Save 25% on Select Stationery Sets →
Save up to 40% on Personalized Stationery →
Save 20% on Greeting Cards when you purchase 5+ →
Free Standard Shipping on Orders $50+ →
  • Go to slide 1
  • Go to slide 2
  • Go to slide 3
  • Go to slide 4
Login My Favorites

Cart

Your cart is empty

Gifts

Sort by

3473 Results

Filters
Groovy Mushrooms Bath BombsGroovy Mushrooms Bath Bombs
Groovy Mushrooms Bath Bombs Sale price$11.00
Sold outCrescent Moon Mini SuncatcherCrescent Moon Mini Suncatcher
Crescent Moon Mini Suncatcher Sale price$22.00
Britney Ornament
Britney Ornament Sale price$22.50
Hohoho nail stickersHohoho nail stickers
Hohoho nail stickers Sale price$14.99
Petite Eucalyptus Satin ScrunchiesPetite Eucalyptus Satin Scrunchies
Petite Eucalyptus Satin Scrunchies

Set of 6

Sale price$12.50
Save 30%Egg Painting KitEgg Painting Kit
Egg Painting Kit Sale price$20.99 Regular price$29.99
Kanoodle GameKanoodle Game
Kanoodle Game Sale price$12.99
Save 30%Glass Ornament Tumblers S/2Glass Ornament Tumblers S/2
Glass Ornament Tumblers S/2

Set of 2

Sale price$13.99 Regular price$19.99
Sold outBrynlee Bee Plush - In Store ExclusiveBrynlee Bee Plush - In Store Exclusive
Brynlee Bee Plush - In Store Exclusive Sale price$28.00
2025-2026 Paper Source Chicago Ave Weekly Desk Planner2025-2026 Paper Source Chicago Ave Weekly Desk Planner
2025-2026 Paper Source Chicago Ave Weekly Desk Planner Sale price$34.99
Sold outRainbow Thinking Putty Tin
Rainbow Thinking Putty Tin Sale price$14.99
Magical World Of Disney TriviaMagical World Of Disney Trivia
Magical World Of Disney Trivia Sale price$39.99
The Chakra Energy Deck: 64 Poses and Meditations to Balance Mind, Body, and Spirit
The Chakra Energy Deck: 64 Poses and Meditations to Balance Mind, Body, and Spirit Sale price$18.95
Cupid Cat MugCupid Cat Mug
Cupid Cat Mug Sale price$15.99
Holiday Beaded Scrunchies, Set of 2Holiday Beaded Scrunchies, Set of 2
Holiday Beaded Scrunchies, Set of 2

Set of 2

Sale price$12.99
Gratitude Overflows Thank You CardGratitude Overflows Thank You Card
Gratitude Overflows Thank You Card Sale price$5.00
Sold outCloudy Day Bath SoakCloudy Day Bath Soak
Cloudy Day Bath Soak Sale price$16.00
(2.0)
Petite Terracotta Satin ScrunchiesPetite Terracotta Satin Scrunchies
Petite Terracotta Satin Scrunchies

Set of 6

Sale price$12.50
Axolotl Spudster PlushAxolotl Spudster Plush
Axolotl Spudster Plush Sale price$23.50
Sold outLittle Camper Lovey Bear PlushLittle Camper Lovey Bear Plush
Little Camper Lovey Bear Plush Sale price$26.50
Sold outMindful Texture Sand GardenMindful Texture Sand Garden
Mindful Texture Sand Garden Sale price$24.99
LEGO Icons Chrysanthemum 10368LEGO Icons Chrysanthemum 10368
LEGO Icons Chrysanthemum 10368 Sale price$29.99
(5.0)
Sold outJellycat Backpack Panda Plush - In Store ExclusiveJellycat Backpack Panda Plush - In Store Exclusive
Jellycat Backpack Panda Plush - In Store Exclusive Sale price$35.00
Sold outPS Collection Slim Stripe Ballpoint Pen S/3PS Collection Slim Stripe Ballpoint Pen S/3
PS Collection Slim Stripe Ballpoint Pen S/3

Set of 3

Sale price$12.99
Paper Source Black Leather Refillable A5 Journal CoverPaper Source Black Leather Refillable A5 Journal Cover
Paper Source Black Leather Refillable A5 Journal Cover Sale price$26.99
12-Month Book Cover Custom Planner12-Month Book Cover Custom Planner
12-Month Book Cover Custom PlannerPaper Source Sale price$39.95
Save 30%Peace Candle
Peace Candle Sale price$12.25 Regular price$17.50
Bug Mash UpBug Mash Up
Bug Mash Up Sale price$11.99
Stabilo MarkersStabilo Markers
Stabilo Markers

Set of 20

Sale price$30.00
Cavallini & Co. Mineralogie Tote Bag
Cavallini & Co. Mineralogie Tote Bag Sale price$19.50
Single Initial Monogram Black Luggage Tag
Single Initial Monogram Black Luggage TagPaper Source

Set of 2

Sale price$19.99
Tiny Easel SweetheartTiny Easel Sweetheart
Tiny Easel Sweetheart Sale price$34.99
Save 30%Egg Shaped CandleEgg Shaped Candle
Egg Shaped Candle Sale price$10.49 Regular price$14.99
Mini Green Felt Tree Decoration
Mini Green Felt Tree Decoration Sale price$12.50
Harvest Candle Set
Harvest Candle Set

Set of 3

Sale price$19.99
Save 30%Flocked Deer D?cor, Set of 2
Flocked Deer D?cor, Set of 2

Set of 2

Sale price$6.99 Regular price$9.99
Save 30%Fanciful Nature Gift & Creative Paper BookFanciful Nature Gift & Creative Paper Book
Fanciful Nature Gift & Creative Paper Book Sale price$13.99 Regular price$19.99
Le Brie Triple Cream Embroidery KitLe Brie Triple Cream Embroidery Kit
Le Brie Triple Cream Embroidery Kit Sale price$29.99
Roses Embroidered JournalRoses Embroidered Journal
Roses Embroidered Journal Sale price$32.00
Floral Ceramic Trinket Dish Making KitFloral Ceramic Trinket Dish Making Kit
Floral Ceramic Trinket Dish Making Kit Sale price$25.50
Sold outSave 30%Lavender Floral DiffuserLavender Floral Diffuser
Lavender Floral Diffuser Sale price$20.30 Regular price$29.00
Sold outSave 12%Mineralogy 1,000 piece puzzleMineralogy 1,000 piece puzzle
Mineralogy 1,000 piece puzzle Sale price$21.94 Regular price$24.95
Crocodile Dentist by Robert Fuhrer and Sano TakeshiCrocodile Dentist by Robert Fuhrer and Sano Takeshi
Crocodile Dentist by Robert Fuhrer and Sano Takeshi Sale price$17.99
Striped Bow SlippersStriped Bow Slippers
Striped Bow Slippers Sale price$26.99
(5.0)
Sold outCoffee Break Candle
Coffee Break Candle Sale price$26.50
Petal Nouveau Market Tote BagPetal Nouveau Market Tote Bag
Petal Nouveau Market Tote Bag Sale price$22.99
Sold outFairy UnicornoFairy Unicorno
Fairy Unicorno Sale price$14.00
Sold outPickleball Paddle OrnamentPickleball Paddle Ornament
Pickleball Paddle Ornament Sale price$19.99

Unique Gift Ideas

Shop our specially curated selection of unique gifts for all ages and occasions. We’ve got gifts for every holiday and season including birthdays, Christmas, Hanukkah, Easter, Father’s Day, Mother’s Day, and more. Whether you’re searching for a gift for grandma, your sister, or coworkers, our gift ideas will inspire giving in a fun and personal way! Browse through a variety of themed gifts including calendars and planners, journals and candles, and drinkware to find the perfect gift for your teen, husband, or wine loving friend. Explore our selection of trending books, décor, useful gadgets, adult games and puzzles, and toys for kids.

Discover uncommon gifts at Paper Source. Whether you’re looking for gift ideas for your girlfriend, parents, or your teacher, we have plenty of wonderful gifts under $20 and $30. From wine glasses and slippers that mom would love to coffee mugs and socks for dad, find gifts for everyone on your shopping list. Check out our personalized gift guide for more gift ideas!