Save 25% on Select Stationery Sets →
Save up to 40% on Personalized Stationery →
Save 20% on Greeting Cards when you purchase 5+ →
Free Standard Shipping on Orders $50+ →
  • Go to slide 1
  • Go to slide 2
  • Go to slide 3
  • Go to slide 4
Login My Favorites

Cart

Your cart is empty

Gifts

Sort by

3473 Results

Filters
Howdy Halloween Socks
Howdy Halloween Socks Sale price$14.99
Kid's Sparkle Art: The PyramidKid's Sparkle Art: The Pyramid
Kid's Sparkle Art: The Pyramid Sale price$14.99
Rifle Paper Co. Garden Party Luggage Tag
Rifle Paper Co. Garden Party Luggage Tag Sale price$28.00
Sold outHolding Space Friendship Greeting CardHolding Space Friendship Greeting Card
Holding Space Friendship Greeting Card Sale price$5.00
Here For You Always Sympathy Card
Here For You Always Sympathy Card Sale price$5.00
Accordion Checked ToteAccordion Checked Tote
Accordion Checked Tote Sale price$24.99
Take Out Box Ornament
Take Out Box Ornament Sale price$17.50
Sold outHedgehog Measuring Cups
Hedgehog Measuring Cups Sale price$24.99
Tapple by NPD Partnership Ltd. (NPD Toys)Tapple by NPD Partnership Ltd. (NPD Toys)
Tapple by NPD Partnership Ltd. (NPD Toys) Sale price$21.99
Sold outSandy Snail Plush - In Store ExclusiveSandy Snail Plush - In Store Exclusive
Sandy Snail Plush - In Store Exclusive Sale price$27.00
Sold outMitzi Reindeer's Dream Book - In Store Exclusive
Mitzi Reindeer's Dream Book - In Store Exclusive Sale price$16.50
Sold outCitrus Crush Ceramic Flower CandleCitrus Crush Ceramic Flower Candle
Citrus Crush Ceramic Flower Candle Sale price$32.50
Lilac Genuine Leather JournalLilac Genuine Leather Journal
Lilac Genuine Leather Journal Sale price$44.99
Zen Garden Snow Day: A Little Time to Play
Zen Garden Snow Day: A Little Time to Play Sale price$12.95
Chick Slap BraceletChick Slap Bracelet
Chick Slap Bracelet Sale price$7.99
Easter Basket Window Gel ClingsEaster Basket Window Gel Clings
Easter Basket Window Gel Clings Sale price$9.99
Yahtzee: Cup Noodles by Edwin S. LoweYahtzee: Cup Noodles by Edwin S. Lowe
Yahtzee: Cup Noodles by Edwin S. Lowe Sale price$19.99
LCR? Left Center Right Dice Game Blue Tin Original by George & Company LLC
LCR? Left Center Right Dice Game Blue Tin Original by George & Company LLC Sale price$6.99
Book Club Pen
Book Club Pen Sale price$16.00
Live Laugh Loathe Cross Stitch Kit
Live Laugh Loathe Cross Stitch Kit Sale price$20.00
Rifle Paper Co. Easter Tea TowelRifle Paper Co. Easter Tea Towel
Rifle Paper Co. Easter Tea Towel Sale price$19.99
Plush Towel Hair Wrap - BluePlush Towel Hair Wrap - Blue
Plush Towel Hair Wrap - Blue Sale price$19.99
Wanted To Bug You Greeting Card
Wanted To Bug You Greeting Card Sale price$7.50
Blackwing Pencil Essential SetBlackwing Pencil Essential Set
Blackwing Pencil Essential Set Sale price$49.95
Floral Heart KeychainFloral Heart Keychain
Floral Heart Keychain Sale price$18.00
Cubebot Skeleton MicroCubebot Skeleton Micro
Cubebot Skeleton Micro Sale price$11.99
Sold outRainbow Palm PalRainbow Palm Pal
Rainbow Palm Pal Sale price$9.99
Bananagrams Game by Rena Nathanson and Abe NathansonBananagrams Game by Rena Nathanson and Abe Nathanson
Bananagrams Game by Rena Nathanson and Abe Nathanson Sale price$15.99
House Plants Tote BagHouse Plants Tote Bag
House Plants Tote Bag Sale price$19.50
Save 25%Succulents Carte Postale Postcard SetSucculents Carte Postale Postcard Set
Succulents Carte Postale Postcard Set

Set of 18

Sale price$12.37 Regular price$16.50
Delightfully Useless TriviaDelightfully Useless Trivia
Delightfully Useless Trivia Sale price$14.00
Sold outSave 30%Teachers Plant Seeds PlanterTeachers Plant Seeds Planter
Teachers Plant Seeds Planter Sale price$10.49 Regular price$14.99
Jeremiah Brent Weekly Rituals Organizational PadJeremiah Brent Weekly Rituals Organizational Pad
Jeremiah Brent Weekly Rituals Organizational Pad Sale price$19.99
Let's Get Lit Hanukkah Adult Socks
Let's Get Lit Hanukkah Adult Socks Sale price$14.99
Projector Dome Star MapProjector Dome Star Map
Projector Dome Star Map Sale price$23.99
Wishes For You Mother's Day Card
Wishes For You Mother's Day Card Sale price$5.00
Red Striped Glass Cloche with MatchesRed Striped Glass Cloche with Matches
Red Striped Glass Cloche with Matches Sale price$24.99
Celestial Embroidered PouchCelestial Embroidered Pouch
Celestial Embroidered Pouch Sale price$19.99
2025-2026 Paper Source Creative Borders Weekly Desk Planner2025-2026 Paper Source Creative Borders Weekly Desk Planner
2025-2026 Paper Source Creative Borders Weekly Desk Planner Sale price$34.99
Sold outMini Yoga Skeletons
Mini Yoga Skeletons Sale price$5.99
Rifle Paper Co. Peacock ClipfolioRifle Paper Co. Peacock Clipfolio
Rifle Paper Co. Peacock Clipfolio Sale price$28.50
Rainbow Congrats Electronic Gift Card
Rainbow Congrats Electronic Gift Card Sale price$0.00
Heart Teacher Thank You Card
Heart Teacher Thank You Card Sale price$6.50
Fuzzies by Alex Hague, Justin Vickers, Wolfgang WarschFuzzies by Alex Hague, Justin Vickers, Wolfgang Warsch
Fuzzies by Alex Hague, Justin Vickers, Wolfgang Warsch Sale price$17.99
Pink Champagne Body Care Set
Pink Champagne Body Care Set

Set of 2

Sale price$36.99
I Am NOT the Easter Bunny!I Am NOT the Easter Bunny!
I Am NOT the Easter Bunny! Sale price$12.99
Gold Luxe Wedding GuestbookGold Luxe Wedding Guestbook
Gold Luxe Wedding Guestbook Sale price$49.99
Travel Sewing Kit Liberty StripeTravel Sewing Kit Liberty Stripe
Travel Sewing Kit Liberty Stripe Sale price$14.99

Unique Gift Ideas

Shop our specially curated selection of unique gifts for all ages and occasions. We’ve got gifts for every holiday and season including birthdays, Christmas, Hanukkah, Easter, Father’s Day, Mother’s Day, and more. Whether you’re searching for a gift for grandma, your sister, or coworkers, our gift ideas will inspire giving in a fun and personal way! Browse through a variety of themed gifts including calendars and planners, journals and candles, and drinkware to find the perfect gift for your teen, husband, or wine loving friend. Explore our selection of trending books, décor, useful gadgets, adult games and puzzles, and toys for kids.

Discover uncommon gifts at Paper Source. Whether you’re looking for gift ideas for your girlfriend, parents, or your teacher, we have plenty of wonderful gifts under $20 and $30. From wine glasses and slippers that mom would love to coffee mugs and socks for dad, find gifts for everyone on your shopping list. Check out our personalized gift guide for more gift ideas!