Up to 40% Off Personalized Stationery →
30% Off Paperless Post Holiday Cards →
Free Standard Shipping $60+ →
  • Go to slide 1
  • Go to slide 2
  • Go to slide 3
Login My Favorites

Cart

Your cart is empty

Stocking Stuffers

Find cute, funny & unique stocking stuffers and small gifts for the holidays! From festive socks to quirky surprises and useful finds, surprise them with a little something they’ll love.

Wrap & Accessories Wrap & Accessories
Gifts Gifts
Crafts Crafts
Party Party
Stocking Stuffers Stocking Stuffers
Greeting Cards Greeting Cards
Boxed Card Sets Boxed Card Sets
Photo Cards Photo Cards

Sort by

191 Results

Leuchtturm Pen loop, lilacLeuchtturm Pen loop, lilac
Leuchtturm Pen loop, lilacLeuchtturm Sale price$5.95
Midori Embroidery Bookmark Clip CatMidori Embroidery Bookmark Clip Cat
Midori Embroidery Bookmark Clip Cat Sale price$10.99
Midori Embroidery Bookmark Clip BirdMidori Embroidery Bookmark Clip Bird
Midori Embroidery Bookmark Clip Bird Sale price$10.99
Leicester Wallpaper Art Tumbler
Leicester Wallpaper Art Tumbler Sale price$32.99
Manuscript Modern Beginner's Calligraphy SetManuscript Modern Beginner's Calligraphy Set
Manuscript Modern Beginner's Calligraphy Set Sale price$12.50
Lobster OrnamentLobster Ornament
Lobster Ornament Sale price$16.99
Pac-Man Keyring Arcade GamePac-Man Keyring Arcade Game
Pac-Man Keyring Arcade Game Sale price$17.99
Tiny Sports!Tiny Sports!
Tiny Sports! Sale price$23.99
Holiday Hair Clips, Set of 3Holiday Hair Clips, Set of 3
Holiday Hair Clips, Set of 3Paper Source

Set of 3

Sale price$12.99
Bro Mask
Bro Mask Sale price$8.00
Classic SlinkyClassic Slinky
Classic Slinky Sale price$4.99
Emergency Dad Jokes
Emergency Dad Jokes Sale price$12.00
The Mini Bonsai Kit
The Mini Bonsai Kit Sale price$11.95
You Are a Badass Talking Button: Five Nuggets of In-Your-Face InspirationYou Are a Badass Talking Button: Five Nuggets of In-Your-Face Inspiration
You Are a Badass Talking Button: Five Nuggets of In-Your-Face Inspiration Sale price$13.95
Teeny-Tiny Turntable: Includes 3 Mini-LPs to Play!
Teeny-Tiny Turntable: Includes 3 Mini-LPs to Play! Sale price$15.95
Wacky Waving Inflatable Tube Guy: (The Original)Wacky Waving Inflatable Tube Guy: (The Original)
Wacky Waving Inflatable Tube Guy: (The Original) Sale price$14.95
Magic Crystal Ball: See the Future!Magic Crystal Ball: See the Future!
Magic Crystal Ball: See the Future! Sale price$14.95
The Hanukkah Llama: Plays Music!
The Hanukkah Llama: Plays Music! Sale price$12.95
Punching Cheeky Santa PenPunching Cheeky Santa Pen
Punching Cheeky Santa Pen Sale price$6.00
Vintage Christmas StickersVintage Christmas Stickers
Vintage Christmas Stickers Sale price$15.50
Really Tiny Book Light - Lilac
Really Tiny Book Light - Lilac Sale price$9.99
Martini Hair ClipMartini Hair Clip
Martini Hair ClipPaper Source Sale price$13.99
PS Collection Sporty Click Ballpoint S/2PS Collection Sporty Click Ballpoint S/2
PS Collection Sporty Click Ballpoint S/2 Sale price$9.99
Miffy Room Blind BoxMiffy Room Blind Box
Miffy Room Blind Box Sale price$14.00
LEGO Creator Santa's Sleigh Ride 30670LEGO Creator Santa's Sleigh Ride 30670
LEGO Creator Santa's Sleigh Ride 30670 Sale price$4.99
Christmas Baking SetChristmas Baking Set
Christmas Baking Set Sale price$19.50
Meow Kitty 5" Palm PalsMeow Kitty 5" Palm Pals
Meow Kitty 5" Palm Pals Sale price$9.99
Vinyl Record Bottle OpenerVinyl Record Bottle Opener
Vinyl Record Bottle Opener Sale price$12.99
Rewined Espresso Martini Candle 3.5 oz
Rewined Espresso Martini Candle 3.5 oz Sale price$17.99
Smoko Miffy Goes Pastel Blind Box FigureSmoko Miffy Goes Pastel Blind Box Figure
Smoko Miffy Goes Pastel Blind Box Figure Sale price$15.00
Floral Hair ClipFloral Hair Clip
Floral Hair Clip Sale price$12.99
Pin Badge Enamel - Moomin - Moomin Mama
Pin Badge Enamel - Moomin - Moomin Mama Sale price$5.99
Mixer Kitchen TimerMixer Kitchen Timer
Mixer Kitchen TimerPaper Source Sale price$14.99
Googly & Bright Sticker BookGoogly & Bright Sticker Book
Googly & Bright Sticker Book Sale price$9.99
Seasonal Trio of SoapsSeasonal Trio of Soaps
Seasonal Trio of Soaps Sale price$19.99
Parmesan Glass Ornament
Parmesan Glass Ornament Sale price$24.99
Pierre w/ Le Petite Pierre - B&N ExclusivePierre w/ Le Petite Pierre - B&N Exclusive
Pierre w/ Le Petite Pierre - B&N Exclusive Sale price$34.99
Bow Mirror Trinket Dish
Bow Mirror Trinket Dish Sale price$19.99
Rug MousepadRug Mousepad
Rug Mousepad Sale price$28.00
Chicken Nuggets Glass Ornament
Chicken Nuggets Glass Ornament Sale price$24.99
Wake Me When I'm Rich Glass Ornament
Wake Me When I'm Rich Glass Ornament Sale price$19.99
What A Time To Be Alive Magnet
What A Time To Be Alive Magnet Sale price$4.99
CHRISTMAS DAD JOKESCHRISTMAS DAD JOKES
CHRISTMAS DAD JOKES Sale price$9.99
The Elf on the Shelf and Elf Pets MinisThe Elf on the Shelf and Elf Pets Minis
The Elf on the Shelf and Elf Pets Minis Sale price$6.99
Super Soft Sock -Ice GraySuper Soft Sock -Ice Gray
Super Soft Sock -Ice Gray Sale price$16.99
Light Up Wreath Wine StopperLight Up Wreath Wine Stopper
Light Up Wreath Wine StopperPaper Source Sale price$19.99
Towel Scrunchies -Set of 2Towel Scrunchies -Set of 2
Towel Scrunchies -Set of 2Paper Source Sale price$19.99
Ornament Hang TagsOrnament Hang Tags
Ornament Hang TagsPaper Source Sale price$10.50

BEST STOCKING STUFFERS 2026

Hang your stockings by the chimney with care, but don’t forget to fill them first with the best stocking stuffers from Paper Source! We have an amazing selection of cute, fun and quirky stocking stuffers to wow your spouses, children and colleagues this holiday season. From candy to toys to socks, our collection has the perfect little gifts for everyone on your list!

Stocking Stuffer Ideas for Everyone on Your List

Explore stocking stuffer ideas from Paper Source and find the best stocking stuffers for men and women. Whether you are looking for stocking stuffers for your wife, husband, kids, friends or coworkers, these gifts are the perfect little packages for slipping into stockings this holiday season.

Unique Stocking Stuffers for Adults & Kids

Shop self-care essentials such as face masks, manicure sets, essential oils and candles. Find cute jewelry and hair accessories such as bracelets, hairclips and fingernail stickers. Browse desk essentials such as desk calendars, journals, pen sets and more. Look through travel basics such as keychains, luggage tags, tech accessories and tote bags. Find stocking stuffers for kids such as cards, games and toys. We even have a wide selection of quirky stocking stuffers, sure to make your friends and family laugh this holiday season. Still not sure what to get? Look through our Holiday Gift Guide or purchase a Paper Source Gift Card!

The Best Stocking Stuffers for your Holiday Gift Exchange

Find the perfect stocking stuffers for your Holiday Gift Exchange, White Elephant or Secret Santa at Paper Source! Stocking stuffers are the perfect small gift for your holiday exchange and are great gifted on their own! You’ll have everyone trying to steal your gift! Put your stocking stuffer in a Holiday Treat Bags for an extra festive touch!

FAQ About Stocking Stuffers 2026

If you are searching for some good stocking fillers, here are a few great ideas:

  • Candy
  • Gift Cards
  • Small Games & Toys
  • Candles & Wellness Gifts
  • Socks, Scarves, & Gloves
  • 2027 Calendars, Planners and Journals
  • Books
  • Novelty mugs, Magnets & Keychains
  • Art Supplies

What traditionally goes in a stocking?

Traditionally stockings are filled with fruit, candy and toys or other small gifts.

How many gifts should be in a stocking?

While there is no set number as to the number of gifts that should go in your stocking, most stockings are filled with 3-5 small stocking stuffers.

Our Top Picks for Stocking Stuffers 2026

Wacky Waving Inflatable Tube Elf

MAGNA-TILES microMAGS Travel Set

Itty Bitty Duffle-Beauty Sage

Garden Party Gel Pens

Legami Scented Eraser - xoxo - Unicorn

Bookmark Paper - Moomin Gardening - Picnic Reading

You may also be interested in…

Kids Toys & Plush

Candles & Diffusers

Quirky Gifts