Save up to 40% on Personalized Stationery →
20% Off 5 or more Greeting Cards →
Hundreds of Gifts, Crafts & more on sale! Shop Paper Cuts →
Free Standard Shipping on orders $60+ →
10% Off when you sign up for SMS alerts →
  • Go to slide 1
  • Go to slide 2
  • Go to slide 3
  • Go to slide 4
  • Go to slide 5
Login My Favorites

Cart

Your cart is empty

Payton's Favorites

Follow Payton on Instagram @presentsbypayton

Sort by

49 Results

Filters
Holly Ricrac Textured Wrapping PaperHolly Ricrac Textured Wrapping Paper
Holly Ricrac Textured Wrapping PaperPaper Source Sale price$12.50
Winter Botanical Foil Wrapping PaperWinter Botanical Foil Wrapping Paper
Winter Botanical Foil Wrapping PaperPaper Source Sale price$12.50
Sold outConfetti Candy Cane CandleConfetti Candy Cane Candle
Confetti Candy Cane Candle Sale price$29.99
Sold outPet Impression Ornament KitPet Impression Ornament Kit
Pet Impression Ornament Kit Sale price$16.50
Save 30%Santa's Evidence KitSanta's Evidence Kit
Santa's Evidence Kit Sale price$9.09 Regular price$12.99
Sold outRed and Green Dual Stone Paper Roll Wraps
Red and Green Dual Stone Paper Roll WrapsPaper Source Sale price$18.50
Red/Green Tinsel-Edged Bows S/2
Red/Green Tinsel-Edged Bows S/2 Sale price$10.50
Wired Ribbon Red/Green/Gold Check 2.5" 10 YD
Wired Ribbon Red/Green/Gold Check 2.5" 10 YDPaper Source Sale price$12.50
Gold and Red Bow Gift Tags
Gold and Red Bow Gift TagsPaper Source

Set of 10

Sale price$10.50
Moody Jeweltones Colorscope Tissue S/16
Moody Jeweltones Colorscope Tissue S/16 Sale price$10.50
Holiday Classic Icons Adhesive TagsHoliday Classic Icons Adhesive Tags
Holiday Classic Icons Adhesive TagsPaper Source Sale price$13.50
Frasier Fir Tissue Paper
Frasier Fir Tissue Paper Sale price$16.00
Sold outCandy Cane Red Foil Stone Wrapping PaperCandy Cane Red Foil Stone Wrapping Paper
Candy Cane Red Foil Stone Wrapping PaperPaper Source Sale price$10.50
Wired Red Stripe Ribbon 1.5" 10 YD
Wired Red Stripe Ribbon 1.5" 10 YDPaper Source Sale price$12.50
Rifle Paper Co. Hanukkah Floral Wrapping PaperRifle Paper Co. Hanukkah Floral Wrapping Paper
Rifle Paper Co. Hanukkah Floral Wrapping PaperRifle Paper Co. Sale price$12.50
Metallic Fringe Ribbon 1/2" 10 YD
Metallic Fringe Ribbon 1/2" 10 YDPaper Source Sale price$14.50
Sold outSquishmas 2025 NeeDoh Advent CalendarSquishmas 2025 NeeDoh Advent Calendar
Squishmas 2025 NeeDoh Advent Calendar Sale price$29.99
Swivel Cheese Board SetSwivel Cheese Board Set
Swivel Cheese Board SetPaper Source Sale price$42.99
Sold outSnowflake Beaded CoastersSnowflake Beaded Coasters
Snowflake Beaded CoastersPaper Source

Set of 4

Sale price$19.99
Candle Warming LampCandle Warming Lamp
Candle Warming LampPaper Source Sale price$34.99
Sold outInhaler Gift Set - PS ExclusiveInhaler Gift Set - PS Exclusive
Inhaler Gift Set - PS Exclusive Sale price$34.99
Rose Quartz Stone Eye MaskRose Quartz Stone Eye Mask
Rose Quartz Stone Eye MaskPaper Source Sale price$34.00
Cooling Head CapCooling Head Cap
Cooling Head CapPaper Source Sale price$19.99
Save 30%Exfoliating KitExfoliating Kit
Exfoliating KitPaper Source Sale price$16.80 Regular price$24.00
Sold outFrench Lavender SpongeFrench Lavender Sponge
French Lavender Sponge Sale price$16.00
Stitch Your Travels Passport CoverStitch Your Travels Passport Cover
Stitch Your Travels Passport Cover Sale price$29.99
Silent Night, Starry Night 1000 piece PuzzleSilent Night, Starry Night 1000 piece Puzzle
Silent Night, Starry Night 1000 piece Puzzle Sale price$22.95
Festive Holiday Car Stained Glass KitFestive Holiday Car Stained Glass Kit
Festive Holiday Car Stained Glass Kit Sale price$15.50
Tree and Present Surprise Balls S/4Tree and Present Surprise Balls S/4
Tree and Present Surprise Balls S/4Paper Source

Set of 4

Sale price$18.50
Golf Tool
Golf Tool Sale price$25.00
Things To Do With Dad CouponsThings To Do With Dad Coupons
Things To Do With Dad Coupons Sale price$6.99
Save 30%Be Present Gel Phone ClingsBe Present Gel Phone Clings
Be Present Gel Phone Clings

Set of 4

Sale price$9.09 Regular price$12.99
Work From Anywhere KitWork From Anywhere Kit
Work From Anywhere Kit Sale price$40.00
Booze & Vinyl: A Spirited Guide to Great Music and Mixed DrinksBooze & Vinyl: A Spirited Guide to Great Music and Mixed Drinks
Booze & Vinyl: A Spirited Guide to Great Music and Mixed Drinks Sale price$27.00
Holiday Plaid Small Shirt Gift Box
Holiday Plaid Small Shirt Gift BoxPaper Source Sale price$14.50
Ornaments Wrapping PaperOrnaments Wrapping Paper
Ornaments Wrapping PaperPaper Source Sale price$12.50
Ornament Hang TagsOrnament Hang Tags
Ornament Hang TagsPaper Source Sale price$10.50
MAGNA-TILES microMAGS Travel Set, 26-Piece Magnetic Construction Set, The ORIGINAL Magnetic Building BrandMAGNA-TILES microMAGS Travel Set, 26-Piece Magnetic Construction Set, The ORIGINAL Magnetic Building Brand
MAGNA-TILES microMAGS Travel Set, 26-Piece Magnetic Construction Set, The ORIGINAL Magnetic Building Brand Sale price$19.99
Into The Wild - Reusable silicone A3 mat: A to Z AnimalsInto The Wild - Reusable silicone A3 mat: A to Z Animals
Into The Wild - Reusable silicone A3 mat: A to Z Animals Sale price$24.99
Sold outElf Breakfast KidDough Play KitElf Breakfast KidDough Play Kit
Elf Breakfast KidDough Play Kit Sale price$22.99
LEGO Iconic Christmas Table Decoration 40743LEGO Iconic Christmas Table Decoration 40743
LEGO Iconic Christmas Table Decoration 40743 Sale price$39.99
The Calm Caterpillar Calmee KitThe Calm Caterpillar Calmee Kit
The Calm Caterpillar Calmee Kit Sale price$29.99
Design a Dreidel KitDesign a Dreidel Kit
Design a Dreidel Kit Sale price$12.99
Acrylic Dreidel Set - Blue & WhiteAcrylic Dreidel Set - Blue & White
Acrylic Dreidel Set - Blue & White Sale price$32.99
Foldable Watercolor Set of 56
Foldable Watercolor Set of 56 Sale price$45.00
Snow KidSnow Kid
Snow Kid Sale price$19.99
Garden in a Bag Grow Kit
Garden in a Bag Grow Kit Sale price$14.99
Ooze Labs: Instant Snow StationOoze Labs: Instant Snow Station
Ooze Labs: Instant Snow Station Sale price$29.99