Up to 40% Off Personalized Stationery →
30% Off Paperless Post Holiday Cards →
Free Standard Shipping $60+ →
  • Go to slide 1
  • Go to slide 2
  • Go to slide 3
Login My Favorites

Cart

Your cart is empty

Stocking Stuffers

Find cute, funny & unique stocking stuffers and small gifts for the holidays! From festive socks to quirky surprises and useful finds, surprise them with a little something they’ll love.

Wrap & Accessories Wrap & Accessories
Gifts Gifts
Crafts Crafts
Party Party
Stocking Stuffers Stocking Stuffers
Greeting Cards Greeting Cards
Boxed Card Sets Boxed Card Sets
Photo Cards Photo Cards

Sort by

191 Results

Holiday Goose Plush ExclusiveHoliday Goose Plush Exclusive
Holiday Goose Plush Exclusive Sale price$24.99
Tinsel Tree Tayto Potato 8" Midi Mochi PlushTinsel Tree Tayto Potato 8" Midi Mochi Plush
Tinsel Tree Tayto Potato 8" Midi Mochi Plush Sale price$20.00
Hydrogel Face Masks- Pack of 5Hydrogel Face Masks- Pack of 5
Hydrogel Face Masks- Pack of 5Paper Source Sale price$34.99
Boogie Board Sketch Pals, Gingerbread PalBoogie Board Sketch Pals, Gingerbread Pal
Boogie Board Sketch Pals, Gingerbread Pal Sale price$19.99
Santa List NotepadSanta List Notepad
Santa List Notepad Sale price$12.50
Gingerbread Latte Butter Signature Dome SlimeGingerbread Latte Butter Signature Dome Slime
Gingerbread Latte Butter Signature Dome Slime Sale price$17.99
Grabie Sealed For Holiday Wax Seal KitGrabie Sealed For Holiday Wax Seal Kit
Grabie Sealed For Holiday Wax Seal Kit Sale price$19.99
Feline Festive Holiday Socks
Feline Festive Holiday Socks Sale price$9.99
Penguin Village Porcelain OrnamentPenguin Village Porcelain Ornament
Penguin Village Porcelain Ornament Sale price$24.99
Snow Animal Pens, 3 styles assorted
Snow Animal Pens, 3 styles assorted Sale price$3.99
Desktop TherapistDesktop Therapist
Desktop Therapist Sale price$29.50
Holiday Bear Tree Punching PenHoliday Bear Tree Punching Pen
Holiday Bear Tree Punching Pen Sale price$6.00
Meg the Gingerbread Woman - B&N ExclusiveMeg the Gingerbread Woman - B&N Exclusive
Meg the Gingerbread Woman - B&N Exclusive Sale price$29.99
Sassy Sayings Ceramic Magnets Set of 3Sassy Sayings Ceramic Magnets Set of 3
Sassy Sayings Ceramic Magnets Set of 3 Sale price$19.99
Holiday Icons Eraser Set of 6Holiday Icons Eraser Set of 6
Holiday Icons Eraser Set of 6 Sale price$9.99
Tree Snow Globe Novelty PenTree Snow Globe Novelty Pen
Tree Snow Globe Novelty Pen Sale price$8.99
Holiday Candle DuoHoliday Candle Duo
Holiday Candle Duo Sale price$25.00
5" Gia Gingerbread Girl Plush5" Gia Gingerbread Girl Plush
5" Gia Gingerbread Girl Plush Sale price$11.99
Perk Up Eye GelsPerk Up Eye Gels
Perk Up Eye Gels

Set of 5

Sale price$17.00
Ted the Gingerbread ManTed the Gingerbread Man
Ted the Gingerbread Man Sale price$29.99
Holiday Charm Bracelet with 5 CharmsHoliday Charm Bracelet with 5 Charms
Holiday Charm Bracelet with 5 Charms Sale price$12.99
Book Cover-Peppermint Stripes
Book Cover-Peppermint Stripes Sale price$24.95
Fuzzy Bow Socks
Fuzzy Bow SocksPaper Source Sale price$16.99
Five Minute Journal Green FloralFive Minute Journal Green Floral
Five Minute Journal Green Floral Sale price$33.00
Wacky Waving Inflatable Tube Elf
Wacky Waving Inflatable Tube Elf Sale price$15.95
Bear Fuzzy SockBear Fuzzy Sock
Bear Fuzzy Sock Sale price$16.99
Bah Humbug Metal Clip BookmarkBah Humbug Metal Clip Bookmark
Bah Humbug Metal Clip Bookmark Sale price$12.99
Satin Contour Eye Mask
Satin Contour Eye MaskPaper Source Sale price$24.99
Linen Sleep MaskLinen Sleep Mask
Linen Sleep MaskPaper Source Sale price$19.99
The Little Frog's Guide to Self-Care: Affirmations, Self-Love and Life Lessons According to the Internet's Beloved Mushroom FrogThe Little Frog's Guide to Self-Care: Affirmations, Self-Love and Life Lessons According to the Internet's Beloved Mushroom Frog
The Little Frog's Guide to Self-Care: Affirmations, Self-Love and Life Lessons According to the Internet's Beloved Mushroom Frog Sale price$11.99
MAGNA-TILES microMAGS Travel Set, 26-Piece Magnetic Construction Set, The ORIGINAL Magnetic Building BrandMAGNA-TILES microMAGS Travel Set, 26-Piece Magnetic Construction Set, The ORIGINAL Magnetic Building Brand
MAGNA-TILES microMAGS Travel Set, 26-Piece Magnetic Construction Set, The ORIGINAL Magnetic Building Brand Sale price$19.99
Starry Blue Knit BalaclavaStarry Blue Knit Balaclava
Starry Blue Knit Balaclava Sale price$29.99
uni One P. Asst. 2 CT
uni One P. Asst. 2 CT

Set of 2

Sale price$15.99
Itty Bitty Duffle-Beauty Sage
Itty Bitty Duffle-Beauty Sage Sale price$18.95
Calico Critters Cutie Collectibles -Very Berry Babies SeriesCalico Critters Cutie Collectibles -Very Berry Babies Series
Calico Critters Cutie Collectibles -Very Berry Babies Series Sale price$9.99
Festive Tree SquishyFestive Tree Squishy
Festive Tree Squishy Sale price$5.99
Jasmine Duo (Set Hand Cream + Roll-On)Jasmine Duo (Set Hand Cream + Roll-On)
Jasmine Duo (Set Hand Cream + Roll-On) Sale price$19.90
Midori Embroidery Bookmark Clip SquirrelMidori Embroidery Bookmark Clip Squirrel
Midori Embroidery Bookmark Clip Squirrel Sale price$10.99
Felt Holiday Mice, AssortedFelt Holiday Mice, Assorted
Felt Holiday Mice, AssortedPaper Source Sale price$14.99
The Screaming Christmas Goat: Ahhhhh!
The Screaming Christmas Goat: Ahhhhh! Sale price$14.95
Fred Use Your Noodle - Lasagna BookmarkFred Use Your Noodle - Lasagna Bookmark
Fred Use Your Noodle - Lasagna Bookmark Sale price$9.00
Cat Handwarmers 2-PackCat Handwarmers 2-Pack
Cat Handwarmers 2-PackPaper Source Sale price$16.99
Cozy Grip Socks, Pink Plaid
Cozy Grip Socks, Pink Plaid Sale price$14.95
Squiggly HairclipsSquiggly Hairclips
Squiggly HairclipsPaper Source Sale price$13.50
Hazel the Nutcracker Learn to Crochet KitHazel the Nutcracker Learn to Crochet Kit
Hazel the Nutcracker Learn to Crochet Kit Sale price$29.99
The Blue Bracelet SetThe Blue Bracelet Set
The Blue Bracelet Set Sale price$12.50
Reusable Makeup Cleansing Rounds 7pcReusable Makeup Cleansing Rounds 7pc
Reusable Makeup Cleansing Rounds 7pcPaper Source

Set of 7

Sale price$16.00
Garden Party Gel PensGarden Party Gel Pens
Garden Party Gel Pens

Set of 4

Sale price$18.50

BEST STOCKING STUFFERS 2026

Hang your stockings by the chimney with care, but don’t forget to fill them first with the best stocking stuffers from Paper Source! We have an amazing selection of cute, fun and quirky stocking stuffers to wow your spouses, children and colleagues this holiday season. From candy to toys to socks, our collection has the perfect little gifts for everyone on your list!

Stocking Stuffer Ideas for Everyone on Your List

Explore stocking stuffer ideas from Paper Source and find the best stocking stuffers for men and women. Whether you are looking for stocking stuffers for your wife, husband, kids, friends or coworkers, these gifts are the perfect little packages for slipping into stockings this holiday season.

Unique Stocking Stuffers for Adults & Kids

Shop self-care essentials such as face masks, manicure sets, essential oils and candles. Find cute jewelry and hair accessories such as bracelets, hairclips and fingernail stickers. Browse desk essentials such as desk calendars, journals, pen sets and more. Look through travel basics such as keychains, luggage tags, tech accessories and tote bags. Find stocking stuffers for kids such as cards, games and toys. We even have a wide selection of quirky stocking stuffers, sure to make your friends and family laugh this holiday season. Still not sure what to get? Look through our Holiday Gift Guide or purchase a Paper Source Gift Card!

The Best Stocking Stuffers for your Holiday Gift Exchange

Find the perfect stocking stuffers for your Holiday Gift Exchange, White Elephant or Secret Santa at Paper Source! Stocking stuffers are the perfect small gift for your holiday exchange and are great gifted on their own! You’ll have everyone trying to steal your gift! Put your stocking stuffer in a Holiday Treat Bags for an extra festive touch!

FAQ About Stocking Stuffers 2026

If you are searching for some good stocking fillers, here are a few great ideas:

  • Candy
  • Gift Cards
  • Small Games & Toys
  • Candles & Wellness Gifts
  • Socks, Scarves, & Gloves
  • 2027 Calendars, Planners and Journals
  • Books
  • Novelty mugs, Magnets & Keychains
  • Art Supplies

What traditionally goes in a stocking?

Traditionally stockings are filled with fruit, candy and toys or other small gifts.

How many gifts should be in a stocking?

While there is no set number as to the number of gifts that should go in your stocking, most stockings are filled with 3-5 small stocking stuffers.

Our Top Picks for Stocking Stuffers 2026

Wacky Waving Inflatable Tube Elf

MAGNA-TILES microMAGS Travel Set

Itty Bitty Duffle-Beauty Sage

Garden Party Gel Pens

Legami Scented Eraser - xoxo - Unicorn

Bookmark Paper - Moomin Gardening - Picnic Reading

You may also be interested in…

Kids Toys & Plush

Candles & Diffusers

Quirky Gifts