Save up to 40% on Personalized Stationery →
20% Off 5 or more Greeting Cards →
Hundreds of Gifts, Crafts & more on sale! Shop Paper Cuts →
Free Standard Shipping on orders $60+ →
10% Off when you sign up for SMS alerts →
  • Go to slide 1
  • Go to slide 2
  • Go to slide 3
  • Go to slide 4
  • Go to slide 5
Login My Favorites

Cart

Your cart is empty

Magical Mail

Tag us on Instagram with @papersource #psmagicalmail

Sort by

91 Results

Filters
Sold outSave 30%A7 Vellum Envelopes
A7 Vellum Envelopes

Set of 10

Sale price$4.55 Regular price$6.50
Night A7 Envelopes
Night A7 Envelopes

Set of 10

Sale price$7.00
Night A2 Scallop Note Cards
Night A2 Scallop Note Cards

Set of 20

Sale price$10.00
Assorted Festive Hanukkah Star Shaped Cards
Assorted Festive Hanukkah Star Shaped Cards

Set of 20

Sale price$7.00
Pure White 4 Bar Mitten Shaped Cards
Pure White 4 Bar Mitten Shaped Cards

Set of 20

Sale price$8.00
Pure White Ornament Shaped Cards
Pure White Ornament Shaped Cards

Set of 20

Sale price$8.00
5.5" Stardream Antique Gold Circle Cards
5.5" Stardream Antique Gold Circle Cards

Set of 20

Sale price$10.00
Scallop 4 Bar Red Oval Cards
Scallop 4 Bar Red Oval Cards

Set of 20

Sale price$8.50
Red Ornament Shaped Cards
Red Ornament Shaped Cards

Set of 20

Sale price$8.00
Red 4 Bar Mitten Shapes
Red 4 Bar Mitten Shapes

Set of 20

Sale price$9.50
Assorted A7 Holiday Trees Shaped Cards
Assorted A7 Holiday Trees Shaped Cards

Set of 20

Sale price$8.00
Save 15%Cypress A7 Folded Cards
Cypress A7 Folded Cards

Retiring Soon

Set of 20

Sale price$10.20 Regular price$12.00
Save 15%Cypress Card Stock 8.5" x 11"
Cypress Card Stock 8.5" x 11"

Retiring Soon

Set of 10

Sale price$7.22 Regular price$8.50
Paper Bag Card Stock 8.5" x 11"
Paper Bag Card Stock 8.5" x 11"

Set of 10

Sale price$8.50
Red 8.5" x 11" Card Stock
Red 8.5" x 11" Card Stock

Set of 10

Sale price$8.50
Antique Gold Card Stock 8.5" x 11"
Antique Gold Card Stock 8.5" x 11"

Set of 10

Sale price$9.50
Luxe White Card Stock 8.5" x 11"
Luxe White Card Stock 8.5" x 11"

Set of 10

Sale price$10.50
30# Inkjet Vellum Paper 8.5" x 11" Bulk Pack
30# Inkjet Vellum Paper 8.5" x 11" Bulk Pack

Set of 10

Sale price$24.95
Christmas Trees On Taxi Handmade Paper
Christmas Trees On Taxi Handmade Paper Sale price$6.50
Sold outHoliday Glitter Leaves Handmade PaperHoliday Glitter Leaves Handmade Paper
Holiday Glitter Leaves Handmade Paper Sale price$6.50
Marigold Glitz Scarlet Handmade PaperMarigold Glitz Scarlet Handmade Paper
Marigold Glitz Scarlet Handmade Paper Sale price$7.50
Green and Gold Foil Plaid Handmade Paper
Green and Gold Foil Plaid Handmade Paper Sale price$6.50
Christmas Trees on White Handmade Paper
Christmas Trees on White Handmade Paper Sale price$6.50
Red & Green Pom Pom Handmade PaperRed & Green Pom Pom Handmade Paper
Red & Green Pom Pom Handmade Paper Sale price$9.50
PAPER SOURCE 14PC QUILLING KITPAPER SOURCE 14PC QUILLING KIT
PAPER SOURCE 14PC QUILLING KIT Sale price$26.99
Cranberry Pigment Inkpad
Cranberry Pigment Inkpad Sale price$6.95
Greenery Pinecone Stamp
Greenery Pinecone Stamp Sale price$8.95
Graphical Wreath Wood Block Stamp
Graphical Wreath Wood Block Stamp Sale price$11.50
Tinsel Tape Fred and Friends
Tinsel Tape Fred and Friends Sale price$7.99
Happy Holidays Washi Tape
Happy Holidays Washi Tape

Set of 3

Sale price$10.00
Plaid and Poinsettia Washi Tape S/3
Plaid and Poinsettia Washi Tape S/3

Set of 3

Sale price$10.00
Sold outSanta's Workshop Sticker BookSanta's Workshop Sticker Book
Santa's Workshop Sticker Book Sale price$14.00
Sold outSnowglobe Sticker Book
Snowglobe Sticker Book Sale price$14.00
Sold outWinter House Sticker Book
Winter House Sticker Book Sale price$13.00
Winter Snowmen StickersWinter Snowmen Stickers
Winter Snowmen Stickers Sale price$7.00
Sold outUgly Sweater StickersUgly Sweater Stickers
Ugly Sweater Stickers Sale price$7.00
Sold outVelvet Bow Gift Embellishments
Velvet Bow Gift Embellishments Sale price$7.50
Sold outSanta Reindeer StickersSanta Reindeer Stickers
Santa Reindeer Stickers Sale price$7.00
Festive Lights StickersFestive Lights Stickers
Festive Lights Stickers Sale price$7.00
Stitched Trees StickersStitched Trees Stickers
Stitched Trees Stickers Sale price$7.50
Tree Snowglobe Shaker StickersTree Snowglobe Shaker Stickers
Tree Snowglobe Shaker Stickers Sale price$7.00
Christmas Characters Shaker Sticker Sheet
Christmas Characters Shaker Sticker Sheet Sale price$7.00
Sold outRetro Ornament Christmas StickersRetro Ornament Christmas Stickers
Retro Ornament Christmas Stickers Sale price$6.95