Free Standard Shipping $60+ →
Login My Favorites

Cart

Your cart is empty

Magical Mail

Tag us on Instagram with @papersource #psmagicalmail

Sort by

89 Results

Grabie Sealed For Holiday Wax Seal KitGrabie Sealed For Holiday Wax Seal Kit
Grabie Sealed For Holiday Wax Seal Kit Sale price$19.99
Whimsical Holiday Washi Tapes S/8
Whimsical Holiday Washi Tapes S/8 Sale price$15.50
Winter Critter Shaker StickersWinter Critter Shaker Stickers
Winter Critter Shaker Stickers Sale price$7.50
Chenille Tree StickersChenille Tree Stickers
Chenille Tree Stickers Sale price$7.50
Velvet Bow Stickers
Velvet Bow Stickers Sale price$7.50
Traditional Christmas Puffy StickersTraditional Christmas Puffy Stickers
Traditional Christmas Puffy Stickers Sale price$7.50
Snowman Shaker StickersSnowman Shaker Stickers
Snowman Shaker Stickers Sale price$7.50
Sweet Treats Puffy StickersSweet Treats Puffy Stickers
Sweet Treats Puffy Stickers Sale price$7.50
Velvet Bow Gift Embellishments
Velvet Bow Gift Embellishments Sale price$7.50
Cut Up This Book: Christmas Collage KitCut Up This Book: Christmas Collage Kit
Cut Up This Book: Christmas Collage Kit Sale price$19.99
Feeling Festive Washi S/8Feeling Festive Washi S/8
Feeling Festive Washi S/8 Sale price$15.50
Envelope Liner Template KitEnvelope Liner Template Kit
Envelope Liner Template Kit

Set of 7

Sale price$14.00
Festive Lights StickersFestive Lights Stickers
Festive Lights Stickers Sale price$7.00
Tree Snowglobe Shaker StickersTree Snowglobe Shaker Stickers
Tree Snowglobe Shaker Stickers Sale price$7.00
Christmas Characters Shaker Sticker Sheet
Christmas Characters Shaker Sticker Sheet Sale price$7.00
2026 Hanukkah Stickers2026 Hanukkah Stickers
2026 Hanukkah Stickers Sale price$7.50
Winter Critters Stickers
Winter Critters Stickers Sale price$7.00
3D Wreaths Sticker Sheet3D Wreaths Sticker Sheet
3D Wreaths Sticker Sheet Sale price$7.00
Holiday Characters Stickers
Holiday Characters Stickers Sale price$7.00
Holiday Cats Shaker Sticker SheetHoliday Cats Shaker Sticker Sheet
Holiday Cats Shaker Sticker Sheet Sale price$7.50
3D Peppermint Candy Sticker Sheet3D Peppermint Candy Sticker Sheet
3D Peppermint Candy Sticker Sheet Sale price$7.00
Holiday Dogs Sticker SheetHoliday Dogs Sticker Sheet
Holiday Dogs Sticker Sheet Sale price$7.00
Velvet Bows Sticker SheetVelvet Bows Sticker Sheet
Velvet Bows Sticker Sheet Sale price$7.00
Very Merry Shaker Sticker SheetVery Merry Shaker Sticker Sheet
Very Merry Shaker Sticker Sheet Sale price$7.00
Jolly Snowmen Puffy Sticker SheetJolly Snowmen Puffy Sticker Sheet
Jolly Snowmen Puffy Sticker Sheet Sale price$7.00
Hanukkah Icons Puffy StickersHanukkah Icons Puffy Stickers
Hanukkah Icons Puffy Stickers Sale price$7.00
Hanukkah Icon StickersHanukkah Icon Stickers
Hanukkah Icon Stickers Sale price$7.00
Berry Wreath Circle Labels
Berry Wreath Circle LabelsPaper Source Sale price$0.35 Each
Holiday Icons Envelope Seal
Holiday Icons Envelope SealPaper Source Sale price$0.35 Each
Personalized Sticker - Upload Your OwnCircle label with custom artwork that reads, Made by Mandy, used on an envelope as a seal.
Personalized Sticker - Upload Your OwnPaper Source Sale price$0.35 Each
Vintage Garland Tree Holiday Return Address Label
Vintage Garland Tree Holiday Return Address LabelPaper Source Sale price$0.35 Each
Mod Bevel Border Holiday Return Address Label
Mod Bevel Border Holiday Return Address LabelPaper Source Sale price$0.35 Each
Fun Holiday Washi Tape S/8Fun Holiday Washi Tape S/8
Fun Holiday Washi Tape S/8

Set of 8

Sale price$15.50
Holiday Wax Seal KitHoliday Wax Seal Kit
Holiday Wax Seal Kit Sale price$32.99
Gold Sealing Wax
Gold Sealing Wax Sale price$8.50
Custom Stamp Gift SetCustom Stamp Gift Set
Custom Stamp Gift Set

Staff Favorite!

Paper Source Sale price$39.95
Handmade By Custom StampStep-by-step video detailing how to replace the custom stamp plate.
Handmade By Custom StampPaper Source Sale price$29.95
Custom Embosser Gift SetCustom Embosser Gift Set
Custom Embosser Gift SetPaper Source Sale price$60.00
Memory Tape Runner Permanent XL
Memory Tape Runner Permanent XL Sale price$6.50
Foam Squares Combo Pack
Foam Squares Combo Pack

Set of 440

Sale price$5.50
PVA Glue 4oz.
PVA Glue 4oz. Sale price$8.50
Xyron 150 Create A StickerXyron 150 Create A Sticker
Xyron 150 Create A Sticker Sale price$17.50
DIY Shop Craft Scissors 8"DIY Shop Craft Scissors 8"
DIY Shop Craft Scissors 8" Sale price$16.50
Grayscale Dual Brush PensGrayscale Dual Brush Pens
Grayscale Dual Brush Pens

Set of 10

Sale price$32.50
Very Berry Dual Brush Pens
Very Berry Dual Brush Pens

Set of 6

Sale price$19.50
POSCA - 5M Size- Dark Color Set
POSCA - 5M Size- Dark Color Set Sale price$28.99
POSCA 3M Gold Fine Tip MarkerPOSCA 3M Gold Fine Tip Marker
POSCA 3M Gold Fine Tip Marker Sale price$4.50
Envelope Addressing Guides
Envelope Addressing Guides Sale price$10.99