25-50% Off Custom Stamps >

Photo Cards · Personalized Gifts · Holiday Shop

Free Standard Shipping on Orders $50+    ends January 25 · details >

Stocking Stuffers

NEST Sugar Cookie Votive Candle

NEST Sugar Cookie Votive Candle
next
This sweet tooth loving candle mixes the warm flavors of Tahitian vanilla bean and bourbon-infused ... Read More
10002947
$16.95 $10.17

Merry and Beer Glass

Merry and Beer Glass
previous / next
Fill up this "Merry and Beer" glass with your favorite brew this holiday season. It ... Read More
10001713
$22.95 $13.77

Giant Stress Ball-Blue

Giant Stress Ball-Blue
previous / next
Giant stress ball from Play Visions. Comes in a giftable box. Bright blue color. This ... Read More
10001592
$15.95

Holiday Gummy Kabob Candy

Holiday Gummy Kabob Candy
previous / next
These yummy gummy kabobs are a holiday candy dream! Featuring fun holiday candies in all ... Read More
131001
$4.95 $2.97

Holiday Village Travel Tea Tin

Holiday Village Travel Tea Tin
previous / next
Made exclusively for Paper Source, this travel-sized Republic of Tea tin features a holiday village. ... Read More
10002282
$6.95 $4.17

Santa Punching Pen

Santa Punching Pen
previous / next
Santa sure does pack a punch! With extendable arms, this Santa punches outward with the ... Read More
520569
$3.95 $2.37

Melting Snowman Putty

Melting Snowman Putty
previous / next
Mold this white putty into a tiny snowman with hat, eyes, scarf and arms. Then ... Read More
526805
$14.95 $8.97

Fake Snowballs

Set of 6
Fake Snowballs
previous / next
Winter play is easy with these faux snowballs that won't ever melt. Specially designed to ... Read More
520568
$10.95 $6.57

Native Union Key Cable Blue

Native Union Key Cable Blue
previous / next
KEY Cable is a keychain with concealed connectors, giving you access to any USB power ... Read More
10002856
$29.99

Native Union Belt Cable Blue

4 ft
Native Union Belt Cable Blue
previous / next
BELT Cable puts an end to untidy, tangled-up cables at the bottom of your bag. ... Read More
10002857
$24.99

Rifle Clear Tapestry iPhone Case

Rifle Clear Tapestry iPhone Case
previous / next
Rifle Paper Company iPhone case with a slim profile and vibrant finish in a Rifle ... Read More
10003281
$34.00

Peace Joy Cheer Waffle Tea Towel

Set of 2
Peace Joy Cheer Waffle Tea Towel
previous / next
A perfect gift this holiday season, these crisp, white waffle tea towels are embroidered with ... Read More
10002145
$19.95 $11.97

Sugarfina Juice Cleanse Mini

Sugarfina Juice Cleanse Mini
previous / next
In need of a pick-me-up? A shot of "green juice" baby gummy bears will do ... Read More
10002684
$3.95

Sugarfina Margarita Gummies

Sugarfina Margarita Gummies
previous / next
This crisp, clean margarita gummy is infused with Casamigos Blanco Tequila with hints of lime ... Read More
10002683
$9.95

Sugarfina Rosé Gummies

4 oz.
Sugarfina Rosé Gummies
previous / next
Can't get enough Rosé? This gummy is for you! Sugarfina's Rosé Gummies feature exclusive packaging ... Read More
521703
$9.95

Sugarfina Bourbon Bears

Sugarfina Bourbon Bears
previous / next
Sugarfina's tasty Bourbon Bears in Paper Source designed and exclusive packaging! Imported from Germany, these ... Read More
10001232
$9.95

Sugarfina Champagne Bears

Sugarfina Champagne Bears
previous / next
Infused with bubbly champagne, these sophisticated bears from Sugarfina sparkle in flavors of Brut and ... Read More
521424
$9.95

Peppermint Bark Fatty Sundays Pretzels

Peppermint Bark Fatty Sundays Pretzels
previous / next
Peppermint Pretzels: With swirly red and white peppermint candy dusted over rich dark chocolate, our ... Read More
10003219
$4.50 $2.70

Peppermint Spoons

Set of 6
Peppermint Spoons
previous / next
While stirring up your favorite hot cocoa, add a touch of peppermint with these yummy ... Read More
10000027
$9.95 $5.97

Santa Sunglasses

Santa Sunglasses
previous / next
Be glamorous at the holiday party with these chic santa sunglasses. They also make a ... Read More
512135
$7.95 $4.77

Gold Flashlight

Gold Flashlight
previous / next
This shiny gold flashlight from Wild & Wolf features a metallic finish accompanied with a ... Read More
5060121266049
$24.95

Survival Playing Cards

Survival Playing Cards
previous / next
Stay ready for anything with this deck of waterproof cards, featuring a different survival tip ... Read More
10002853
$16.95

F'lint Marble Lint Rollers Assorted

F'lint Marble Lint Rollers Assorted
previous / next
This compact, retractable roller quickly removes lint, dust and pet hair from clothing and other ... Read More
10002546
$10.95

Wood Hammer Multi-Tool

Wood Hammer Multi-Tool
previous / next
Carry 10 handy tools in the form of a beechwood and stainless steel hammer.Includes: hammer ... Read More
520452
$19.95

Silver Pure Platinum Crazy Aaron Putty

Silver Pure Platinum Crazy Aaron Putty
previous / next
Crazy Aaron's putty stretches and bounces to any shape. Putty is great for relieving stress ... Read More
10001574
$12.95

Worlds Smallest Fiddle Cube

Worlds Smallest Fiddle Cube
previous / next
An unusually addicting, high-quality desk toy designed to help you focus, this mini fiddle cube ... Read More
10002848
$7.95

Retro Arcade Handheld Machine

Retro Arcade Handheld Machine
previous / next
240 built-in nostalgic games bring back the fun of an arcade in this handheld gaming ... Read More
5060407527055
$39.95

Ridley's Magic 8 Ball

Ridley's Magic 8 Ball
previous / next
Hold the wisdom of the universe in the palm of your hand! Simply ask the ... Read More
10003102
$16.95

Pocket Bowling

Pocket Bowling
previous / next
This pocked-sized tube contains everything you need for an exciting game of ten pin bowling ... Read More
10003172
$9.95

NYT Mini Crosswords

NYT Mini Crosswords
previous / next
Only got a minute of free time? That's all you need to complete a New ... Read More
10002999
$9.99

SOS Password Book

SOS Password Book
previous / next
Keep your most important passwords all in one place. This small and compact password book ... Read More
10001295
$4.95

Squishy Ball

Squishy Ball
previous / next
The perfect gift for anyone who needs to relieve a little stress - just squeeze ... Read More
818929010327
$4.95

Finger Monsters

Finger Monsters
previous / next
These playful rubber monster puppets fit right onto your fingers. Great for kids party favors ... Read More
406999
$4.75

Dancing Reindeer Wind Up Toy

Dancing Reindeer Wind Up Toy
previous / next
Spin the reindeer and watch him dance! A fun toy for all ages. ... Read More
678643753029
$5.95 $3.57

Dinosaur Wind Up Toy

Dinosaur Wind Up Toy
previous / next
With this dinosaur wind up toy, you can make yourself a Jurassic friend! Give the ... Read More
10002826
$3.95

Flying Wish Paper

Flying Wish Paper
previous / next
Write it and light it! Send your wish off into the world with this whimsical ... Read More
520462
$11.95

4-in-1 Pen Tool

4-in-1 Pen Tool
previous / next
This 4-In-1 Pen Tool is all you need to get the job done! Go straight ... Read More
612615000971
$4.95

Chocolate Magic Milk Straws

Set of 6
Chocolate Magic Milk Straws
previous / next
Magic Milk Straws are yummy straws filled with flavor beads that transform white milk into ... Read More
497154
$3.95

Secret Message Writing Set

Secret Message Writing Set
previous / next
Keep your secret messages safe by using invisible ink pens! Everything you write will go ... Read More
444405
$9.95

Screen Cleansing Tech Wipes

Screen Cleansing Tech Wipes
previous / next
Keep your technology clean and germ free with these screen cleansing towelettes. Contains 15 pre-moistened ... Read More
742832056489
$5.95

Car Vent Phone Mount

Car Vent Phone Mount
previous / next
Go hands-free with a portable air vent phone holder with no slip grip. Expands to ... Read More
612615075740
$5.95

PopSockets Phone Grip And Stand - Aluminum Silver

PopSockets Phone Grip And Stand - Aluminum Silver
previous / next
A simple invention that will change the way you use your phone! Stick PopSocket on ... Read More
10000269
$15.95

PopSocket Phone Mount

PopSocket Phone Mount
previous / next
PopSockets offer a secure grip for texting or snapping the perfect selfie, and propping your ... Read More
10002843
$10.95

XL Braided iPhone Cord

As Seen in Architectural Digest
XL Braided iPhone Cord
previous / next
This sturdy extra long phone charger is cute and practical with a black and white ... Read More
612615080331
$19.95

PopSocket Rose Gold Jewel

PopSocket Rose Gold Jewel
previous / next
PopSockets is the ultimate accessory for your phone. This stick on device helps you get ... Read More
10002844
$16.95

PopSockets Phone Grip And Stand - Floral Blush

PopSockets Phone Grip And Stand - Floral Blush
previous / next
Pop it and lock it! PopSockets is the ultimate accessory for your phone. This stick ... Read More
10000271
$10.95

On The Go Game Pad

On The Go Game Pad
previous / next
This paper pad provides a little entertainment to have on the go. It will keep ... Read More
520033
$11.95

Motivation Pen Set

Set of 3
Motivation Pen Set
previous
A collection of three pens for three distinct purposes. Each ballpoint pen is printed with ... Read More
521422
$14.95

Christmas Stocking Stuffers

Fill all of the Christmas stockings with interesting and unique small gifts from Paper Source. Browse our stocking stuffers to get ideas for all of the men, women, and children in your life. We have plenty of gifts priced under $10 including the world's smallest Etch-A-Sketch and an pooping reindeer.

Arrow pointing to top