Valentine Clearance 50% Off >   Holiday Clearance 75% Off >

Personalized Shop · Weddings · New Arrivals

Flash Sale! 50% Off Select Gifts  · while supplies last ·

+ $5 Flat Rate Shipping · non-custom orders · ends february 23

Valentine's Day Crafts

XOXO Paper Pad

XOXO Paper Pad
next
A Paper Source exclusive from My Mind's Eye, this awesome 6" x 6" decorative paper ... Read More
699464206486
$7.95 $3.98

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Heart Balloons

Set of 10
Heart Balloons
previous / next
10 festive heart-shaped balloons for Valentine's decorating and celebrating! Comes with 5 red and 5 ... Read More
520104
$3.95 $1.98

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

XOXO Heart Assorted Washi Tape

Set of 5
XOXO Heart Assorted Washi Tape
previous / next
An exclusive set of tapes from My Mind's Eye, these cute washi's can be used ... Read More
699464206440
$11.95 $5.98

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Black Fading Heart Washi Tape

Black Fading Heart Washi Tape
previous / next
Black hearts adorn delicate ivory paper tape. Washi tape can be torn by hand and ... Read More
4971910211854
$4.95 $2.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Valentines Day Doillies

Pack of 24
Valentines Day Doillies
previous / next
These elegant heart doilies look lovely as a gift topper or strung on baker's twine ... Read More
900106
$6.95 $3.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Meri Meri Heart Colorful Stickers

Set of 10
Meri Meri Heart Colorful Stickers
previous / next
These colorful stickers from Meri Meri are a great way to seal treat bags, envelopes, ... Read More
900556
$7.95 $3.98

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Love Icon Rubber Stamp Set

Set of 12
Love Icon Rubber Stamp Set
previous / next
A Paper Source exclusive from Hero Arts, these cute Valentine's icons are a sweet addition ... Read More
900555
$17.95 $8.98

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Eyes Wink Rubber Stamp

Eyes Wink Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Great for decorating Valentine's cards, envelopes, treat bags, and tags. Perfectly sized to DIY your ... Read More
900554
$9.95 $4.98

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

White Heart Stickers

White Heart Stickers
previous / next
Stickers are perfect for paper crafts and scrapbooking projects. These white heart stickers feature intricate ... Read More
900093
$6.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Scratch-Off Heart Stickers

Set of 18
Scratch-Off Heart Stickers
previous / next
Scratch off these stickers to reveal fun sentiments underneath! A great way to add some ... Read More
718813784894
$4.95 $2.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

XOXO Holographic Stickers

Set of 72
XOXO Holographic Stickers
previous / next
Holographic foil makes these fun X's and O's pop! Use to create handmade cards, adorn ... Read More
718813784887
$4.95 $2.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Ahoy Me Hearties Pirate Valentine Cards

Ahoy Me Hearties Pirate Valentine Cards
previous / next
Includes 28 (4 different styles) children's valentine cards plus 1 for the teacher, with silver ... Read More
807265
$19.95 $9.98

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Conversation Heart Faces Stickers

Set of 30
Conversation Heart Faces Stickers
previous / next
Our fun Paper Source designed conversation hearts come to life with this awesome sticker pack. ... Read More
718813784856
$4.95 $2.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Tic Tac Toe Valentines Set

Tic Tac Toe Valentines Set
previous / next
Perfect for the classroom! Includes 28 perforated game cards with 28 white envelopes and a ... Read More
807264
$14.95 $7.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Happy Valentine's Day Banner Stickers

Set of 8
Happy Valentine's Day Banner Stickers
previous / next
These dimensional banner stickers are a quick and festive way to add a personal touch ... Read More
718813784818
$4.95 $2.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Cookies & Cream Valentines Set

Cookies & Cream Valentines Set
previous / next
Perfect for the classroom! Includes 28 chocolate-scented Valentine cards die-cut in ice cream and cookie ... Read More
807267
$14.95 $7.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Fuchsia Foil Heart Washi Tape

Fuchsia Foil Heart Washi Tape
previous / next
This washi tape will make you fall in love with crafting! Foil hearts make this ... Read More
900560
$4.95 $2.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Gold Foil Heart Washi Tape

Gold Foil Heart Washi Tape
previous / next
This washi tape will make you fall in love with crafting! Foil hearts make this ... Read More
900559
$4.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Fuchsia Glitter Heart Stickers

Pack of 84
Fuchsia Glitter Heart Stickers
previous / next
Spark some love on all your projects with these fuchsia glitter heart stickers. A sweet ... Read More
900104
$4.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Silver Glitter Heart Clips

Set of 12
Silver Glitter Heart Clips
previous / next
These glitter heart clips are the perfect addition to our seasonal treat bags. Use them ... Read More
900557
$5.95 $2.98

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Gem Heart Repeat Stickers

Pack of 36
Gem Heart Repeat Stickers
previous / next
These tiny glitter heart stickers are bejeweled with colorful gem centers. The red, pink and ... Read More
449668
$4.95 $2.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Dino-mite Valentine Card Kit

Pack of 32
Dino-mite Valentine Card Kit
previous / next
A t-riffic Valentine is within arm's reach with these fierce friends! The smiles on these ... Read More
10000021
$19.95 $6.00

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Trim and Score Board

Trim and Score Board
previous / next
Now you can trim and score with one convenient tool! This package contains one unit ... Read More
10000249
$29.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Happy Valentine's Day Brush Script Rubber Stamp

Happy Valentine's Day Brush Script Rubber Stamp
previous / next
This spunky stamp features one of our favorite fonts - a quirky brush script- wishing ... Read More
871792
$6.95 $3.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Small Rose Outline Rubber Stamp

Small Rose Outline Rubber Stamp
previous / next
Our small rose outline rubber stamp will add perennial charm to your paper creations. Find ... Read More
871541
$5.95

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Love Notes Glitter & Glue Set

Set of 6
Love Notes Glitter & Glue Set
previous / next
Add sparkle to your love notes this Valentine's Day with six different glitters. Colors: Rose ... Read More
447256
$12.95 $6.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.

Red Heart Cards with Fuchsia Envelopes

Set of 10
Red Heart Cards with Fuchsia Envelopes
previous
Scribble sweet nothings on this adorable stationery. The die-cut heart cards set the perfect tone ... Read More
3434470204
$8.95 $4.48

Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.

Please notify me when this product is back in stock.
Arrow pointing to top