Cucumber Eye GelsCucumber Eye Gels
Cucumber Eye GelsPaper Source Sale price$10.50
Grey Cat Fuzzy Crew SocksGrey Cat Fuzzy Crew Socks
Grey Cat Fuzzy Crew SocksPaper Source Sale price$16.99
Birthday Cake Stationery SetBirthday Cake Stationery Set
Birthday Cake Stationery SetPaper Source

Set of 10

Sale price$19.50
Tinsel Trees Electronic Gift Card
Tinsel Trees Electronic Gift Card Sale price$0.00
Light Up ChicksLight Up Chicks
Light Up Chicks Sale price$4.50
CHRISTMAS IN A CANCHRISTMAS IN A CAN
CHRISTMAS IN A CAN Sale price$15.99
Save 30%Custom Journal - Upload Your OwnCustom Journal - Upload Your Own
Custom Journal - Upload Your Own

Lowest price of the season!

Paper Source Sale price$13.96 Regular price$19.95
Floral Electronic Gift Card
Floral Electronic Gift Card Sale price$0.00
LEGO Flowers Roses 40460LEGO Flowers Roses 40460
LEGO Flowers Roses 40460 Sale price$14.99
The Screaming GoatThe Screaming Goat
The Screaming Goat Sale price$13.95
Party Dogs & Cats Electronic Gift Card
Party Dogs & Cats Electronic Gift Card Sale price$0.00
Middle Finger Tiny HandMiddle Finger Tiny Hand
Middle Finger Tiny Hand Sale price$3.50
Wacky Waving Inflatable Tube Guy: (The Original)Wacky Waving Inflatable Tube Guy: (The Original)
Wacky Waving Inflatable Tube Guy: (The Original) Sale price$14.95
(1.0)